Re:The double life of Hasidic atheists
by ars on Monday June 08, 2015 @02:39AM
(#9677528)
> A hard-line "nothing less than absolute and total devotion is even worth considering, and therefore fundamentally not worth your time" is not.
Judaism is about how to have a relationship with God. How can a human hope to do that? By doing what God asked. But also by arguing over what God wants.
It's like how do you have a relationship with a person you never met? By reading his writings.
The atheists in the story probably spend more time thinking about God than a regular member. By doing what God wants (the actions), and by thinking about him constantly, they probably have a deeper relationship with God than others do.
> But, just, if you ever wonder why it is shrinking instead of growing- FYI.
Judaism is not looking for converts. If you want to convert you can, but Judaism isn't going to try to convince you, or tell you your path in life is wrong. Non-Jews can live perfectly meaningful lives.
Judaism is about how to have a relationship with God. How can a human hope to do that? By doing what God asked. But also by arguing over what God wants.
It's like how do you have a relationship with a person you never met? By reading his writings.
The atheists in the story probably spend more time thinking about God than a regular member. By doing what God wants (the actions), and by thinking about him constantly, they probably have a deeper relationship with God than others do.
> But, just, if you ever wonder why it is shrinking instead of growing- FYI.
Judaism is not looking for converts. If you want to convert you can, but Judaism isn't going to try to convince you, or tell you your path in life is wrong. Non-Jews can live perfectly meaningful lives.