News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by vonklaus on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @06:29PM (#9688924)
As someone who just switched to Linux from OS X, it is really hard to migrate. I miss the subtleties of the apple ecosystem. Sure Linux is awesome, but I have been battling trackpad support issues, keymapping the super_key to CMD, and just general battling the UX.

tl;dr a more powerful operating system with worse UI, which is the obvious trade. A less powerful system with a fantastic UI.

Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by wjoe on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @08:26AM (#9691538)
As someone who uses Linux for everything but just had to start using OS X for work, it's really hard to migrate. Remapping ctrl to cmd and various other keyboard oddities, unfamiliar mouse acceleration, and missing features like middle click to paste and holding alt to drag windows. Various other things that I'm able to customise to my liking in Linux, but are much harder to modify in OS X.

Chances are you're going to think that the thing you've been using for years is "good UI", and anything different is "bad UI". I don't doubt that Apple have spent a lot of time designing their UI/UX to work well for most people, but it feels bad to me because it's not what I'm used to.

Either way, you get used to it. I've found programs that make OS X work in a way that's more familar to me, and learned to work with the things I can't change.

Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by dripton on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @08:04PM (#9689332)
UI is subjective. I get mildly annoyed whenever I use a Mac. Little things like having to click on a window to give it focus, or having to use command instead of control in many programs, break my flow. I'd probably get used to those if I only used a Mac, but since I use Linux 95% of the time and Mac 5%, I never do.
Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by globuous on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @07:56AM (#9691367)
Honestly, i don't mind the window focusing on mac. What I absolutely fucking hate though, is working on Windows and not being able to scroll on a window that's not active. By default on Mac, if a window's focused, you can scroll another (unfocused) window by scrolling when you mouse is over it. Without having to refocus windows, which is really nice when you're typing something on the focused window.

As for the cmd button replacing the ctrl button. Never going back to ctrl+<key> for shortcuts. The command button is so much nicer to use, it's your thumb vs you pinky. You don't need to stretch you pinky/move you hand slightly to have access to shortcuts and that's so nice. VERY desturbing at first (I hated it), but never going back. Or maybe I've just gotten used to using my thumb. Ultimately, I think it makes a lot more sense though. No more alt-F4 to close windows, its cmd+Q, no more ctrl+B to bold a text, it's cmd+b, cmd+h minimizes/hides your window etc etc.

Also, what i found infinitely annoying at first and that I really like now on Mac, is the window switching with the keyboard. On Windows, alt+tab switches between all windows (including different instances of same program). on Mac, alt+tab switches between applications and alt+` switches between different instances of a said program. I find that more elegant when you have a lot of windows opened, which i always have.

But all these are tiny little things that add up to something really nice to use, but each individually don't and will never justify OS X being the best OS in the world blah blah. You can probably achieve a similar behavior on windows/Linux/whatever. What's nice about it though is that it's the default setup, no third party app needed/config files. You install it and it makes sense. That's why I'm not switching from OS X anytime soon, it's ergonomic, the UI is sick, power user features everywhere, and a real unix. I see it as a linux that works perfectly out of the box. I remember the first month I spent on OS X (coming from 4 years of linux, 2 yr Ubuntu and 2 yr Arch, using both full desktop env (KDE mostly) and lightweigth window managers), everything works and works well and everything is ergonomic and makes sense. Put simply, a Mac never (or very rarely) gets in the way of your work. And that makes a big difference.

But then, I just like Macs because of how I use my computer. I get it that some might prefer a Linux or Windows, and I respect that. I'm just extremely thankful OS X answers exactly what I expect from a computer.

Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by e_proxus on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @10:18AM (#9692354)
For Windows, Katmouse alleviates some of the pain of scroll focus: http://ehiti.de/katmouse/
Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by fastball on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @10:32PM (#9689738)
Wait how else do you give windows focus?

You mean like with the keyboard? Like SHIFT+TAB? That's on OS X.

Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by mouhtasi on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @10:35PM (#9689752)
I believe some window managers give the option of automatically focusing to the window under the cursor.
Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by endgame on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @10:58PM (#9689823)
And once you're used to it you'll never want to go back. All of my experiences with focus-follow-mouse on commercial OSes have been almost-but-not-quite right.
Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by eropple on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @01:28AM (#9690244)
> And once you're used to it you'll never want to go back.

Eh. I've used focus-follows-mouse and tend instead to strongly prefer the OS X method of allowing scroll events to percolate to the window under the cursor but retaining keyboard focus on the window it's currently in. This allows me to scroll, say, a web browser on my right-hand monitor, while continuing to type in the left.

Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by tehwalrus on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @03:52AM (#9690580)
Hover-focus is great on tiling window managers, but I'm not sure I'd react well to it where windows overlap by design.

Also, don't forget that OS X lets you scroll whatever window your mouse is over, even if it is "blurred" (not in focus). This is the one feature that I miss most whenever I need to use Windows.

Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by chimprich on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @04:23AM (#9690660)
There's a couple of free Windows programs that compensate for this. http://superuser.com/questions/110700/making-a-mouse-scroll-...
Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by 7Z7 on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @07:14AM (#9691197)
I, and many of the thousand or so Linux users at my company, disagree!

The only people here who really seem to like it are the ones using drawing-tablets as their main input.

Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by bubblesorting on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @11:36PM (#9689912)
Focus-follows-mouse doesn't work so great in OSX because of the global menubar, everywhere else it's great though!
Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by aerique on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @06:38PM (#9688985)
It's a phase. I run into similar issues when using OSX while being used to Linux.
Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by xur17 on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @07:24PM (#9689178)
I went through a similar struggle when switching to a Mac about a year ago for work. I still miss the ability to drag windows around from anywhere by holding the alt key, and dragging any part of the window.

Never found a good replacement in OSX.

Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by donut2d on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @11:43PM (#9689932)
You can do the same non-focused window dragging in OSX by holding down command. Actually, you can interact with the unfocused window when holding down command, click buttons, etc.
Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by geon on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:30AM (#9690047)
Dragging overlapping windows is a stupid idea to begin with. I use a keyboard based window manager as much as possible (Spectacle), and with splitscreen I can hopefully almost completely stop using windows.
Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by yoz-y on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @01:52AM (#9690310)
Overlapping windows is what makes mouse based interaction fast. Not everybody wants to use keyboard all the time. Also, often times it is useful to have more than two windows on screen at a time.
Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by geon on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @07:45AM (#9691320)
> Overlapping windows is what makes mouse based interaction fast.

How does the overlappingness make anything faster? If anything it becomes slower, because you need to move windows out of the way, or select them before you can get to the covered part.

> Not everybody wants to use keyboard all the time

In no way necessary. I don't think the WWDC splitscreen demo used keyboard shortcuts at all?

> it is useful to have more than two windows on screen at a time.

Having more than one window on the screen is also not helped by the windows overlapping. I regularly have 2-4 windows side-by-side on the same screen at once without overlapping, and multiple such screens and fullscreen windows on virtual desktops.

Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by wjoe on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @08:12AM (#9691444)
I use HyperDock for this: http://hyperdock.bahoom.com/

It's mainly focused on modifications for the OS X dock which I don't use, but it also does alt drag window movement, and alt + num pad for tiling windows. It costs a a bit of money after a trial period, but it's the most reliable replacement for alt drag I've found so far.

Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by vonklaus on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @07:56PM (#9689309)
haha. You guys must be right. That is the exact functionality that is the most annoying for me right now! I need to get used to this new OS. I miss 3 finger swipe right. ctrl+alt+shift+ [direction] is quite a macro just to move a screen.
Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by aerique on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @08:52AM (#9691699)
Realize that what you mean with "to get used to this new OS" is possibly "I need to get used to this desktop environment / window manager". I don't know what desktop environment you use but it is possibly Ubuntu's Unity, Gnome or KDE.

On Unix you have a lot of choice on the (graphical) interface you chose to interact with. So while to one you're currently using might be OK, there's bound to be one that's even better suited to your needs.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Window_manager

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Desktop_environment

(Also, it's usually trivial to change your keybindings.)

Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by vonklaus on Wednesday June 10, 2015 @12:00PM (#9693169)
yep thanks. I run ParrotOS which is basically debian with some slick UI and pentesting toolsets. It is a gnome desktop enviro. I will check those links out. The keybindings did not hold on the tut I followed, no biggie. My major point is that I am a mac superuser, but when I switch windows I have to manually deselect a window (because it follows me). It is just absorbing the nuances of linux and inculcating the macros into my head.

It is like switching from JS to Ruby for me.

Re:Show HN: Universal Pause Button by girvo on Tuesday June 09, 2015 @09:07PM (#9689501)
I personally changed that to be Super+<Arrow> to change virtual desktop, and Super+Shift+<Arrow> to move the focused window to it. Much nicer shortcut, IMO. Elementary OS[0] uses that by default, actually.

[0] https://elementary.io/