Re:Philae comet lander wakes up
by pjc50 on Sunday June 14, 2015 @05:56PM
(#9716464)
The worst case is rather nasty though: the rendering of a large area uninhabitable and unusable for agriculture. There aren't a lot of sites in Europe where you can site a nuclear reactor far enough away to avoid either evacuating a major city or losing an agricultural region. There is no "away", as people like to say about rubbish.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Compare that large area to that consumed by business-as-usual for the alternatives though. E.g. the area rendered uninhabitable/unusable for hydro power is larger (per kwh). (Of course many people find a reservoir more attractive than a radioactive zone, but both are equally unusable for habitation or agriculture)
area rendered uninhabitable/unusable for hydro power is larger
That can be true of reservoirs (Lake Mead is huge) but isn't necessarily. UK's largest reservoir is https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kielder_Water at a mere 2 miles by <6 miles, supporting a piddly 6MW (yes, megawatts not gigawatts, I had to double check that). But that's subject to planning permission in a way that radioactive exclusion zones aren't. The UK suffered from Chernobyl fallout for years: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/uknews/1514492/20-years-on-B...
It's not that nuclear power is bad on average, it's just that the worst case scenarios affect potentially huge areas.
A clarification to the point about Kielder's power generation: Kielder reservoir is primarily for regulating the water supply, rather than power generation. There are many hydro-electric plants in the UK generating much more power.