The interesting thing is that historically it seems that part of the reason was all the non-firm stuff that was needed. So doing payroll, providing benefits, managing coverage when people went on vacation, but those things arose in a large part because of labor unions. So as labor union's influence has declined, so has the value of the "package" provided by a firm to the employee, and the value equation of contractor or employee can more easily swing back over to contractor.
That is just such an awesomly interesting thing to think about. Thanks for the reference.
[1] http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1468-0335.1937....
http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2012/05/coase_on_extern.htm...
> If Google contract out the development of blue sky ideas to small companies or individuals and that yields products like gmail, that would be a sign. So far though, it's in house or acquisition (a form of contracting?) for really important things.
Blue-sky research is the classic example of the sort of stuff that is particularly hard to build a market around, hence most such research is publicly financed (shielded within universities and government labs) or privately financed by huge, private pseudo-governments like IBM, Microsoft, Bell, etc.
The fact that venture capital has allowed the market to compete with firms for certain kinds of "short term blue-sky research" (i.e., research that is very high risk, although still relatively short time-to-payoff) is certainly a great development. But that doesn't mean we should expect other blue-sky research to be the first area where the technological suppression of transaction costs allows markets to displace firms. Rather, it seems to me that the conventional wisdom is still mostly correct, and we should expect work that is more easily measurable than research to be freed from big firms first.
See also economist Robin Hanson for arguments and data that typical firm size will increase in the future, technology not withstanding:
http://www.overcomingbias.com/2013/09/expect-bigger-orgs.htm...
[2] I wrote a similar comment once, doubtlessly channeling Coase: http://slatestarcodex.com/2014/09/24/book-review-red-plenty/...
[1] Example of a Yellow Cab "non-job" posting: http://www.yellowcabaustin.com/driver.aspx
Shipping in the early "age of the sail" was usually controlled and operated by monarchs or crown backed monopolies. The task was suited to this structure at the time. One big, expensive & risky journey. Technology has shifted this around a bunch of time before and after that time then. Before the medieval collapse of european trade those same routes were alive and well (eg Italy to China) but were handled by a "market" of camel drivers, corsairs, merchants, markets and who knows what all along the spice and silk "roads."
Transaction costs still played a big role and technology dictated the structure of the economy. Along the silk road items could be traded dozens or hundreds of times over years before reaching users who had no idea what strange distant people made them. Beautiful, but inefficient relative to a single flotilla traveling the whole way.
The internet has done these things too. eBay enabled tiny traders and decentralised retail. Amazon concentrated and centralised retail. This is normal creative destruction and it doesn't seem to have an obviously dominant current.
It seems to me that this is fact and metric picking.
OTOH, maybe those stats on "contractors" is indicative of some shift in our labour market conventions. Who knows.
Notice how all contractors are being shown NDAs as standard now. This is the replacement for employees having job security for keeping shut about the knowledge they have.
Now, sign an NDA and you secure the knowledge with legal threats and chilling effects. It works.
http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2012/05/coase_on_extern.htm...
IE, why aren't we all contractors selling the services that we do at companies to each other? In a free market people can bargain to achieve more efficient economic outcomes than a centralised economy can achieve using prices. Why shouldn't this principle apply to firms? Why are firms run like a Soviet dictatorship with a hierarchy and planning?
His answer was "transaction costs.^" The cost of organising every activity that requires more than one person, negotiating terms and all the rest are bigger than the benefits.
The examples of contracting in this article (eg uber) are essentially market creators. I think the way to think about this trend (if it is a meaningful trend and not just a way of bypassing pesky restrictive labour conventions) is 'markets replacing firms' not 'contractor replacing employees.' If that is really the trend, I would expect to see average company size shrink and thus far, it is not.
If Google contract out the development of blue sky ideas to small companies or individuals and that yields products like gmail, that would be a sign. So far though, it's in house or acquisition (a form of contracting?) for really important things.
^Economists have an enormous tolerance for dealing with big hairy concepts like "transaction costs" without unpacking them. I personally that in addition to (or within... damned economists) 'transaction costs' is human beings' inherent skill at operating as a group with all sorts of unnamed dynamics replacing the quid quo pro. If you have an economy instead of a group that people feel a part of, you lose all that.