Everyone talks about rdio, spotify, upcoming apple music, etc... But Youtube already seems to have unlimited free streaming of music + videos, with what appears to be universal selection.
Is it just the case that nobody knows this, so it's not a big deal, but everyone is going to know about Apple Music?
Total streaming revenue might realistically drop by 30-50%, assuming a large fraction of Spotify etc users cancel while Apple Music is free.
Catalog sales will take a hit too, a large hit for iTunes sales. Probably less for other channels.
And artists with new records coming out now will likely take the biggest hit. On the other hand, no one releases records in the summer.
October begins the new indie release year, so maybe the timing is almost as good as it could be.
Don't get me wrong, I don't want to listen to Taylor Swift and Jason Derulo all day long either, but if some indie band is so obscure and hip that it can't pay the bills for 3 months....I dunno....maybe they were never that good?
No band deserves some kind of regular income. Nobody does, in our society.
If I listen to your stuff for 3 months, for free, and like it, why would I stop after my trial expires? Heck, with a free trial, I'm more likely to discover your hip obscure super-cool indie band and more likely to support them later.
I specifically mentioned that as an option - hence why this is a much larger concern for labels than artists (though I'm sure it's a concern for artists as well). Also keep in mind that a live tour takes months to pull together. Apple hasn't given artists that sort of lead time.
And all of that having been said: in what other industry is it normal to say, "Well, if you can't handle a full quarter of decimated revenues dropped on your head with weeks notice it was never meant to be"? Many SMBs couldn't weather that storm. That doesn't mean they're fundamentally broken.
While the major labels can weather the resulting loss of revenue, losing a significant number of your sales from the world's largest music store for a full quarter is likely to put some indie labels and artists in a position where they're unable to pay their bills. Apple Music's impact will likely ripple out to sales at other stores, too, which will worsen its impact on revenues. And while artists can at least fall back on touring revenue, small labels don't have that option.
I can see why labels and artists are upset. Apple Music's free trial may very well have a ruinous effect on their livelihoods.