Re:Signify: Securing OpenBSD from Us to You
by quesera on Saturday June 13, 2015 @08:47PM
(#9713365)
Sure, I'm with you there. I was surprised to learn that NSA held patents at all.
It looks like NSA bought their ECC patents (the ones they license on the forelinked ECC PLA page) from Certicom. I'm still confused as to why NSA would buy a portfolio of patents and then license them restrictively (albeit at no cost).
Just seems a weird thing for a govt agency to do. Not suspicious or nefarious. Just weird.
This covers more or less everything a normal developer would ever do with elliptic curves.
Is there some wacky curve nobody uses that is patent-encumbered, or for which the point multiplication formula is based on patented math code? Maybe. Is there some wacky protocol --- not ECDH, not ECDSA, not EdDSA --- that's similarly encumbered. Yes! For instance: you need a license from Certicom to safely deploy ECMQV. NSA likes ECMQV, and licensed it.
You are not going to use MQV.
The same thing is true of conventional multiplicative group DH and RSA: there are variants and wacky protocols that are patented. Nobody uses them, nobody cares. They're the same kind of patent minefield as putting a shopping cart on a web page is: somebody somewhere has some godawful paper on it maybe, but you can't avoid it and still have a career.
The specifics of this situation aren't very complicated, but they're just complicated enough for people to spread mistrust of curve software. You've gotten a pageful of that on this thread. That's sad, because curve software is much more secure than RSA/DH. Every new system that requires public key crypto should be using curves.