News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The double life of Hasidic atheists by ars on Monday June 08, 2015 @02:50AM (#9677558)
Belief in God is certainly important. But action is more important than belief.

> All the actions and commandments are tools for reaching spiritual connection and understand G-d with more clarity.

And if you do that, and skip the action because you feel you have the spiritual connection you failed. But if you did the action, but did not have any special spiritual feeling, you still did what God wants, and that's what counts.

> The quote you reference, which for the life of me, I cannot recall as being accurate...certainly only means that behavior can influence belief.

It's from Pesachim 50b (among other places) if you want to look it up.

> The idea that Judaism is more concerned with action over thought is patently FALSE!

No. It's not. Thought it important, but action is what matters.

Re:The double life of Hasidic atheists by measure4 on Monday June 08, 2015 @07:15AM (#9678254)
I assume that the quote from Pesachim 50b that you are referring to is "metoch shlo lishma bah lishma", which means that if you do what G-d commanded for your own sake (because G-d will reward you), then you'll eventually come to do it for his sake. This is talking about someone who actually believes they are doing what G-d commanded. I have never heard it interpreted as someone who doesn't believe at all. The talmud says that "mitzvos tzrichus kevanah". In order to actually perform what G-d commanded, you have to realize and recognize that you are doing what G-d commanded. Without any belief in G-d, no matter what actions you do, Judaism teaches that you are not doing anything at all. Judaism is a religion of thought and action. If you have a complete lack of one of those two things, you are not observing the religion whatsoever.