News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Go is doomed to succeed by ngrilly on Sunday June 14, 2015 @11:52AM (#9715298)
I agree with you that the lack of generics is a weakness of Go. Even Rob Pike agrees [1]. But some of your arguments are just plain wrong:

- `go generate` was never designed as a way to bring generics to Go.

- Most Go programmers are not "ignorant of basic functional programming". They use FP in other languages, and even in Go which has first-class functions, higher-order functions and closures. But it's true that the lack of generics severely limits the usage of FP techniques in Go.

- Go partisans don't "recommend" to stuff everything in interface{} and use "blind" type assertions everywhere. They even recommend the contrary. Give me a link to the Go official documentation that recommends that and I'll revisit my position.

To be clear, just like you, I sometimes miss generics in Go, especially when I'd like to use some FP techniques. But for me, it's just an inconvenience. It sounds like for you it's a showstopper and I understand that. But I don't think that using words like "junk", "stupid" or "dumb" helps in making your point.

I hope, and I'm confident, that the Go team will find a way to add some form or type parametricity that fits well with the overall language.

[1] http://blog.golang.org/slices

Re:Why Go is doomed to succeed by eropple on Sunday June 14, 2015 @07:45PM (#9716742)
> `go generate` was never designed as a way to bring generics to Go.

Unix was designed to port Spacewar. What's that got to do with anything?

> Most Go programmers are not "ignorant of basic functional programming".

That doesn't match my experience. The overwhelming majority of Go people I know, and the loudest advocates to whom I am exposed, seem to regard functional programming as a nothing. Your experience may differ.

> Go partisans don't "recommend" to stuff everything in interface{} and use "blind" type assertions everywhere.

Again, that doesn't match my experience; this was literally recommended to me by a senior-level Google engineer. To his credit, he suggested instead using `go generate` as an alternative. (Because that's better. =/ )

> I don't think that using words like "junk", "stupid" or "dumb" helps in making your point.

Completely fair criticism. But let me put it this way: I view Go, and the terminally blinkered Rob Pike, and his disciples, to be so obviously and monstrously disastrous to what I do for a living that those were the remains after a pretty heavy dose of editing and self-censorship.

I could tell you how I actually feel if you'd like. =)