News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google’s Monastic Vision for the Future of Work by vidarh on Sunday June 14, 2015 @10:38AM (#9715051)
It's infuriating until it prevents your neighbour from building a chemical factory right next to your house.

Like it or not, what you build often substantially impacts your neighbours.

Re:Google’s Monastic Vision for the Future of Work by ams6110 on Sunday June 14, 2015 @02:06PM (#9715779)
That doesn't tend to be what happens though. Factories need a lot of land, and they don't want to pay residential market rates for it, and current owners will want to maintain their property values. In a free market, the self-interest of current property owners and developers tends to self-regulate. The government then operates as more of an enforcer of private covenants and restrictions.

http://www.businessweek.com/the_thread/hotproperty/archives/...

Re:Google’s Monastic Vision for the Future of Work by vidarh on Sunday June 14, 2015 @05:28PM (#9716392)
It doesn't tend to be what happens any more because pretty much every developed country in the world, and many underdeveloped countries, have planning and zoning frameworks that creates severe obstacles to it.

The idea that cost prevents it is a fantasy. It may prevent it in your neighbourhood, and it may prevent some of the most extreme situations, but there are plenty of areas where I live (London suburb) where factories etc. and residential neighbourhood are right next door to each other, and where the land costs are equivalent and it would not at all be a cost problem for many "objectionable" businesses to set up shop right next door to your house if zoning allowed it.

True, factories generally get quickly squeezed out of the inner cores of large cities, but residential and industrial areas often collide in the poorer parts of towns.

The example of Houston is interesting, but not that relevant in the overall scheme of things, given that Houston is very low density for a city, and low density and according reduced competition for space certainly makes it less attractive for people to fight battles over land use.

Despite that, let me quote the addendum:

>Right after I posted the above item I got an email from Nancy Sarnoff, a reporter for the Houston Chronicle, pointing out that land use remains a very live issue in Houston. Mayor Bill White, for one, is trying to stop construction of a 23-story high-rise in a neighborhood of single-family houses.

Re:Google’s Monastic Vision for the Future of Work by ougawouga on Sunday June 14, 2015 @10:41AM (#9715058)
Ok, something with noxious elements, yes. (Although I think it should be private neighborhood organizations to prevent this, not government).

All they wanted to build was a couple of office building and bike path.

Re:Google’s Monastic Vision for the Future of Work by vidarh on Sunday June 14, 2015 @10:55AM (#9715093)
> Although I think it should be private neighborhood organizations to prevent this

How? Here's a way for me to speculate in this:

- Buy properties around the edge of said private neighborhood, set up all kinds of highly offensive things all surrounding the neighbourhood.

- Buy up properties in said neighbourhood as the price drops until I can get effective control of said organization.

- Remove the aforementioned offensive things and wait for property prices to rice again.

> All they wanted to build was a couple of office building and bike path.

Which impacts policing needs, fire services, traffic, public transport, garbage collections, postal services, and many others. It is also likely to have indirect effects on the local housing market, and through that an effect on local schools, hospitals and others.

There's no such thing as just a couple of office buildings when it comes to urban planning.

Re:Google’s Monastic Vision for the Future of Work by ougawouga on Sunday June 14, 2015 @09:15PM (#9716970)
I'm not proposing abolishing the courts, so presumably the highly hypothetical scheme you've just described world be litigated in court.

Your second argument, based on logistics, is much stronger and bears consideration.

Re:Google’s Monastic Vision for the Future of Work by vidarh on Monday June 15, 2015 @04:32AM (#9718135)
The highly hypothetical scheme I just described would be legal absent government planning regulations so there'd be nothing to litigate.
Re:Google’s Monastic Vision for the Future of Work by dragonwriter on Sunday June 14, 2015 @10:54AM (#9715091)
Traffic impacts that are created by increasing occupancy faster than new infrastructure can be built have adverse impacts on everyone using the transport infrastructure just like a polluting industry has an adverse impact on the area (also, it has a pollution impact, whether or not infrastructure is adequate, but that's probably generally not as big of a concern.) So, scale can make new office space a noxious impact, and the article seems to clearly indicate that a preexisting overall scale limit was applied and Google, who had asked for most of it, got far less, and LinkedIn got the lion's share.