Re:LastPass Security Notice
by StavrosK on Monday June 15, 2015 @05:38PM
(#9722290)
There are multiple problems with this approach. SHA is way too fast, some site is always going to have Auth requirements that won't be the same as the ones you have set (one service wants mandatory special characters, one wants mandatory alphanumeric only), and, most importantly, you can't change the passwords unless you change the master password and remember which you used where.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:LastPass Security Notice
by dragontamer on Monday June 15, 2015 @07:01PM
(#9722734)
Fair point. But proper key strengthening is a well-known solution to this well-known problem. The general methodology of using password-safe hash + master password + domain name is useful.
As you note, SHA isn't appropriate for this purpose. PBKDF2-strenghtened SHA, SCrypt, BCrypt and other functions should be used.