News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Encrypting Windows Hard Drives by Tomte on Tuesday June 16, 2015 @12:21AM (#9723801)
Especially egregious was the episode where he misunderstood the "xkcd password scheme" and lashed out against it in his blog, and then kept on defending his flawed opinion against all explanations.

That did a lot of damage to all attempts to teach password security to laymen.

OTOH he was one of the first "famous" security people to publicly recommend writing down passwords.

So all in all he is certainly a net win.

Re:Encrypting Windows Hard Drives by tptacek on Tuesday June 16, 2015 @12:24AM (#9723805)
Cryptography Engineering is a good book (with some flaws).

Schneier is much less of a factor in real-world crypto than generalist developers think he is.

I feel bad blaming him for it; it's not his fault that people who don't do serious work in cryptography have made him a cryptographic folk hero. On the other hand: there are still people using Blowfish because his name is on it, so maybe I don't feel bad blaming him.

Re:Encrypting Windows Hard Drives by Tomte on Tuesday June 16, 2015 @12:36AM (#9723851)
Oh, certainly (I was just talking about passwords)!

Cryptography Engineering is something I hold very dear and have lent out to colleagues. Very well written, so it's an enjoyable read. And a good length, not a thousand pages tome.

My main problem with Schneier at this point is that he pivotted (Ha! This is HN after all...) from cryptography and technical analyses to political commentary. And I haven't found him very convincing in that regard. Even annoying at times.