News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Indian Programmer Exposes Code Injection, Gets a Cease an... by derefr on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @03:23PM (#9694671)
"Just because", no. But:

1. The server has no access restrictions for the Javascript URL, presumably. So, if you trust the server's configuration to match the owner's intent, then the owner was saying "this page is intended for public consumption."

Which is to say, importantly, not only for their customers to view in exchange for their subscription fees (which would put the ad-injector script under license of whatever TOS the customers agreed to), but rather for anyone to view who has no prior relationship with them, for any purpose.

This is the "reproductions are allowed of works of artistic craftsmanship (buildings, sculptures, etc.) that are permanently situated in a public place or in premises open to the public" argument.

2. The owner never put a copyright claim against anyone else making copies of this work. Like the Internet Archive's copy of their website, say (if there is one.) That would suggest this takedown notice is a motivated use of copyright law to attack someone, rather than business-as-usual of them enforcing their IP.

Judges don't like it when you have a history of not caring about people doing something you could have complained about. They take that as evidence you don't care.

3. Fair use! This is a:

• transformative use (it's visible source code, not an executing program!),

• of a small part of their copyrighted work (it's just the Javascript!),

• intended for a purpose that could be said to be both parody (revealing a previously-unnoticed essence of the original work through transformation) and edification (teaching people that the network is doing this thing.)

There's probably even more arguments than these. I hope the poster takes some of them to Github with a counter-takedown to get their repo back up.

Re:Indian Programmer Exposes Code Injection, Gets a Cease an... by wvenable on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @04:08PM (#9694939)
> The server has no access restrictions for the Javascript URL, presumably. So, if you trust the server's configuration to match the owner's intent, then the owner was saying "this page is intended for public consumption."

That argument did not help weev with AT&T. If they are distributing the code, they are allowed to do that as the copyright owner. That's why it's called copyright. But that doesn't grant anyone else the right to distribute the content. By your argument, any content posted anywhere publicly on the Internet is not subject to copyright restrictions. Which is clearly not the case.

> The owner never put a copyright claim against anyone else making copies of this work.

It's unlikely they are aware of anyone else distributing their work. This may be the only unauthorized distribution of this work so far.

> transformative use (it's visible source code, not an executing program!),

There is nothing transformative about this.

> of a small part of their copyrighted work (it's just the Javascript!),

It must be very small; an excerpt. This is not an excerpt of the program.

> There's probably even more arguments than these.

If they're of the same quality they're unlikely to make a difference. These are poor arguments. Fair use never* applies to copying a complete work.

* It's perhaps possible; but this case certainly doesn't qualify.

Re:Indian Programmer Exposes Code Injection, Gets a Cease an... by belorn on Thursday June 11, 2015 @07:07AM (#9698887)
It also didn't help in a famous piracy case in Sweden where people shared paid web streamed sports that didn't have any access restrictions. Since the cable company intended for the web pages to be access only by paying customers, sharing them was seen as infringing copyright.