News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by nkurz on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @04:53PM (#9695295)
In case you were wondering what Curtis's talk might have been about (and whether it would have held any technical merit) this page has a link to Clark's earlier introduction to Urbit: http://popehat.com/2013/12/06/nock-hoon-etc-for-non-vulcans-...

The "Exit, voice, and loyalty" terminology might seem odd if you don't know it's origins. It's from 1970 book by economist A. O. Hirschman that's coming back in popularity: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Exit,_Voice,_and_Loyalty. Hirschman gives an 1978 intro/postscript in his own words here: http://homepages.wmich.edu/~plambert/comp/hirschman.pdf

I'm surprised by apparent predominance of support here on HN for Strangeloop's position. While clearly legal, it's strikes me as a terrible precedent to require speakers on technical topics to pass a political litmus test. I'd be interested to know the actual direction that the sentiment lies. Do those who support Curtis appearing at the talk (wisely?) refrain from posting out of (legitimate?) fear of career repercussion? Or am I (comfortable speaking because I'm largely outside the industry) in the minority?

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by joelgrus on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @05:07PM (#9695398)
Do those who support Curtis appearing at the talk refrain from posting out of fear of career repercussion?

No and yes. I have been pretty vocal about it on Twitter:

https://twitter.com/joelgrus/status/606474432509394944 https://twitter.com/joelgrus/status/606673594198794240

but I've also been sitting on a 75%-written blog post that I'm hesitant to actually post.

Not because of career repercussions (I have never had an employer who really gave a shit what I write about in my spare time) but because of conference repercussions.

I am promoting a book, and to that end I am scheduled to speak at various conferences and meetups. And I worry that the mob would somehow try to get me uninvited. It's not like there's an actual policy that Yarvin violated that I can be confident I'm on the right side of.

So I am torn between my natural inclination to say exactly what I think, and the more practical takeaway of "don't write or have written anything that might anger the mob".

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by existencebox on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @05:17PM (#9695495)
I typically avoid posting in these sorts of threads, very little good has come from political debates on the internet that I've seen, but your last sentence pushes me to speak up.

Status-quo social thoughtcrime is rather terrifying to me. There's no "easy" way to amend laws or lobby a system to address the issue, as one would against a governmental stance.

It's also cyclical, as less "clean" people speak out against it, the "only rapists defend rapist" situation mentioned by sister posts occurs, and the entire culture of defending someone who might be distasteful, separating the issue from their broader history, diminishes.

I can't claim to judge you for your decision, I fully acknowledge the unfortunate state of things and your ability to make a choice that best serves your needs, but for the sake of putting my money where my mouth is; I think he should have been allowed to speak (espousing viewpoints I disagree with is far and beyond an offensive enough act to cause me to want to petition against someone, and even then, I would not attempt to convey that aversion as anything more than my personal stance).

The fact that I (or you, or any of us) feel any uncertainty due to fear of the repercussions for merely voicing this opinion only serves to reinforce my conviction that it needs to be voiced.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by fweespeech on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:21PM (#9696848)
That is very, very true. It is, frankly, impossible to force change in such a situation unless you already have a large enough soapbox to be heard and can build a network of similarly minded [and widely read/heard] individuals.

I think, regardless of political affiliation, we have to admit to ourselves that most people are prepared & willing to silence people with beliefs they find odious. Please note that I said "beliefs" not "actions".

The right to vocalize and discuss our beliefs freely is something that must be fundamentally protected, most especially when it is odious. The only way to do that is to make it both legally permissible [as the law can apply violent force] but also socially permissible to the point of indifference for people to voice different beliefs [even the odious, bigoted ones].

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by Jare on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @05:25PM (#9695555)
Thank you both. I too have a half finished post that I can't figure how to finish properly, but I now feel I don't need to.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by topynate on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @05:12PM (#9695444)
You're getting bitten by preference falsification, as proposed by Timur Kuran.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Preference_falsification

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by joelgrus on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @05:17PM (#9695497)
I mean, I feel like I'm conveying my exact preferences pretty clearly ("let Yarvin speak"), the question is more how much I want to antagonize the people who got him uninvited.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by theorique on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:30AM (#9698596)
It's not like there's an actual policy that Yarvin violated that I can be confident I'm on the right side of.

This is the bigger issue - the chilling of all controversial views and debate.

It's less about "violated Rule XXIV, subsection (c) of the Code of Conduct" and more about "wrote some stuff that made us feel funny and we're worried that something awkward might happen at the meeting". Yes, the organizers have the power to rewrite the schedule for bad reasons or no reason at all. But it's important to point out what was done, and why we think it was done.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by d9h549f34w6 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @05:09PM (#9695411)
I for one support Curtis on this issue, but tend not to post here on the subject except under an alternate username. I do this because I do in fact fear the "social justice" crowd and their ability to mess with people and their careers when they don't follow the party line.

If I were to hazard a guess, I think I'm not alone in this and I think you're not in a minority (or at least a small one). The recent HN stories seem to get a good number of "silent upvotes" before anyone steps into the fray to add a comment.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by tjradcliffe on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @05:28PM (#9695591)
> I do in fact fear the "social justice" crowd and their ability to mess with people and their careers when they don't follow the party line

This is something I'd love see SJW's here react to. How do you feel about the fact that you have created a climate of fear amongst people who disagree with you?

Would you prefer convincing them of the correctness of your position, but willing to accept that at least by making them afraid you are helping further your cause?

Or are you concerned you've become the kind of discourse-stiffling monster you set out to defeat?

Or are you proud you've made the priviledged afraid?

Or something else entirely?

Because don't kid yourself: people are increasingly afraid to speak up on these issues because they are genuinely afraid of the consequences to their future employment prospects. Personally, I see that as a shameful situation, antithetical to any reasonable notion of a just society.

[Disclaimer: I've been accused at times of being an SJW, an MRA, a shill for Big Carbon, and quite a few other things besides.]

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by protomyth on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @05:34PM (#9695639)
"How do you feel about the fact that you have created a climate of fear amongst people who disagree with you?"

I don't think they care or, more specifically, if you fear then you don't think correctly and should shut-up[1]. Its quite a common attitude in movements and has happened many times.

1) or they'll add you to a blacklist to shut you up - the clean modern version of disappearing a person

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by d9h549f34w6 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @05:44PM (#9695715)
My guess is that they would be happy that they've created that climate of fear. I've noticed a trend among at least some in the "social justice" community that sees progress happening in terms of suppressing bad actions/speech until those who remember it die off. A lot of believing that the way forward is to akin to waiting for the "old racist generation" to die.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sdfghjkl34567 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @06:45PM (#9696162)
Responding under a throwaway.

I've been involved in anti-racist/anti-fascist work, either directly or on the periphery, for about ten years at this point. This takes many forms, from street confrontations with fascists, protests at book readings and other events, and also disrupting fascist conferences and similar.

Anti-Racist Action is the organization that has developed the most tactical and strategic influence in this space, not by design, but by chance (and it largely doesn't exist anymore). Disrupting fascist meetings by denying them space by getting hotels to drop them is the bread and butter of any ARA chapter. It's the easiest thing to do, and most modern tumblerites aren't willing to get in the streets with a bandanna and a baseball bat, so it's what gets done now. And in fact, it's likely that this sort of thing happens because ARA activists got involved in more liberal groups, etc., and the tactics just trickled down.

Personally, I have developed political differences with the "SJW" orthodoxy myself (though obviously in the other direction), and have seen the effects of this sort of attack applied on a social level. It has made my own work slightly more difficult, because I have to pick my comrades more carefully to ensure that they won't alienate me from my network. But this isn't a big deal for leftists, because there are already so many camps that are mutually oppositional that you'd need to do that already for some of your politics anyway. What's new in the last few years is having that extend away from your class alignment. (This is an answer to a question you didn't really ask, which is how the "SJW" community itself is affected by this, though it is what came to mind when I asked myself how I felt about it.)

As far as this issue and other similar issues are concerned, I'm overjoyed that, as you put it, a climate of fear exists for fascists, misogynists, racists, and similar. I hope that this continues and only worsens for these people.

I'm happy for many reasons. The first is that it has, as you've said, made privileged people afraid. I think this is only the beginning. Privilege creates safety, and as it is removed, I think the unsafety of the oppressed will in part come to the currently privileged classes. But if I could flip a switch and make every man feel the persistent, gnawing fear that a woman has of men, I would in a heartbeat. I wouldn't even consider whether the consequences were strategic, I would just do it.

I'm also happy that these people are achieving real victories. This is nearly impossible to do in a post-reformist landscape, and so the people involved in getting this fascist kicked out of this conference will have a real victory under their belt where their friends who are campaigning against some law that will inevitably pass or for some reform that will inevitably never happen won't. I hope that these victories can motivate people into taking more action. Burnout is a huge problem in activism and successes stave it off.

I would not say that I set out to defeat a "discourse-stifling" monster. The monsters I set out to defeat were patriarchy, capitalism, and white supremacy. These systems violently oppress, they don't "stifle discourse." In fact, they LOVE discourse! When people are discoursing, they aren't in the streets. I've seen so many promising movements hobbled by reformism that I'm glad the possibility no longer exists, though that isn't at all the fault of SJW-outrage (and is rather a consequence of the fact that the economy is in large part so perilous that nobody can afford the concessions that were previously won by reformists). So if discourse is permanently removed as a tactical and strategic option for future leftists, I'll consider it a victory.

You might be unsurprised to find out that free speech is not valued on the left or among "SJW" groups. I suggest you research this further, because I can't communicate to you in a single hacker news comment why this is, or what theoretical basis it has.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by mindslight on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @07:26PM (#9696347)
> But if I could flip a switch and make every man feel the persistent, gnawing fear that a woman has of men, I would in a heartbeat.

Would it not be better to work towards nobody feeling such fear?

> I'm also happy that these people are achieving real victories ... their friends ... are campaigning against some law that will inevitably pass

Once again championing (any) change itself over sane outcomes. Oppressive laws and the march of the machine are inevitable, so let's just fight each other?

Your comment is a poignant example of everything gone wrong with the "progressive" mentality. Thank you for being candid though.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sdfghjkl34567 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @08:14PM (#9696566)
>Would it not be better to work towards nobody feeling such fear?

But that isn't the hypothetical. Do you understand the concept?

Certainly if I had a faeries & unicorns switch I'd hit that as well, but we don't always have the options we'd like.

In the meantime, if it's possible to make fascist programmers afraid for their careers, that's great for me. It means fascist movements are disrupted before they can even form. God knows leftists have been afraid for long enough.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by mindslight on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @08:35PM (#9696652)
You came up with that specific hypothetical and it inherently carries your framework. It is set up as a zero sum interaction where everyone needs to be brought down rather than lifted up. But fighting injustice with more injustice is a race to the bottom.

By your usage, I presume you're using definition #1 of http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/fascist even though you are not capitalizing it. If it is possible to make Fascist programmers afraid for their careers, then Fascists cannot possibly wield much power.

On the other hand, the results of mob justice look an awful lot like a distributed implementation of fascism definition #2 - how is it not appropriate to describe, for example, a summary firing for political views as such?

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sdfghjkl34567 on Thursday June 11, 2015 @09:56AM (#9699700)
Dictionaries are descriptions, not proscriptions, of words. I'm not "using" any definition of fascism other than the one I've built up in my own mind based on my own lived experiences. I'm not going to be questioned on a dictionary.

It is true that all exercises of political power are at the end of the day coercive. My personal take on this is to minimize political power, but to do this takes a specific social arrangement that doesn't exist in the present day.

The hypothetical I came up with is one where it's easier to attack an existing system than to create new and liberatory systems. This is the same as reality. It is much, much easier to get a fascist talk removed from a conference than it would be to get everyone at that conference to come to an appropriate understanding of feminist and anti-racist thought and praxis. There are certainly people involved in education, propaganda, and outreach, but this is by nature a much slower process and one that will not bear fruit in any reasonable time span. It is certainly not fast enough to counteract things like fascists at conferences, so we shut down the fascists.

I also obviously disagree as to whether denying a fascist the ability to spread fascism is injustice, or more broadly, whether attacking the oppressor classes and limiting their ability to oppress is somehow unjust. But then, I also care much less about any concept of "justice." Certainly the world is not a just place, and I question whether the concept of justice as communicated by oppressor classes is something we need to bring with us into the future.

Finally

>distributed implementation of fascism

Do you notice the contradiction?

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by nkurz on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:18PM (#9701331)
It is much, much easier to get a fascist talk removed from a conference

How does one distinguish a "fascist talk" from a "technical talk presented by one accused of being a fascist"? Is the difference relevant? I think Moldbug views himself as anti-fascist, and argues that Fascism and Communism are alternative undesirable endgames for democracy: http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2009/07/carlyle...

And I'm not sure whether one should equate Moldbug with Yarvin. Is the blogger a pseudonym, a construct, a caricature, or an alter-ego? Should a comedian be equated with their on-stage persona? An actor with the character they play? An author with their protagonist?

I (truly) appreciate the insight your earlier comments provide.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sdfghjkl34567 on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:47PM (#9701876)
>How does one distinguish a "fascist talk" from a "technical talk presented by one accused of being a fascist"?

Well, pragmatically, the difference is immaterial, because to maximize the memetic intensity of anti-fascism, we have to attack all fascists everywhere all the time. Within the fold, there is very little opposition, because once one valid point has been made, going against it is nearly impossible.

This is the real danger in going down the ideological-purity path the way the mainstream extreme-liberal tumblerite bloc has. I get around this by maintaining a network of people I trust implicitly as comrades and who also trust me, but this is how ideologic drift happens in, say, activist groups.

>I think Moldbug views himself as anti-fascist

Well, nobody's the villain of their own story.

>Is the blogger a pseudonym, a construct, a caricature, or an alter-ego? Should a comedian be equated with their on-stage persona? An actor with the character they play? An author with their protagonist?

Do you think Moldbug is intended as a fiction?

>I (truly) appreciate the insight your earlier comments provide.

Don't think they provide so much insight. I'm one person and pretty idiosyncratic in my ideology and praxis. I am certainly not representative and I'm sure I would disagree with (just as an example) most of the people whose twitter comments were cited in the OP's article.

I just wanted to say that yes, I fully enjoy the fact that people are now afraid to be racist, sexist, etc., at tech conferences.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by eli_gottlieb on Monday June 15, 2015 @10:49AM (#9719648)
>to maximize the memetic intensity of anti-fascism, we have to attack all fascists everywhere all the time

Nobody on the Left talks like that. I'm guessing you're actually one of Yarvin's own bunch masquerading as an antifascist to discredit the cause.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by nkurz on Thursday June 11, 2015 @06:08PM (#9702764)
Do you think Moldbug is intended as a fiction?

No, I think they are essays where in the author is testing out ideas to see how they hold together when criticized by the world. Some of these ideas are deep beliefs, where the question is simply how the outside will react to hearing about them. Some of them are fragments of arguments he's trying to piece together, in the hope that the process of writing will clear things up in his own mind. Others are probably there simply because he was drawn in the cadence of the language.

But I do think that Moldbug is consciously a persona, and not identical to Yarvin. And I don't think either is a fascist by any reasonable definition. Racist? Yes, the writing is racist by the current way the word is used to label practically any belief in racial differences. But I'd prefer to judge the author (Yarvin) by how he treats others in the world, not how he writes about the world in the abstract.

I fully enjoy the fact that people are now afraid to be racist, sexist, etc., at tech conferences.

If this was the only outcome, I'd might agree with the tactics. But what if their pragmatic reaction is to simply avoid situations where they can be accused of these things? Don't hire women, because they might accuse you of sexism. Don't hire minorities, because you might lose your job if accused of racial prejudice?

In such an environment, silence is likely the best strategy. But along with the silence is likely the belief that everyone else shares the same opinion, but similarly doesn't speak about it. I believe more in sunlight as a disinfectant: get the ideas out in the open. I think it's good for people to hear more points of view they disagree with.

I'm one person and pretty idiosyncratic in my ideology and praxis.

Yes, but that ideology is so different from mine that I learn just by the knowledge that such a viewpoint exists.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by mindslight on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:51PM (#9700810)
If your definition differs, please describe it. Sharing definitions is necessary to communicate, as opposed to simply lobbing feels back and forth.

> My personal take on this is to minimize political power, but to do this takes a specific social arrangement that doesn't exist in the present day.

So in the mean time, you switch to maximizing political power? Why exactly do you think this would end any differently than it has in the past - simply empowering new autocrats borne by new religions?

> But then, I also care much less about any concept of "justice."

How can you propose to have a society without justice? When people feel wronged, their desire is to get greater revenge. Without moderating this force, feuds grow ever larger.

It seems as if you're envisioning a magic society where everybody just "gets it" and nobody transgresses against one another. And since you can never have that (there will always be differences of opinion), you take solace in mob destruction but yet still tell yourself you're fighting the good fight.

>> distributed implementation of fascism

> Do you notice the contradiction?

Not at all. The result is the same for those on the receiving end. (and for your inevitable thought of 'well they deserve it' - that's exactly the position of the oppressors you're fighting against. good job!)

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by amcastillo on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:29PM (#9700643)
>Do you notice the contradiction?

No. Distributivism comes to mind.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by anon_adderlan on Monday June 22, 2015 @05:10PM (#9761228)
> In the meantime, if it's possible to make fascist programmers afraid for their careers, that's great for me. It means fascist movements are disrupted before they can even form. God knows leftists have been afraid for long enough.

Disrupting fascist movements sounds like a great idea, but is that really your intent?

> But if I could flip a switch and make every man feel the persistent, gnawing fear that a woman has of men, I would in a heartbeat. I wouldn't even consider whether the consequences were strategic, I would just do it.

Because it seems your intent is to make others as afraid as you are regardless of the consequences. Unless it's not, in which case things would probably be a lot more clear if you stopped flip flopping and refusing to define the words you use.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by almaIV on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @08:31PM (#9696636)
"Would it not be better to work towards nobody feeling such fear?"

When you ask questions like this, you give the respondent authority, because it is worded in a way that gives the possibility that the respondent might say something intelligent in response.

There is no such possibility here.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by TheCartographer on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:26PM (#9697287)
>You might be unsurprised to find out that free speech is not valued on the left or among "SJW" groups. I suggest you research this further, because I can't communicate to you in a single hacker news comment why this is, or what theoretical basis it has.

Who needs theory? Practicality tells all.

Extreme ideologies don't value free speech, because free speech allows the unwashed masses to communicate to each other just how ridiculous they think your ideology is. This is true regardless of where an ideology falls on the oversimplistic "right-left" spectrum: North Korea, Fascist Italy, Communist Russia, Oligarchical-Capitalist Russia, Cambodia, North Vietnam, Burma, Communist China, pretty much the entire Middle East, etc. The list goes on and on and on.

Suppress free speech and criminalize dissident thoughts, and you establish a social basis for staying in power - for the good of the people, of course.

It's unsurprising that extreme ideological adherents are always united in at least one common idea, regardless of the actual content of the ideology they are espousing: the belief that people themselves don't know what is best for their own interests and must be closely watched and shepherded (and culled) if they fall into an annoying habit of thinking on their own.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sdfghjkl34567 on Thursday June 11, 2015 @09:36AM (#9699596)
I'm sure you've studied these political ideologies extensively (though my political ideology is pretty obviously very far from the ones you've listed). But it doesn't seem like you've ever questioned the sacred cow that is free speech to you.

I would give you some discussion questions, but I'm sure you'll never, ever move past this roadblock, so I won't feed the trolls.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by TheCartographer on Friday June 12, 2015 @09:39AM (#9705743)
No trolling here. I'm a staunch believer in free speech, no matter how distasteful.

Not because it is a sacred cow, but because I believe the benefits to free speech far outweigh any drawbacks. (For largely the same reasons, I support open data in government to an much further extent than I think most people would.)

Out of curiostity, Mr Throwaway, what -ism do you use to identity your personal ideology?

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by instantgator on Monday June 15, 2015 @03:40PM (#9721507)
>North Korea, Fascist Italy, Communist Russia, Oligarchical-Capitalist Russia, Cambodia, North Vietnam, Burma, Communist China, pretty much the entire Middle East, etc.

>though my political ideology is pretty obviously very far from the ones you've listed

That is very arguable and not obvious at all.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by tjradcliffe on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:17PM (#9696827)
Thanks for the forthright reply!

I've been involved in political activism of one kind or other for decades, mostly in ways that are opposed to your ideals, so I'm not one tiny bit surprised to find a lefty who is opposed to free speech, nor am I unfamiliar with the "theoretical basis" for such abhorent positions.

I wanted to cast as broad a net as possible in my question, as I know how eclectic the left is: the two major Communist parties in my country spent most of their political capital fighting each other while the mainstream drifted gently, and rather too far, to the right.

Your myopia, anger and hatred are unfortunately true to the rightwingnutjob's caricature of anyone interested in building a just society, which makes the job of sane social reformers more difficult. Just so you know (yeah, I know, we're you're enemies too... and it's important to have a comprehensive enemies list, isn't it?)

And while on the one hand I can take heart in the knowledge that you'll never get close to achieving your goals, I'm also saddened that you will spread so much toxicity into your environment on your way to ultimate failure. The world needs more love, not more hate, or more fear.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sdfghjkl34567 on Thursday June 11, 2015 @09:47AM (#9699654)
Yes, communism is certainly a dead horse these days. It's a little disappointing to me, but then I was never an electoralist and would never have taken either of those parties seriously. It's a little hilarious to read "I know how eclectic the left is: there were TWO communist parties in my country!" I suggest you research the left a little more, specifically the libertarian (in the original sense) left.

If you have a specific idea at all about how the world should be better, the people who oppose that are certainly not your friends. I think you're mistaking vision for myopia, dedication for anger, and pragmatism for hatred... but then you certainly hate me more than I hate you.

I'm probably just as unsure as you about whether I'll achieve my goals, but I have to try, because to do anything less would be a betrayal of all of humanity. I believe everyone is responsible for their actions, and so if I'm to be responsible I have to act somehow.

It's very easy to say that "the world needs more love," but love doesn't break bricks, as the saying goes. I doubt your own activism is limited to "love"; you probably do things that are intended to make reality assume some objective state. In doing that, you are preventing your opponents from forcing the world into their preferred state. This is no different from opposing free speech. I just have a more complete vision of the world that I want, and it doesn't include Mein Kampf or Birth of a Nation or hacker news's casual misogyny and racism.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by cactusface on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @07:03PM (#9696255)
> But if I could flip a switch and make every man feel the persistent, gnawing fear that a woman has of men, I would in a heartbeat.

There's not much point in railing against racists / sexists / etc. if you're going to make equally condescending generalizations about the victims you're trying to save.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by almaIV on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @07:00PM (#9696236)
"most modern tumblerites aren't willing to get in the streets with a bandanna and a baseball bat"

Probably because this is a really stupid course of action to begin with, independent of tumblr.

Using baseball bats to reinforce your political views seems like a great idea until your opponents show up with guns. Which means you, now, have to show up with guns, and so on, until you're a full-on terrorist group.

Well, that and you risk going to jail for assault with a deadly weapon, and you don't want to be in the same cell with someone from the Aryan Brotherhood when they find out your reason for jailtime was assaulting white power groups.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by hga on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @07:54PM (#9696484)
Using baseball bats to reinforce your political views seems like a great idea until your opponents show up with guns.

I have to wonder if this dangerous person lives in the US, or at least the true US, the 2/3rds of which allow concealed carry. I marvel at how the National Socialist Movement and some "White Nationalists" thought it wise to meet in New Jersey and Illinois, respectively, where and when it was illegal to carry concealed (not groups of smart people, it would seem :-). Hmmmm, for that matter, Ohio is in one way the worst state in the union for self-defense, because the burden of proof is on the person claiming it. (These incidents mentioned at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Racist_Action)

Try that shit in the state of Missouri where Strange Loop is meeting and you'll very possibly get legally shot. Counterwise the Nazis were greatly aided by prior Weimar efforts at gun control, which they of course reinforced once they started getting formal power.

In fact, all these actions by the left in the US strike me as extremely unwise, for in the many possibilities of "this will not end well", those of a very well armed population putting paid to their pretensions should be quite prominent in their minds.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sdfghjkl34567 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @08:08PM (#9696541)
Do you think that white nationalists don't take guns to their protests and marches? Do you think when the KKK meets, they're unarmed?

It's hilarious to me that you seem to think leftists could set off an arms race.

Also, what do you think the black panthers, weather underground, etc., were?

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by almaIV on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @08:29PM (#9696620)
Were? The black panthers still exist. They have nothing to do with people calling themselves "anti-fascist" though.

"Do you think that white nationalists don't take guns to their protests and marches?"

I think the kind of person who talks about carrying around baseball bats isn't going to go to these marches.

What you think is hilarious is on you and your weird sense of humor. If you go to a meeting with baseball bats, eventually, the people you're disrupting are going to bring weapons stronger than baseball bats.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by hga on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @08:36PM (#9696655)
Hmmm, I wasn't thinking of sdfghjkl34567 and company as cowards, but now that you mention the possibility, maybe it isn't a coincidence that the calm events (not protests and marches) they brought baseball bats (and hammers) to in the US, at least per https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Racist_Action#History were in states where their targets couldn't legally carry guns. It would be interesting to check with Google to see if their targets meet elsewhere relatively unmolested.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sdfghjkl34567 on Thursday June 11, 2015 @10:06AM (#9699764)
The wikipedia history for ARA itself is a pretty reductive list of actions compared to all ARA-aligned actions. Again, I mentioned ARA because they popularized the tactic of shutting down meetings by pressuring hotels (which is not to say they invented secondary target activism), not because it was the only group doing so or for any other specific reason.

Anti-racist and anti-fascist organizing happens under the mantle of a thousand different groups all over the world. There are antifa in Russia that have it much harder than antifa in France or the UK or the US.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by amcastillo on Thursday June 11, 2015 @12:40PM (#9700739)
> Anti-racist and anti-fascist organizing happens under the mantle of a thousand different groups all over the world.

And yet we are asked to believe that an obscure blogger flirting with monarchist political thought would introduce a dangerous authoritarian element if allowed to present on a technical topic. Thanks for putting this into context.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sdfghjkl34567 on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:39PM (#9701828)
I would not call Moldbug obscure; neo-reactionaryism is growing especially in tech circles and legitimizing its source is a dangerous act, not because he will seize power given the platform, but because it communicates a lack of concern with the threat "neo-reactionaryism" or fascism represents.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by anon_adderlan on Sunday June 14, 2015 @10:31PM (#9717195)
> and legitimizing its source is a dangerous act

This thinking, right here, is a problem.

Discussing an individual's technical contributions does not legitimize their political views, let alone their technical ones.

And the big threat today is not neo-reactionaryism, but zealotry in all its forms. Radicals from any group are more dangerous than moderates from a single distasteful group, and they all use exactly the same tactics to win. And if we're going to win by burying bad ideas through threats and intimidation instead of openly dismantling them through rational and ethical thought, then I'm not sure the battle is even worth winning.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by amcastillo on Thursday June 11, 2015 @06:33PM (#9702898)
> neo-reactionaryism is growing especially in tech circles

This will be great news to the neoreactionaries. How do you figure?

> because it communicates a lack of concern with the threat "neo-reactionaryism" or fascism represents.

And what is the threat, if not that they will seize power?

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by eli_gottlieb on Monday June 15, 2015 @01:24PM (#9720709)
Certainly neoreaction is a cancer, but the best cure for these cancers is sunlight.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sdfghjkl34567 on Thursday June 11, 2015 @10:03AM (#9699748)
The "new" black panthers exist, but as a former actual black panther I know says, I don't see their breakfast programs.

Antifa did and do routinely disrupt fascist actions with physical force and frequently got (and get) shot for it. Sometimes the antifa are the ones doing the shooting.

But most of the time the antifa are hilariously underarmed compared to the (as you've pointed out) very well armed rightists and it's a combination of bravado and stupidity that they take the actions they do. The KKK, neo nazis, etc., have all had weapons stronger than baseball bats for a while. There's no "eventually." Do you understand what I'm saying?

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by hga on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @08:17PM (#9696575)
But venues for anti-fascist violence most certainly include "protests at book readings and other events, and also disrupting fascist conferences and similar", or so you seem to be saying, and most certainly per history in the US (e.g. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anti-Racist_Action#History). But as I noted elsewhere, the non-protest/march incidents happened in viciously anti-gun states (although that's no longer true for Illinois), where those using guns to defend themselves from hammers and baseball bats would have gone to jail as well.

Plus, if what you say was true, can you point to some incidents where your side actually, you know, got shot for their troubles? I mean your violent side, not the pre-Black Power civil rights period of this.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by blackbagboys on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @06:57PM (#9696225)
Thank you for confirming my suspicion that if you scratch the surface, all political extremists are motivated by the same all-consuming, destructive nihilism.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by saryant on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @06:59PM (#9696233)
That one clearly does, hence the throwaway.

(edit: parent edited post, this no longer makes sense. Original was about revolutionaries never expecting the guillotine to fall on their own neck)

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sdfghjkl34567 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @08:04PM (#9696522)
Yeah, that wouldn't make very much sense. Far more revolutionaries have been on the guillotine than behind it.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by tjradcliffe on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:19PM (#9696839)
Mostly put there by their fellow-revolutionaries.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sdfghjkl34567 on Thursday June 11, 2015 @09:58AM (#9699709)
Well, it's a high-stakes game. As Benjamin Franklin said, you hang together or your hang separately.

But far more put there by the state, make no mistake. It's not like there haven't been plenty of purges and organized campaigns of systematic repression from the state to the left. But you like ignoring that when we talk about fascist programmers not being able to present their widgets, don't you?

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by i_are_smart on Monday June 15, 2015 @10:21AM (#9719418)
Purges come after the revolutionaries replace the state.

See: The Holocaust The Great Purge The Reign of Terror etc

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by duncan_bayne on Thursday June 11, 2015 @08:21AM (#9699193)
This has to be a false flag. Surely?

"But if I could flip a switch and make every man feel the persistent, gnawing fear that a woman has of men, I would in a heartbeat."

If that's intentional parody, it's brilliant. If not, I guess there's always therapy.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by hga on Thursday June 11, 2015 @09:09AM (#9699438)
No, there really are people out there like that. If you haven't run into one before, you should perhaps consider yourself fortunate, but then again that perhaps limits your view of how evil people can be, especially at the "gut" level, the level that's best at motivating actions or at least preparations.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by defen on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @07:17PM (#9696307)
Ted Kaczynski was wrong about a lot of things, but reading this I can't help but think he was correct in his diagnosis of the ills of modern leftism (power process, feelings of inferiority, oversocialization)
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by convexfunction on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @07:50PM (#9696460)
So you think that being scared is evidence of fascism, misogyny, racism, or similar? No legitimate reasons to think what's happening is terrifying?

How terrifying.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by eli_gottlieb on Monday June 15, 2015 @10:26AM (#9719459)
>You might be unsurprised to find out that free speech is not valued on the left or among "SJW" groups. I suggest you research this further, because I can't communicate to you in a single hacker news comment why this is, or what theoretical basis it has.

Communist here. Fuck you: of course we care about free speech.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by anon_adderlan on Monday June 22, 2015 @04:34PM (#9760997)
> I'm overjoyed that, as you put it, a climate of fear exists for fascists, misogynists, racists, and similar. I hope that this continues and only worsens for these people.

That 'climate of fear' also exists for those people who don't fall into such cleanly vilifiable categories, and yet occasionally engage in language and behavior that could be categorized as such, often unknowingly because those definitions seem to depend on contexts they cannot determine, have different meanings for each individual, and are rapidly being expanded to encompass broader categories of thought and behavior.

> I'm happy for many reasons. The first is that it has, as you've said, made privileged people afraid. I think this is only the beginning. Privilege creates safety, and as it is removed, I think the unsafety of the oppressed will in part come to the currently privileged classes. But if I could flip a switch and make every man feel the persistent, gnawing fear that a woman has of men, I would in a heartbeat. I wouldn't even consider whether the consequences were strategic, I would just do it.

One thing I've noticed about the fearful is that they tend to resent the fearless, and want everyone to live under the same fears they do. It's a very primal thing, as people who fear the same things are part of the same tribe. These fears are not used to achieve anything strategic, but to define the very culture members exist in, and so are vigorously spread and defended regardless of any practical value they may have. In such a culture you will never get beyond that fear. You can see this most readily in religious sects, but many political movements are little other than that.

And regardless of the 'harm' fear prevents, it is still the antithesis of knowledge, and a society ruled by fear cannot be ruled by knowledge. In such a society knowledge itself is a threat, and the only people willing to discuss controversial ideas will either be the ones courageous enough to question or hateful enough not to care. The fearful of course will not be able to tell the difference.

Personally, that is not a price I am willing to pay for a 'safe' society. That doesn't mean such a system is right or wrong, only that it doesn't align with my values. But regardless of differing values, it still troubles me that anyone would take such joy in other people's fear and unsafety, and I don't think any good can come of that.

> So if discourse is permanently removed as a tactical and strategic option for future leftists, I'll consider it a victory.

And yet here you are, using a throwaway account to engage in tactically and strategically driven discourse.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by a8da6b0c91d on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:20PM (#9696845)
> fascist

You keep using that word. I do not think it means what you think it means.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sdfghjkl34567 on Thursday June 11, 2015 @09:32AM (#9699568)
Why is this not gray? I thought hacker news was above memes.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by Sacho on Thursday June 11, 2015 @02:41PM (#9701461)
Personally, I also don't understand what definition of fascism you are using(and another person call you out on it earlier...). Defining it as "the one I've built up in my mind" pretty much means it's noise to me, since it does not carry any information(I have no idea what kind of definition you've built up in your mind).
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sdfghjkl34567 on Thursday June 11, 2015 @03:57PM (#9701950)
It is not possible for anyone to understand what definition of any word anyone is using. Regardless of dictionaries human concepts are organic and subjective and very difficult to communicate. The entirety of human art is based on this concept. If you can see only noise there perhaps you have subsisted on a barren rule-based if-then existence a little too long.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by anon_adderlan on Sunday June 14, 2015 @11:12PM (#9717314)
> It is not possible for anyone to understand what definition of any word anyone is using.

So instead of attempting to clarify what you mean by 'fascism' to further discussion, you effectively declare that the words you use only have meaning to you, making further discussion impossible. I hope then it's acceptable to use the word 'gay' to designate 'lame' (especially among my gay friends), unless you're also stuck in that barren rule based wasteland too.

Words only point to a reality. And while we cannot know the entirety of that reality, it can certainly be made much clearer in this case. Words are useless unless they're communal property and their meanings (sufficiently) shared.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by venomsnake on Thursday June 11, 2015 @04:00PM (#9701970)
Because it is more coherent than your posts.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by anon_adderlan on Sunday June 14, 2015 @10:50PM (#9717256)
Perhaps because it's making a good point in addition to being clever.

Why is it important to you that it be gray? Why are you implying that the status of Hacker News is affected by this?

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sudioStudio64 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @05:28PM (#9695584)
I would say that depending on the area and subject there is also a "freedom justice" crowd that can be just as crazy and groupthink-ish.

I also find myself not posting sometimes because of repercussions at a later date....not too often, but you know...

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by Mithaldu on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @06:55PM (#9696215)
I'm all for Strangeloop canceling his talk, however not for reasons of his political leanings, but because i consider Urbit to be nonsense and the way it handles itself to be dishonest.

That said, this entire conversation has an amazingly suppressive effect on me. This is primarily because i come from east germany, have grown up in its social era until my early teens, and have seen how it changed since the wall fell, and thus consider myself strongly socialist and glad that germany itself still is strongly socialist. I am left.

And i find myself under attack for what i consider to be a human-friendly view. I see talk of leftists, the red guard, communists, etc. etc. etc. and find the american internet to be extraordinarily busy painting what i consider to be my political leaning as "terrorist".

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by sudioStudio64 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @08:59PM (#9696747)
I think it comes from scarcity and changing demographics... there is a very real feel of loss off status and power among the white middle and working class.

You are right about the crazy views on socialism and German politics in general.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by a8da6b0c91d on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @09:28PM (#9696878)
Please provide one example of a person being fired, or otherwise enduring serious economic consequences, for publicly voicing socialist or communist views. There are none. There are dozens of quite recent examples of rightists or libertarians or traditional Christians enduring serious consequences for free speech. In America we once had the red scare where a witch hunt hit socialists/communists. These days we have the "brown scare" hitting anyone right of Jeb Bush.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by theorique on Thursday June 11, 2015 @07:39AM (#9699001)
The following link is an ongoing set of updates of people who have fallen victim to the so-called "brown scare" - being fired, ostracized, or otherwise penalized for holding right-wing views.

It's a lot more pervasive, and has been going on a lot longer than most people think. The Brendan Eich or Pax Dickinson purges are probably the most known to the HN community, but there are many, many more.

https://handleshaus.wordpress.com/2013/12/26/bullied-and-bad...

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by Mithaldu on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:18PM (#9697248)
I'm not very familiar with US politics. When i say attacked, i was primarily talking about the articles talking about strangeloop. (It sounds like you misunderstood me there.)

On the other hand, consider how "Obamacare" was attacked, and (if i understood correctly what came out of your country) changed, cut and successfully damaged, thus affecting wide parts of the US population. ( http://www.galen.org/newsletters/changes-to-obamacare-so-far... )

Also, i find it a little disingenuous to ask for something and in the same breath declare delivery of such impossible.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by a8da6b0c91d on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:26PM (#9697286)
Name one person who was fired for supporting Obamacare. That is the relevant question in relation to your unclear point. I dare say you don't even understand. Name one person who was fired for comments in support of the federal involvement in local police matters in relation to the Treyvon Martin and Michael Brown incidents. The left is in power. The only people getting fired are those in opposition to the left.

With regard to your link I don't know whether you're obtuse or spraying squid ink. The topic under discussion is consequences for voicing free speech.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by Mithaldu on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @11:30PM (#9697303)
Allow me to quote you:

    Please provide one example of a person [...]
    enduring serious economic consequences
To be clear here: People are being damaged through anti-left actions without even needing to have voiced anything. Plus, you can't deny that plenty people are trying to get people fired over this.

As for this:

    Name one person who was fired for comments in support 
    of the federal involvement in local police matters in 
    relation to the Treyvon Martin and Michael Brown 
    incidents. The left is in power.
What exactly was the federal involvement? What exactly was done that would otherwise not have been done? I do not know the details, and do also not understand how any of that connects to left politics. Please educate me.

Edit: I'm sorry for the edits, and i hope you see this post only after i am done editing. One last note on this:

    The topic under discussion is consequences for voicing free speech.
I was answering someone who was asking if people were afraid to speak up on the matter. I am saying, yes, i am, because i see american people who have many listeners brand me indirectly but surprisingly aggressively for my beliefs.
Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by jbigelow76 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @05:11PM (#9695431)
I'm surprised by apparent predominance of support here on HN for Strangeloop's position.

Do you not recall the self-immolation of the Mozilla Community during the Brendan Eich CEO fiasco? Big overlap in the two communities.

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by Castlereagh on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @05:03PM (#9695359)
Do those who support Curtis appearing at the talk (wisely?) refrain from posting out of (legitimate?) fear of career repercussion?

This. It also has the perverse effect of leaving the defense of "racists" to actual racists (e.g., [1]), thereby leading to guilt by association: "See, only racists are willing to defend this guy, so he's obviously a racist!"

[1]: https://twitter.com/B8GodDante/status/607201146017615872

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by theorique on Thursday June 11, 2015 @05:28AM (#9698592)
More recently, perhaps within the past year or two, I've been seeing online a polarization and evaporative cooling effect in action. There doesn't seem to be as much middle ground and nuance as there has been in the past. Any support or acceptance for an officially disapproved entity is tantamount to total or unqualified support or acceptance.

Many moderates - in this case, moderate supporters of Yarvin, as shown in the comments here - appear to be fearful of getting tarred with the scarlet "R" and facing career threat. The scarlet "S" and "M" are also significant.

In contrast, the "C" is not threatened nowadays, if it ever was. Left-wing extremism is given a pass, while right-wing extremism is always tarred with the "R" brush. People rarely use the "F" word - they just default to "R", which is far more damaging.

(I mean: racist / sexist / misogynist / communist / fascist above.)

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by hga on Thursday June 11, 2015 @09:19AM (#9699499)
You can expand the above a bit by distinguishing between "c", "I, Steven Klabnik, am 'a communist' as the simplest thing to describe me", vs. "C", "I, Julius Rosenberg, became a member of the US Communist Party when it was popular, required careful vetting and submission to party discipline, which by definition made me a traitor."

And this reminds me of a quote by the not moderate Jim Hightower, "There's nothing in the middle of the road but a yellow stripe and dead armadillos."

Re:Two Kinds of Freedom of Speech (or Strangeloop vs. Curtis... by cactusface on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @06:29PM (#9696072)
> While clearly legal, it's strikes me as a terrible precedent to require speakers on technical topics to pass a political litmus test.

It's funny, in some countries you have laws against hate speech - it probably wouldn't be legal to write stuff like "blacks make good slaves because of their genetics" [sic] - but in the US because of the free speech thing society relies on all these extrajudicial lynch mobs. So... terrible precedent or common sense?