Re:Tested in the field: Will monkeys type shakespeare?
by astine on Monday November 30, 2009 @06:59PM
(#968968)
And perhaps the things to take away from this is that just because the probability of an event is zero, that doesn't mean the event can't happen.
Ah! That does seem to be the take-away here. In that case, however, how would you measure the probability of an impossible event?
I still maintain that an invinite number of dead monkeys would never type Shakespeare, no matter the resources alloted to them. :)
My example about the ranges was an attempt to show that the otherwise excellent ideas from the finite world simply don't apply, so you have to do something else. You suggested that ...
... and that's what I was refuting.And perhaps the things to take away from this is that just because the probability of an event is zero, that doesn't mean the event can't happen. Talking about the probability being "infinitesimally small" requires that you make a whole pile of other definitions precise, and that way lies madness. Or at least, non-standard analysis, which is pretty close to the same thing.
In my opinion it doesn't help the understanding of the "interested layman."
All this, of course, is only valid in the theoretical musings of mathematicians (or those doing math at the time) In the "real world" it's all different again.
Doing this sort of thing correctly and consistently is hard.