You've just stated exactly my point!!! Not everybody that identifies with GG has malicious motivations, they're just "useful idiots" who need to think more critically about the statements they ingest. Hence my complaint about over-generalization: if you outright vilify people and call them names, they'll only get defensive and be less likely to consider critiques.
> Yeah, Nathan Grayson totes had to flee from his home and completely uproot his life.
I never meant to imply that the distribution was equal, and I acknowledged previously that there were lots of goons acting completely reprehensibly ("Now, there probably are sexist feelings at the root of many of their members' concerns").
I have stopped entertaining the notions of people who want to hurt my friends, and the people who want to defend them. Changing minds is a nice-to-have, but putting a stop to the bad behavior is a necessity. So at this point I think that it is sufficient to beat them. Which has already happened; they've already, individually and in aggregate, lost the battle to dominate the industry, to freeze out people who want to cater to people who aren't young white males. The GamerGate people will have their sinecures and their friendly developers (which is why the shirt-rending screaming about "SJWs" is hilarious, it's not like the industry is going to stop making games for young white males), but as a whole, they've lost, and I'm okay with not really making nice-nice to them as they fade to irrelevance.
Seriously, if you're ignoring one side being horrible but not the other, that's endorsing harassment and threats.
But all of that--yes, literally (who), all of that--is secondary to this: on the big, important things, they're right. American culture is profoundly racist and sexist and video game culture is worse than average. Games are built largely to pander--not even just your average "catering"--to young white males, and even as a young(-ish) white male that kind of sucks. This is something we should talk about. This is a real thing.
What isn't a real thing is the straight-up fiction told by Eron Gjoni that led directly to destroying a woman's life. What isn't a real thing is the catastrophic misreading of a couple of articles about the sublimation of "gamer culture" (what a joke) into the mainstream. "'Gamer' is meaningless because everybody plays games" turned into, in the minds of some very scared and very small people, "fuck gamers they're dead." The request for more representation in games permuted somehow into "no representation for people like us", even though there's literally (who) no way on God's green earth that video game publishers would not still and forever cater to that population. "Some people who like games and make games hang out with and know some people who like games and write about games" turned into ethics in games journalism, while, all along and completely unmentioned, IGN et al, with their million-dollar ad spends (not necessarily corrupting, but a sort of bias that none of the GamerGate talking heads mention), and the straight-up YouTube payola schemes (you know, actual corruption) have gone unmentioned, almost certainly because they aren't "anti-GG".
So even setting aside the bad behavior that overwhelmingly comes from one side of the aisle, we are starting at a position of fundamental reasonableness versus fundamental unreasonableness.
Some of the people involved are people I would characterize as extremists, others to a large degree just bad actors. And if the criticisms actually were "FemFreq makes stuff up for attention," I'd probably honestly be partly in agreement. But it's not, it's really not. In the heart of hearts of the people doing this shit, it's that women and minorities are elbowing their way to the table and the specter of loss of relative privilege is scary so we'd better fight back and the only way we know how to fight back is to try to make them give up by making it not worth the damage to their lives.
The fact of the matter is this: you lose when you start trying to hurt people. You just do. That, in the rhetoric you don't actually care about, there's a point to be considered actually and truly stops mattering when you are attempting, as a group, to hurt people in a concrete and tangible manner. A GamerGater being socially shunned for his retrograde bullshit is not the same as a normal person being forced from her--invariably her--home because of death threats toward her and her family. This is not the False Equivalency Zone, and you will find no takers here.
Bomb threats--prove it. Cites, please.
Doxxing, yes. And the people involved have, by and large, been thrown out of the communities they purported to champion.
Syringes, though. Syringes. It's cool that you're giving up on your false neutrality, though; going to bat for Milo Yiannopoulos and his sterling reputation for honesty about anything tips your hand.
I am done with you. HAND.
I know them by the fruits of their labors, as they should be known.
The concerted attacks on Anita Sarkeesian--an academic, not a journalist--and Jenn Frank--a writer of opinion articles, not a journalist--and a handful of others who just happen to be loud and female and mostly not-journalists but still just so very unethical, we promise, prove the mistruths in those the declarations of intent, be it from outright liars who are participating to the useful idiots who cover the brigading scum.
> The lapses were mutually beneficial, and there was harassment against the men involved as well.
Yeah, Nathan Grayson totes had to flee from his home and completely uproot his life.
Wait, no, the other thing.