News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Arguments in the Bitcoin Block Size Debate by Animats on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:28AM (#9697557)
"What do you mean by this? If 2mb of transaction data is generated every 10 minutes, but only 1mb of it is mined, what is the free market solution?"

When you submit a transaction, you're entering an auction. The winners of the auction get their transactions processed quickly. The losers don't. The market thus sets a price on getting a transaction processed. This discourages free-riders who expect their transactions to be processed free or for a nominal fee. Miners are facing the dreaded "halving" next year, when the block reward drops by half. They need higher fees to compensate.[1]

[1] http://www.coindesk.com/new-study-low-bitcoin-transaction-fe...

Re:Arguments in the Bitcoin Block Size Debate by beaner on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:45AM (#9697627)
This isn't an actual solution though, because space is still limited. Bitcoin cannot be a currency if it can only fit 2,000 transactions per block. Even if everyone is willing to pay $100 in fees for their $1 transactions, they won't all fit, and that's broken.

The challenge is to find a way for miners to be incentivized and for them also to process all reasonable transactions. There's no reason miner's couldn't increase their fees independently of the block size increase.

Re:Arguments in the Bitcoin Block Size Debate by eyci on Thursday June 11, 2015 @01:06AM (#9697711)
> They need higher fees to compensate.

That's not an argument for any block size in particular, though. Saying that fee revenue is maximized at smaller blocks is positing that demand for block space (i.e. transaction demand) is relatively inelastic, whereas there isn't really any consensus or even much discussion on what the elasticity is.

Re:Arguments in the Bitcoin Block Size Debate by sneak on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:00AM (#9698521)
Auctions for limited capacity at this ridiculously early stage in bitcoin's growth will shake confidence in the network to the point of abandonment.

A currency you can't easily transact in is one nobody wants to use. An auction process like this means you can't easily use bitcoin.