Using unknown cryptography is not security through obscurity. If the encryption is legit, then it's good. The problem is when you are relying solely on obscurity without the encryption.
Re:Snowden Document Search
by bthornbury on Friday June 12, 2015 @11:16AM
(#9706383)
Security by obscurity is great until it isnt. It's largely impractical for long term data security.
I don't understand why you'd say that is group think.
It's the ivory tower problem. I agree with you and the parent post.
Parent said:
"new less scrutinized algorithms may still offer a practical defense"
But in my experience that P word there is unknown to ivory tower dwellers. And so the practical peasants end up getting unrealistic (but theoretically correct) advice.
But here on HN, many folks like their mantra of "security by obscurity is bad" too much. Personally, I think many of those who repeat that didn't think for themselves.