Edit for clarity: by larger/more populous I mean the x-axis on the graphs in the paper, though I forgot that this is only Republican voters and Republican/Democrat split in the precinct is also a factor. The x-axis doesn't necessarily mean rural to urban.
> Some argue that more liberal candidates are more popular in urban than in the rural precincts. To verify this hypothesis, we drew geographically random samples of precincts and computed partial correlations to filter out the population density factor. We will demonstrate in this paper that this factor has no impact on our conclusions.
Perhaps it's due to gerrymandered districts, republican vs democratic districts, large farm districts vs small towns, small towns vs large cities, or some other factor we can't think of in a few minutes.
The authors should rule out a lot more possible explanations before alleging fraud.
Some argue that more liberal candidates are more popular in urban than in the rural precincts. To verify this hypothesis, we drew geographically random samples of precincts and computed partial correlations to filter out the population density factor. We will demonstrate in this paper that this factor has no impact on our conclusions.
I'll have to look at this in more detail when I have time.
Note also that just a few races have to be flipped, "momentum" is really critical. For instance, if they're correct and Romney didn't win New Hampshire, it's very easy to imagine him never getting decisive traction no matter how much money he threw into the campaign (one analysis I recently read noted he campaigned for dollars rather than votes, which of course was telling in the end).
Googling now, all I seem able to find is various media articles and no independent statistical responses. The only followup seems to be http://www.kansas.com/news/politics-government/article171398... but, in a version of 'proving too much', that raises more questions for me than it answers by indicating that they've found the phenomenon to be much more general than 'Republican primaries in one year' (for starters, rereading the paper, I'm not sure I buy the foundational claim: why would there be any trend of vote bias with precinct, why wouldn't these supposed biases be simply implemented as a randomized flip on each vote, which would rig the election without leaving any noticeable sign? And think of the logistics: how can all these states and races have been rigged - what, did they all buy the exact same model of Diebold voting machines back in 2007?) This sounds like some sort of demographic or statistical artifact; they say they control for the obvious demographic and precinct-level issues, but of course, you never measure or correctly model everything.