As far fraudulent devices, I think it's pretty safe to assume that people aren't going to be swiping their cards with random people; rather merchants and vendors that they already have a reasonable level of trust with, but in situations where sales would have been limited to cash only or more complicated and PO-based (trade shows, live events, sales guys in the field, etc.). It won't stop the kinds of fraud that already happens; like your waiter at a restaurant keeping lists of card numbers for sale on the black market. And, I guess it would make that kind of fraud easier, since the attacker would have more information.
But, people are, I think, pretty cagey with handing random people their credit card outside of the context of a reasonably trustworthy business. I doubt this will change that. I'm about the hit the road doing sales work for my company, and I can see this coming in very handy, and I don't think my potential customers would have any reason to be concerned about fraud (since they can easily check up on us, and know that I am who I say I am).
Hope doesn't scale.
http://paulbuchheit.blogspot.com/2007/03/how-to-be-right-90-...
I just answered specifically to the comment, referring to the security aspect. Paypal was losing 10 million USD from fraud, so hope won't do it for the security.
"assume that people aren't going to be swiping their cards with random people"
Assuming, just won't do it.
I'll also mention that folks swipe their cards in fake ATM swipers pretty regularly. It hasn't hurt ATM usage, in general. Likewise, PayPal fraud is still an issue that they fight every day...but PayPal is incredibly profitable. eBay and craigslist also have huge fraud problems, but again, the sheer volume of legitimate transactions and the value of the huge markets they serve is enough to overcome any misgivings people have about using the services. So, I don't think that fake swipers will make this particularly company any more or less trusted than existing providers that have to fight fraud (assuming they are vigilant about actually fighting it).
The interesting thing here is that PayPal made all their margins by encouraging people to use bank accounts rather than credit cards because they made almost no profit on credit card transactions. I'm interested in how this revenue model will work out, it seems like merchant services providers have arrived at their current model of business (arduous checks before granting accounts) out of necessity. Since Square is basically in the merchant accounts business (that's where their margin is) it will be interesting to see if they actually know something that merchant service providers do not about granting accounts to anyone who wants them without more verification.
I've always wondered why merchant service providers didn't instantly verify accounts and allow people to start charging immediately, but hold the captured funds while the account was verified with all the proper checks. Maybe that is what Square is doing.
why are we naysaying this specific business and not other point of sale things that operate the exact same way? what prevents someone from running a fake newspaper stand with a laptop and CC swiper? why is this product vastly different?
If the device doesn't look 100% 'official' I wouldn't touch it with my card.
do they do restaurant payments different in the UK? would you simply hand your card over to a waiter to pay a bill? what prevents the waiter from just writing down your info? you wouldn't even see a device there.
i think that its just an issue of trust. you won't necessarily trust someone with a hacked together device on a street corner, but if its your cousin jim's glass blowing sculpture store, you'll probably trust anything they run your card through.
plus, in the US at least, we have a fairly robust consumer protection on cards. if you suspect your card to be compromised or see a charge on it you know isn't yours, dispute it and you'll probably have your issues resolved satisfactorily.
The portable POS devices allow the customer to tip as well BTW.
"They" don't run cards much any more. It's a case of consumers putting their own cards into chip+pin devices and keying in their PIN.
Sure @ disputes, we have similar, but it's an extra hassle and not fun.
also, what are your thoughts on online purchases? you're relinquishing a certain degree of control there, too.
disputing isn't fun or convenient, but if it wasn't there or it was worse, i don't know that the CC system would be as popular or successful. its one of the reasons why debit cards had a rocky start.
A scammer can today get hold of a fake taxi badge, pass a skimmer back to the passenger saying it's going to take payment and achieve the same end.
Presumably the argument against square would be that it will desensitise consumers to the risks associated with this and they'll drop their guard.
I think this might make sense if consumers had any guard in the first place. However since I'm sure the average person would hand their credit card to a taxi driver to skim today it's hard to see that Square changes anything.
At the end of the day this will come down to people being careful about who they hand their card to - just as they are (aren't) on the internet.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Credit_card_fraud#Skimming
How is this any different?
The beauty of credit cards is that you're not responsible for fraud. I know that when I go to a restaurant the server could easily take a quick cell camera shot of my card, but I accept that risk because I know that I monitor my card activity and that I can recover that money if it does happen. The same applies here.
All you need is a taxi, and iPhone, and you can go around town collecting credit card numbers.
And unlike websites, there is no paper trail to link you to the scam.
This isn't even as big a threat as, say, making people acclimated to the idea of joining open wireless networks at coffee shops -- card skimming at least requires physical access to the card for a few seconds.
If today a beggar extended his card reader-equipped iPhone to you, would you swipe? If this company takes off, in a few years you very well might.
Payment methods which give third parties permanent access to your wallet are bad.
a- Card present. Chances of fraud when the card is swiped are much lower than when it isn't (for obvious reasons). b- Signature. This lets you have a basic form of authentication for the user after the fact (oh, didn't make this purchase? Why is this your signature?) c- Location. Each purchase is tagged with the GPS coordinates from the phone. d- If need be, pictures. You could always snap a quick photo of the cardholder if the transaction comes up as a serious fraud risk.
Yes, there are still risks of the person skimming your card info, or stealing your CC number another way, but these are risks present in the entire credit card system.
It's certainly much safer than PayPal, and they're doing alright.
What is the hole in this? I'm not saying there is no hole, and I did like your question (and upvoted it), but I'm wondering if you can think of a good attack that I'm missing.
Edit: Instead of "iPhone" I should have said just "phone" since it will be on multiple platforms.
You are doing everything on another person's gadget. Any verification Square can come up with, can be bypassed by simply not implementing it.
Verified icon? Easy JPG
Encoded credit card #s? Who said the fraudsters would need to use your tool?
Square Verified badge? Easily copied.
It basically boils down to trust issue, early on, consumers will just be unaware of how vulnerable they are, but then stories will start popping up all over the place about how so and so, paid with a credit card for a taxi ride using Square, and then got hit with $5K in credit card fraud.
The Square system is like me handing over a pot with all my money in it and saying "take what you like". Whilst the above is akin to me passing the money to an esscrow (my bank) and them checking it is OK and telling the receiver of the funds.
Sure a fraudster can get hold of a fake merchant ID and encode the transaction value, ID and their merchant ID with an acquired private key - but that merchant ID can just be locked when fraud is spotted and decrypting the data off the wire is going to require lots of resources.
What am I missing.
This will basically just eliminate all the risk.
They'll launch, make a couple hundred mil, then they'll get hit with fraud, a ton of people will lose money, and they'll be forced to shut down, since noone will want to use the service, in fear of getting defrauded.
Since there is no barrier to entry, it'll be like 2 weeks before someone comes out with a black market version, that will look exactly the same, but instead of processing credit cards, it'll store them for future fraud.
Will be like the ATM snooping devices, but instead of having to get into the bank, all you need is an iPhone, and some "small" business to rob people with. A taxi, or a newspaper stand.
Edit: If you are going to downvote, at least tell me how exactly do you think this will avoid fraud from fakers who imitate the look and feel of the device?