News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by ZanyProgrammer on Monday June 15, 2015 @02:26PM (#9721065)
Well, that's a very Protestant, Whiggish view of things. Catholic Emancipation in the UK wasn't complete until 1829 for example. The idea of the Glorious Revolution as ushering in a democratic and free era was really only true if you were an Anglican, slightly less so for Dissenters, and very much less so for Catholics (both in Britain and Ireland).

I think a lot of those crises in Europe were just continuations of the Reformation in many respects.

Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by btilly on Monday June 15, 2015 @03:09PM (#9721337)
I deliberately stated a very mild form of the idea because that is what actually seems to have been accepted relatively early on. The stronger idea that we should actually treat people with different beliefs as we would like to be treated in turn took a lot longer.

For instance the lot of many faiths in the UK started improving with the toleration act of 1668. Why were Catholics excluded? Because there had been actual attempts to kill English kings (most famously the Gunpowder plot) and the Pope kept the stance that Catholics should try to overthrow England's government. The Catholic church maintained that position until 1766. In response, England started treating Catholics better. First in various colonies, and then for England itself with the 1778 Papists Act. Something much closer to equality arrived as you noted in 1829.

Atheists got worse treatment. For example they could not testify in UK courts until 1870. And even though atheist Charles Bradlaugh started getting regularly elected in 1880, and he was not allowed to be a member of the House of Commons until 1886.

The US was fundamentally no better, and in practice worse despite the Bill of Rights. For example it was not until 1961 that the Supreme Court ruled that atheists could not be barred by their non-belief from things like being a notary public.

But for all that we can legitimately criticize about the way these ideas were put in practice, they are worlds better than when Henry VIII took land from Catholics for not recognizing his marriage, his daughter Mary killed Protestants for not recognizing the Pope, the Pope in return tried to convince Catholics to try to kill Elizabeth I, and James 1. Both then passed various laws penalizing Catholics in retaliation.

Remember the Bloody Question? "If the Pope should invade England, which would you support? The Queen or the Pope?" Killing people who said, "the Pope" was pretty brutal, but reflected political reality.

Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by amyjess on Monday June 15, 2015 @03:24PM (#9721417)
> The US was fundamentally no better, and in practice worse despite the Bill of Rights

You also have to remember that until the Fourteenth Amendment was passed, the Bill of Rights only applied to acts of Congress ("Congress shall make no law...") and not to state legislatures.

Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by btilly on Monday June 15, 2015 @04:24PM (#9721831)
You have oversimplified the history. After the Fourteenth Amendment arrived, there was considerable confusion about what it actually meant for state laws. And it took a long time for the very complex details to get ironed out. That is why the case I pointed to was nearly a century after the 14th amendment was passed.

See http://tenthamendmentcenter.com/2012/03/12/the-14th-amendmen... for a detailed (and admittedly somewhat opinionated) history of this topic. And see http://constitution.findlaw.com/amendment14.html to start digging in on exactly how complex the current interpretation of the 14th amendment actually is.

Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by amyjess on Tuesday June 16, 2015 @12:03PM (#9726774)
> You have oversimplified the history. After the Fourteenth Amendment arrived, there was considerable confusion about what it actually meant for state laws. And it took a long time for the very complex details to get ironed out. That is why the case I pointed to was nearly a century after the 14th amendment was passed.

I'm not disagreeing with you.

I was just placing a hard earliest point where the Bill of Rights could apply to the states, not saying that it was immediately interpreted as such as soon as it was ratified.

Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by selimthegrim on Monday June 15, 2015 @06:23PM (#9722522)
Google 'Slaughterhouse cases', and 'Colfax massacre', and then curse Louisiana for being the rock which incorporation stubbed its toe on.
Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by pdonis on Monday June 15, 2015 @08:12PM (#9723062)
> the Bill of Rights only applied to acts of Congress ("Congress shall make no law...")

That specific language only appears in the First Amendment. Other amendments were taken to apply to the states well before the Fourteenth; for example, there is case law from state courts from the first half of the 19th century dealing with how states interpret the Second Amendment, which would be meaningless if that Amendment were not held to apply to the states.

Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by afarrell on Monday June 15, 2015 @08:58PM (#9723193)
I would be very interested in reading that case law if you can dig it up for us.
Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by btilly on Monday June 15, 2015 @09:31PM (#9723305)
Most of the cases that are usually cited were, upon close reading, decided based on clauses in various state constitutions. The one exception that I am aware of is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nunn_v._Georgia where the decision was made in a state court and hence was only binding for that state.

By contrast in the early years after the 14th was passed, the Supreme Court stated in both https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_v._Cruikshank and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Presser_v._Illinois that the 2nd amendment was only a restriction on what the federal government could do. State and local regulation was unaffected.

Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by amyjess on Tuesday June 16, 2015 @12:01PM (#9726753)
> Most of the cases that are usually cited were, upon close reading, decided based on clauses in various state constitutions.

Yes. One of the arguments against adding the Bill of Rights to the Constitution was that the states already had similar clauses. That was the reason why they're amendments and not part of the original Constitution, in fact. The argument went something like this:

"Here's your new Constitution! Please ratify it."

"Um, there's no Bill of Rights."

"Well, the states already have Bills of Rights."

"Yeah, that sounds like a loophole waiting to happen. Add a Bill of Rights or I'm not ratifying it."

"Fine, fine. I promise that if you ratify it, we'll amend it with a Bill of Rights the first chance we get."

Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by ZanyProgrammer on Monday June 15, 2015 @03:20PM (#9721403)
And yet your own hereditary monarch in 2015 has to be an Anglican.
Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by JonnieCache on Monday June 15, 2015 @03:28PM (#9721439)
That's been recently changed. Catholics are now allowed, and men no longer take precedence over women.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perth_Agreement

The whole thing is still, to quote Doug Stanhope, "some dungeons and dragons bullshit", but at least its not immutable even today.

Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by grkvlt on Monday June 15, 2015 @05:40PM (#9722297)
Nope, those Married to Catholics are now allowed, but Catholics themselves? Definitely not. And Jews? Muslims? Forget it! "the requirement for the sovereign to be in communion with the Church of England remained"
Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by tsotha on Tuesday June 16, 2015 @01:34AM (#9723983)
Well, it's kind of problematic if the head of a church doesn't actually belong to it.
Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by walterbell on Monday June 15, 2015 @03:50PM (#9721577)
> at least its not immutable even today

We've since moved to immutable trade agreements.

Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by TeMPOraL on Monday June 15, 2015 @04:02PM (#9721670)
And here I was thinking immutable == good. I guess functional programming doesn't work well with nation states.
Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by mikeash on Monday June 15, 2015 @05:10PM (#9722147)
Laws actually resemble immutable data structures pretty strongly! When a law is repealed, it's not simply erased, but rather a new law is passed that says "this law repeals that old law." When a law is changed, it's not rewritten, but a new law is passed that says "Section X of law Y is changed to read, 'blah blah blah.'" The full law in effect at any given time is just the sum of all those changes.

End digression!

Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by btilly on Monday June 15, 2015 @04:26PM (#9721850)
Which hereditary monarch would that be?

I was born in California.

Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by tim333 on Tuesday June 16, 2015 @08:32AM (#9725242)
England et al, I think.
Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by ZanyProgrammer on Monday June 15, 2015 @03:32PM (#9721466)
"However, the ban on Catholics and other non-Protestants becoming sovereign and the requirement for the sovereign to be in communion with the Church of England remained."
Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by bgilroy26 on Monday June 15, 2015 @02:31PM (#9721097)
Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by DubiousPusher on Monday June 15, 2015 @03:34PM (#9721474)
Thanks for posting this. That essay is fantastic. It's actually a perfect complement to that article and the discussion happening in this entire thread.

It beautifully highlights the modern historian's crisis.

You cannot distill history into a framework because any unique set of events seem to be reproduced somewhere else in history with different outcomes.

You must distill history into a framework otherwise it's impossible to reason about and understand.

Re:The General Crisis of the 17th Century by benbreen on Monday June 15, 2015 @04:10PM (#9721739)
This seems like a good spot to link to one of my favorite essays on the theme you've raised here - the historian and philosopher Isaiah Berlin (of the hedgehog and the fox fame) on "The Concept of Scientific History." (Short version: he argues that there's no such thing). By the way, I'm happy to see such an interesting discussion of my favorite historical topic on HN - thanks.

http://berlin.wolf.ox.ac.uk/published_works/cc/scihist.pdf