News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Readlang – Learn a language while you surf the web by jcoffland on Friday June 12, 2015 @04:36PM (#9708361)
I like the idea of doing two things at once but you often end up doing both things poorly. There's a high likelyhood that you will learn somethings incorrectly due to machine translation errors, even in popular languages. For other language combinations, English-Chineese for example, Google translate is really bad. Frequent and repeated exposure to a language is the best way to learn. This product could help but learning a language is like loosing weight, there aren't really any short cuts. You still have to work hard.
Re:Show HN: Readlang – Learn a language while you surf the web by steveridout on Saturday June 13, 2015 @07:20AM (#9710682)
Learning a language is going to take a lot of time and effort, no argument there.

But not all methods are equally effective so anything that reduces the time or effort required, even if just by 10%, is technically a 'short cut'. And anything that increases your enjoyment of the process is a win, regardless of whether it saves time, since it will help maintain motivation. Losing motivation is surely the most common reason people fail to learn.

The main idea here is to reduce the friction of reading as much as possible, freeing up your attention to focus on understanding and enjoying the text. The machine translation is only used here for words and short phrases, where it's more effective than for complete sentences.

(I'll take your word for it that google translate isn't so good with English-Chinese, I'm mainly focussed on the European languages for now)