Re:When small meets large, small almost always wins
by SixSigma on Saturday June 13, 2015 @02:59PM
(#9712163)
What IBM noticed (or rather Louis V. Gerstner did) was that companies didn't buy computers to do payroll, they bought solutions to solving the payroll problem, which happened to eventually be computers.
And IBM were going broke trying to sell their computers instead of the best solutions, which they changed: even if that was on competitor's hardware or software.
Its true that when new technology enters the market, it creates an opportunity for the markets to be recontextualized in terms of that technology. Sometimes the incumbents embrace it, sometimes they don't. Mark's example of IBM is interesting by as much by what it omits as what it leaves in.
The DEC, Data General, Etc. growth of minicomputers came at IBM's expense of market share, but microcomputers were dominated by IBM (there is a reason it was the IBM PC and IBM PC compatibles for so long). The outcome of a new technology "meeting" a large incumbent is rarely predictable, and so a poor basis for establishing a "law" or even a reasonable insight.
The thing that I have always observed is that history doesn't repeat itself so much as there are capabilities that people want (services or products) and as the economics of those products or services can be improved by re-implementation in new technology, that technology takes over the implementation role for people.
For example small business has to do payroll, which they started on ledgers, then moved to punch card machines, then to computers, large, mini, and then micro, and then to service bureaus like ADP. This had nothing to do with history repeating itself and everything to do with the overhead cost of running payroll and keeping in compliance with all of the various labor laws.
Perhaps a more actionable observation is that when ever a change to a good or service is enabled by technology which allows it to be provided at the same price with a higher margin, or a lower price with the same margin, that technology change will push out the older technology. If the incumbent doesn't see it or can't act on the change there is an opportunity to capture market share.
Using that observation to translate Uber's success, Uber is using two innovations, independent drivers who own their own cars (arguably the more important change), and a sales protocol based on smart phones to do the same thing taxis have done for centuries. In so doing they can deliver a taxi service at the same price as current services but with better margins, or at a lower price with the same margins. So they capture market share, the incumbent is constrained in their response by regulation and is making changes there but until they do, Uber succeeds. Small isn't meeting "large" rather the service is getting reshaped by the available technology to lower (or sometimes shift) costs.