You're right, that's the standard spin that is disproven by evidence. Still used though.
You can point to the exact policy failing: http://www.kansascity.com/opinion/editorials/article6514956....
But the spin is more effective than the facts, so who cares.
1) The economy would grow and so would revenues 2) Cut spending: food stamps, social security, education, etc. But lets not mention defence.