Re:CommonJS effort sets JavaScript on path for world domination
by swannodette on Wednesday December 02, 2009 @09:31AM
(#972069)
While I agree with you that the lack of concurrency is problematic in the long run I think that JavaScript on the server will be at least as useful for many web applications as PHP, Python, Ruby, Perl - all of which have modest or non-existant concurrency stories.
I'm curious as to why you think JavaScript can't hold it's own weight against said-languages for the server-side?
In 2009, my default presumption is that an emerging platform that probably won't even be viable until 2010 ought to have a concurrency story better than what we already had. If it doesn't have that, why wouldn't I use an existing language?
If it were entering a vacuum, sure, great, no problem, but it's not.
I guess this goes back to my old standard for examining the usefulness of a language: "What problem does it solve?" There ought to be a single sentence that says what problem the language solves. Python: "It's too hard to program; we need to make it easier." Perl: "Too many separate UNIX tools, we should merge them together." Haskell: "Our academic theory is great and all, but we need to come out of our ivory towers and prove it works.
Javascript on the server: "..."? "I really want to be able to use the same language on the server as the client" is a I think what it's going for, and as far as that goes it's ok, but my objection is that it isn't a very good server language. And note my objections really are about the language, not merely a lack of libraries, which is completely solvable. You can't just graft on concurrency anymore, at least not as far as I'm concerned; my standards have risen.