News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by bshimmin on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:49PM (#9739902)
If you buy a house and pay off the mortgage, once you're older and don't want (or aren't able) to work any longer, you can live in your house for the cost of your utility bills. If you don't own a house, you still have to pay rent.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by bemmu on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:22PM (#9740188)
So basically if you make an investment, you'll be better off than not making one if everything goes well. I can agree with that.

But why a house? I could just as easily say that if you take a loan to get a McDonald's franchise, then once that's paid off you'll at least have that store. Or the same logic for any other investment.

And the counterargument would be that you don't want to be fully leveraged because there's some risk involved in that. In the case of a loan maybe something will go wrong and you won't be able to afford the payments. Or maybe a new opportunity arises and you don't want to live in that town anymore and need to sell, possibly at a loss.

Maybe I actually should go out and buy a house. I just get this feeling that I don't really fully understand all the risks involved in this decision.

Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by OneOneOneOne on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:28PM (#9740248)
Advice I give is to buy a house once the cost of owning the house is lower than rent. What I learned the hard way is to not buy more than you need.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by bshimmin on Thursday June 18, 2015 @02:14PM (#9740549)
You can't live in a McDonald's franchise. You can obviously sell it and buy, er, a house though!
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by scarmig on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:51PM (#9739915)
Alternatively, you could save the $200k down payment, invest it, and invest any difference in lower monthly expenses to end up with a pretty nice nest egg after 30 years, and live off the capital gains.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by vidarh on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:20PM (#9740171)
Consider the purchase a hedge against faster house price growth. For the last 7 years, I've paid 1.09% interest on my mortgage (I'm in the UK; Bank of England rates are at 0.5%), while house prices have kept increasing . Which means that with repayment, I'm paying half as much as I would if I was renting. The rest is free for me to invest...

It very much depends on where you live, and how the markets develop what pays off. But I'm very happy I bought.

If you buy your house as an investment, it's a big risk. If you buy it as a hedge, and intend to stay long term, it's generally pretty cheap insurance against getting priced out of the area you want to live in.

Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by scarmig on Thursday June 18, 2015 @02:14PM (#9740548)
The answer is always very much it depends, of course! And I'm in the process of purchasing a house myself, so I clearly don't think it's an insane decision.

It is, however, more complicated than the train of thought that says, "After 30 years, you'll own your own place, instead of having thrown away hundreds of thousands of dollars to a landlord."

Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by stank345 on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:54PM (#9739944)
You mean a $20k down payment, right? Most of us aren't buying million dollar homes...
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by guelo on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:59PM (#9739987)
Most of us aren't buying $100k homes either. National median home price is $219k. In the Sillicon Valley area it's $900k.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by stank345 on Friday June 19, 2015 @10:32AM (#9744989)
Yeah, I just figured it was a typo. It begs the question though: what percentage of us are putting 20% down?
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by calbear81 on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:59PM (#9739989)
$20k would mean a $100k house which is hard to buy in most mid-size and larger cities unless you're willing to live a bit more remotely.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by scarmig on Thursday June 18, 2015 @02:11PM (#9740528)
200k is downright ordinary in the Bay Area, unfortunately. But, yeah, some places have lower typical down payments, but rents tend to also decline commensurately with home prices. Roughly speaking.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by tootie on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:57PM (#9739969)
Not just the downpayment. If your monthlies are lower you're earning interest on those savings as well.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by delbel on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:56PM (#9739966)
You're going to be in a big surprise when your property tax bill comes to mostly fund trillion dollar public retirement pension accounts. Property taxes of typical city can run up to $200 or $400 a month.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by OneOneOneOne on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:03PM (#9740020)
Rent will increase to reflect that change.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by log_n on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:23PM (#9740203)
But when you rent you have the option to move to another city if you don't like how your tax dollars are being managed. Especially when you are retired/unemployed and thus don't have to worry about living close to your job. You don't even have to move far necessarily depending on the type of tax you are trying to avoid.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by vonmoltke on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:50PM (#9740421)
Moving is a very disruptive life change, becoming more disruptive the longer you have been at your current location. It isn't something to be undertaken lightly, so it would probably take a significant move in property taxes to induce one to move.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by subsection1h on Thursday June 18, 2015 @04:05PM (#9741274)
Moving isn't very disruptive for me. Since 1995 I've moved once every couple of years and have lived in 6 states and 12 cities. Working remotely has made this super easy.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by vonmoltke on Friday June 19, 2015 @10:18AM (#9744904)
First, you are the exception. Second, moving frequently actually makes it less disruptive to a point because you are not sinking deep roots in one particular area.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by OneOneOneOne on Thursday June 18, 2015 @04:55PM (#9741559)
Sounds like fun.

Not trying to be nosy but did you make the move with children? (How did you help them adjust?)

Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by bane on Thursday June 18, 2015 @02:26PM (#9740624)
Amazingly, when you own property, you can sell it and also move to another city.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by mfringel on Thursday June 18, 2015 @05:16PM (#9741662)
I'm curious... how many times have you moved because you felt your tax dollars weren't managed appropriately?
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by Domenic_S on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:23PM (#9740207)
Why would someone who's ostensibly been paying property tax for 30 years suddenly be surprised on the 31st year?
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by vbezhenar on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:37PM (#9740329)
Depends on country, I guess. In Kazakhstan I pay $10 taxes for my house per year and around $50 per month for all bills. Not that much.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by OneOneOneOne on Thursday June 18, 2015 @05:01PM (#9741595)
Really!?! That seems pretty low. Is there a different rate if you live in your house? Even though I don't like property taxes I think that without fewer individuals would own their house in the US since corporate ownership of houses would have a lower cost.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by rbobby on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:06PM (#9740050)
Just to jump on... houses require maintenance. About 1% of the house value per year (roof needs replacing, hvac needs fixing, etc etc). If you skimp on maintenance the value of the house declines, possibly a lot (a leaking roof or basement can cause serious damage over time).
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by OneOneOneOne on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:23PM (#9740196)
I think this is true for basic maintenance. Repairing something broken or about to cause problems like a roof is necessary. Beyond that I've noticed that house price seems to depend more on location than overall condition. There doesn't seem much financial incentive for homeowners to update their house.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by warkdarrior on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:51PM (#9739913)
And property taxes.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by Someone1234 on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:58PM (#9739975)
And routine maintenance and repair (e.g. complete roof replacements every 20 or so years).

Owning a home is super expensive even without a mortgage. So even going into retirement with a paid off house, you'll still want to set aside a decent pot of gold to keep that house "going" even aside from utilities (some of which are optional anyway, like cable/landline).

Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by api on Thursday June 18, 2015 @12:53PM (#9739935)
"and pay off the mortgage"

In most large metro areas this is impossible for ordinary mortals without a liquidity event or a very high income.

We are still very much in a housing bubble being driven by insanely cheap money -- near-zero or even <0 effective central bank interest rates. The only places housing is affordable are places where there are no jobs.

Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by hga on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:00PM (#9739993)
"No jobs" strikes me as too strong a statement.

Too few jobs from too few employers, especially specialized one like ours, is probably more accurate. And therefore a potential need to move to another area where there is a job needs to be factored in.

Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by claar on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:05PM (#9740043)
I don't understand what you mean. Paying off the mortgage is a big reason to buy vs rent. If you can afford the mortgage payment, then in 30 years, you own the house.

If this is impossible for ordinary mortals, how are ordinary mortals buying houses?

I ask as a small city homeowner, so forgive my ignorance of the metro area real estate world.

Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by ryandrake on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:28PM (#9740245)
I don't think "ordinary mortals" in, for example, the Bay Area, consider their mortgage something they'll ever pay down completely. 30 years may as well be forever, and a lot of people I know refi over and over to stay on the treadmill. This is why in a market downturn, people end up underwater, losing the house.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by a_c_s on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:21PM (#9740179)
"ordinary mortals" who can make their payments on a 30 year mortgage will have it paid off in 30 years.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by bshimmin on Thursday June 18, 2015 @02:12PM (#9740540)
Exactly this - if banks didn't think people could pay off mortgages, at least some chunk of the people, they wouldn't be offering them.

I agree that buying a house in central London (for example) is probably outside the reach of mere mortals, but I think that problem occurs several steps before the "paying off the mortgage" bit applies!

Many very interesting replies to my initial comment; it certainly is useful to see things from a different perspective.

Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by hga on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:05PM (#9740045)
One thing you can do while still somewhat physically able, or perhaps with getting help from neighbors, is a large garden.

Right now I'm living with my father, and we have some neighbors who moved here after Hostess died. They have a big garden, which my father and I help with in various ways; they get a lower cost of living, we get wonderfully fresh veggies.

Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by peter303 on Thursday June 18, 2015 @01:23PM (#9740205)
In some areas the 3% property tax approaches the 3% mortgage rate. Your housing costs are only halved by paying off.
Re:Is It Better to Rent or Buy? by vonmoltke on Thursday June 18, 2015 @02:00PM (#9740476)
Those aren't equivalent. Mortgage payments include principal as well as interest. Interest is only paid on the outstanding balance, not the full, current value of the house. Even at 3% APR, the mortgage payment is typically 2 - 3 times the amortized tax payment. The actual separation depends significantly on mortgage term, value financed, value movement since purchase, and homestead laws.