News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by WillPostForFood on Friday June 12, 2015 @04:48PM (#9708440)
The primary contribution of agriculture is feeding people, not GDP. What does watering one's lawn contribute to?
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by jkyle on Friday June 12, 2015 @04:56PM (#9708483)
The point is watering your lawn is a drop in the giant reservoir. If only 20% of the water is being used by residents (in reality, it's a bit less) and you pass super aggressive water conservation laws targeting residential use such that it's reduced by 50% then you've conserved a whopping.....

10%

In contrast, a mere 12% increase in agriculture efficiency gets you the same win.

Targeting residents to curb the water crisis in CA is like targeting SNAP benefits as a solution to the deficit.

It just plain won't work.

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by mindslight on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:16PM (#9708601)
While this is true for the big picture, it's still fucked up that the status quo is for most everyone to have a well-watered lawn. And the response of "cities" like Los Angeles is to subsidize people's servants completely redoing their yards!

Implementing water restrictions is incredibly easy - you declare "no outdoor water usage except on these two days of the week after 5pm" and issue fines to people who don't comply. But it is incompatible with Californian entitlement, because gasp the grass might get a little brown.

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by vitd on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:56PM (#9708812)
I'm sorry, but have you ever been to Los Angeles? Where is this mythical place you're talking about with these mythical people?

I live in Los Angeles proper, and the majority of my neighbors already had low-water lawns to begin with. Those that don't (including me because the owners of the house I rent don't want to change it) are basically just letting the lawn die because we understand the situation and really aren't that vain.

Also, we do have watering restrictions and the city does give out fines if you don't follow them. I'm not sure what you're talking about, frankly.

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by mindslight on Friday June 12, 2015 @06:51PM (#9709059)
Actually yes, I'm on the west side right now.

I'm in one of the few buildings without grass. The sidewalk across the street is damp every morning. Walking around, I often see pools of runoff that have persisted throughout the day. Most all the lawns are still being trimmed every single week. Maybe this neighborhood is just terrible.

Are there actually any restrictions besides http://www.lawaterrestrictions.net/current-water-restriction... ? To someone used to the Northeast's late-summer restrictions those are laughable - you can still water your lawn every day of the week!

Good on you for letting your lawn wither, but I assure you that the out of touch culture is alive and well.

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by DannyBee on Friday June 12, 2015 @07:09PM (#9709121)
"While this is true for the big picture, it's still fucked up that the status quo is for most everyone to have a well-watered lawn."

Why? Why should we not focus on what actually matters?

Note that california's per-person water consumption (including lawn watering) has declined over the past 20 years.

So people are doing a good job.

Note also that parts of LA and other places you are complaining about, have the lowest per-capita water use in california (though nearby have some of the largest) Here are some figures:

http://www.latimes.com/local/california/la-me-1105-californi...

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by mindslight on Friday June 12, 2015 @07:57PM (#9709271)
Yes, I think the only real solution is to properly price water and build desalinization plants for areas along the coast. And yes, individuals conserving water will not prevent whatever outcome awaits, only slow it down slightly.

But personally wasting water is still insanity. It demonstrates an attitude of being someone else's problem, which ties right in to the general California philosophy of outsourcing personal judgment/responsibility.

I've seen much better conservation efforts during New England droughts, which only ever last a few months and are then followed by an inundation of precipitation.

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by wallyhs on Friday June 12, 2015 @06:11PM (#9708880)
It's not just about the grass. When trees die, they become hazards and must be removed. That's expensive. Without trees, there are fewer birds. There is no shade. The sound of leaves is absent from the wind. Obviously, there are more important things for a society to worry about, but my point is that this issue is not just about grass.

People seek out natural things such as plants. They put them in their homes, they hang paintings of them on their walls, and they decorate their cubicles with them. I don't think it is surprising that people want green lawns. It is depressing to live in a brown world.

The answer seems to be to design _better_ lawns: plant grasses, shrubs, and trees which grow naturally in the area, do not require huge amounts of water, and are drought-resistant. I don't know about LA, but, in my area, this transition has been underway for years.

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by ojbyrne on Friday June 12, 2015 @06:36PM (#9708988)
Mountain View, and probably many other cities in California, have already made that declaration, and other restrictions.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by s73v3r on Friday June 12, 2015 @07:48PM (#9709242)
Except those regulations are in place in a lot of places. It just happens to be incredibly hard to enforce.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by WillPostForFood on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:06PM (#9708549)
Sure, but you were touting GDP as the way to target water reduction, which doesn't make sense. I agree water should be priced based on supply, which would bring more efficiency to use in farming, lawns, or whatever.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by jkyle on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:21PM (#9708625)
You misunderstood me. I updated with an edit to clarify in the original post.

GDP is mentioned to show that increased cost of production for agriculture will not have a catastrophic effect on our economy....if you ask most Californians (or others), they often think agriculture is a huge proportion of our economy and requiring water efficiency would have a huge negative impact on our bottom line. Lost jobs, revenue, etc.

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by intopieces on Friday June 12, 2015 @06:26PM (#9708941)
I'll copy what I said above because it's relevant to your point as well: The problem, though, is that the water taken up by agriculture and the water taken up by people in cities does not come from the same big bucket. A drop of water saved by Ag doesn't equate to a drop of water that can be used in my shower. Infrastructure changes will have to happen and the 20% users will also have to make cuts.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by mentat on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:06PM (#9708546)
Well said. Thank you for arguing with facts and numbers.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by slavik81 on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:11PM (#9708568)
Is it? A significant proportion of that agriculture consists of luxury crops for export. Nobody's going to starve if the price of water-intensive foods like avocado and almonds increase a little.

If you care about feeding the poor, give them money to buy their food. Don't wreck the environment and distort the market with supply-side meddling.

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by emp on Friday June 12, 2015 @06:34PM (#9708983)
Don't forget raising animals for meat, growing food to feed animals, and growing food for export to feed animals. This accounts for more water than almonds that seem to always be the scapegoat.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by jkyle on Saturday June 13, 2015 @03:30PM (#9712284)
Another interesting fact about almonds. They're actually the most cost effective use of water from the volume to profit ratio.

So, yes, it takes more water the produce a bushel of almonds then it does to produce a bushel of <whatever>. However, that bushel of almonds earns more profit per gallon.

What does this mean? It means if you start charging farmers for water usage (rather than access) then almonds are a more attractive crop then others crops from a profit perspective.

Counter to what most believe, restricting farmer's water access or charging more for water might actually increase the shift to certain water intensive luxury crops like almonds.

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by yellowapple on Friday June 12, 2015 @09:04PM (#9709450)
> If you care about feeding the poor, give them money to buy their food.

Yep. Let's make the poor people dependent on the rich people for basic sustenance instead of allowing food to actually be affordable. Let's also marginalize the people who are just barely not poor enough to qualify for such a thing, because "well, sorry that you're barely keeping your family above the poverty line, but you know, gotta blame the farmers for being inconvenient to the cityfolk, and you're not quite as poor as this family over here so why should we care about your problems?".

Any system that depends on the arbitrarily-defined concept of "poverty" v. "not-poverty" is a non-answer to many lower and lower-middle class households.

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by PerfectElement on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:42PM (#9708738)
Why avocados? It takes 74.1 gallons to produce 1 pound. Much less than most calorie-dense foods.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by CydeWeys on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:00PM (#9708516)
Most water used by cities isn't used for watering lawns. This is a red herring fallacy anyway because no one is proposing loosening up restrictions on lawn watering at the expense of waterin crops.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by dragonwriter on Friday June 12, 2015 @04:54PM (#9708473)
> The primary contribution of agriculture is feeding people, not GDP.

The primary value to California of exporting food (which is what most California agriculture is) is the economic activity produced.

(Given a global food market with largely equivalent substitute goods, one could argue that the same is true of agriculture that is used for local consumption, as well.)

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by WillPostForFood on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:00PM (#9708510)
You say GDP contribution to Californianis more important than supplying food to the state/country/world. I say feeding people and keeping food prices low is more important than that particular economic statistic when looking at the value of water consumption.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by jkyle on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:26PM (#9708650)
If this is your honest opinion, you'd be pushing for emergency triage of water allocation for agriculture. Specifically, reducing luxury crops like almonds, beef, and chicken.

We could cut our water usage in 1/2 and still produce enough nutritious food for the entire nation plus some.

This coming from someone who has favorite pass time of smoking brisket, ribs, and grilling steaks. It's just the facts.

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by yellowapple on Friday June 12, 2015 @09:09PM (#9709460)
> If this is your honest opinion, you'd be pushing for emergency triage of water allocation for agriculture. Specifically, reducing luxury crops like almonds, beef, and chicken.

I'd be fine with agricultural triaging, personally.

However, pinning the blame on almonds and livestock is misplaced (and, in the latter case, characterizing them as "luxury" crops seems misplaced unless you consider basic nutrients like protein a "luxury"). Instead, it would be wiser to focus on things like rice, which consumes absurd amounts of water relative to the amount of resulting food. I don't have any statistics on hand, but I reckon California's rice production alone dwarfs livestock (and possibly even almonds) in terms of water usage, and (I'd argue) would count much more easily as wasted water than livestock or nuts (since, compared livestock and nuts, rice isn't particularly nutritious).

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by sbov on Saturday June 13, 2015 @01:00AM (#9709949)
From my research, pound for pound rice takes less than almonds.

Guess what crop California spends almost 50% of its water on? Alfalfa, which is used to feed cattle.

Also, just cutting out beef can make a huge dent. It's water usage is truly wtf level, whereas chicken is closer to almond level.

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by yellowapple on Monday June 15, 2015 @12:58PM (#9720566)
> Guess what crop California spends almost 50% of its water on? Alfalfa, which is used to feed cattle.

Alfalfa isn't used for just cattle, you know.

Also, do you have a source for that number? I'm having trouble finding one from a U.S. or California government source (USGS, USDA, CDFA, etc.), but at least one article [0] pins that number at closer to 15% (and almonds at 10%).

> Also, just cutting out beef can make a huge dent. It's water usage is truly wtf level

A citation is also needed here. According to the USGS's 2010 data (which admittedly is likely outdated), livestock as a whole (beef, chicken, pork, you name it) takes up around 0.5% of California's water [1]. Whether or not this includes alfalfa is unclear, but if the previous figure is correct, I'd suggest that cattle water usage is nowhere near the "WTF" level.

That figure makes a lot of sense to me, having grown up raising angus cattle (I'm not sure whether or not dairy cattle have higher water requirements due to milk production being their emphasis). Alfalfa was certainly a big part of their feed, but grass hay and grazing were just as important to their diet. Larger commercial operations might have different methods, but I'd reckon that most ranches aren't high-scale commercial operations.

[0]: http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/future_tense/2014/0...

[1]: http://ca.water.usgs.gov/water_use/2010-california-water-use...

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by sbov on Wednesday June 17, 2015 @01:59PM (#9733910)
> Also, do you have a source for that number? I'm having trouble finding one from a U.S. or California government source (USGS, USDA, CDFA, etc.), but at least one article [0] pins that number at closer to 15% (and almonds at 10%).

I got my numbers a bit mixed up. According to: http://pacinst.org/wp-content/uploads/sites/21/2013/02/ca_ft...

Meat and dairy uses 47% of California's water. I'm not sure how I transplanted that into Alfalfa alone.

> I'd suggest that cattle water usage is nowhere near the "WTF" level.

Here I'm merely speaking on how much water it takes to produce a pound of the product. From what I can tell chicken is around 500 gallons of water per pound, but beef is more like 1,500+ - I was mostly looking at waterfootprint.org, but other sources seem to back up these estimates.

Chicken is at least close to almonds, which people are freaking out about since its several times other options, but beef is 3x chicken. Hence, WTF level.

Lets do some math. I have some friends who live in San Francisco, which (going off memory) has an average water consumption of 50 gallons of water/day/person.

But some eat steak for dinner every day of the week, probably around 12 ounces. At 1,500 gallons of water per pound, thats 1,125 gallons of water for their meal. If they switched that to chicken, assuming the same number of ounces (not sure if we can do this though - if people need to eat more ounces of chicken than beef) and 500 gallons per pound, thats 375 gallons of water. A savings of 750 gallons of water per day.

They just reduced their personal water footprint by many times what the water utility sees. They could 100% cut out flushing toilets, taking showers, doing the dishes, doing laundry, and not come even close to what eating chicken instead of beef does.

I've seen some maps comparing SoCal water usage vs NorCal. Going off memory, 50 gallons vs 100-150 gallons day/person. The reality is, the gap between 50 and 150 is covered by choosing to eat chicken over beef 4 times a month.

Dietary water footprint is much more significant than what our water utilities show us.

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by Kalium on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:11PM (#9708570)
The point being made here is not that feeding people and keeping food prices low isn't important. The point being made here is that California agriculture isn't required to feed people or keep food prices low.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by sbov on Friday June 12, 2015 @06:30PM (#9708962)
Then the nation needs to view it as a national problem rather than a Californian problem. People don't though, instead they point and laugh as they eat our state dry.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by Lawtonfogle on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:03PM (#9708533)
>The primary contribution of agriculture is feeding people, not GDP.

Feeding people can be done in many areas. Why should one area sacrifice a limited resource when another area can do the same but with more of that resource? If they aren't compensated for the sacrifice of that resource, there is no reason for that resource to be sacrificed. Charity to big business will lead to being left destitute.

Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by zaroth on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:03PM (#9708534)
GDP is simply a measure of the value of this product which is "feeding people". Similarly, parks and landscaping, the cost of upkeep and the resulting increase in property values, are also accounted for in the notion of GDP.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by iwwr on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:03PM (#9708529)
Homeowner's Association rules or even town planning/zoning may actually prohibit someone from using arid-friendly grasses or perhaps replacements like artificial turf or pavement.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by jkyle on Friday June 12, 2015 @05:28PM (#9708663)
There's a decent movement going to make restrictions like that from HOA's null and void if they conflict with state conservation interests.
Re:California Announces Restrictions on Water Use by Farmers by yellowapple on Friday June 12, 2015 @09:11PM (#9709464)
Then HOAs need to die off already, simple as that.