Re:Leaked emails won't harm UN climate body, says chairman
by patio11 on Sunday November 29, 2009 @11:27PM
(#967326)
I would very much have preferred for this information to come to light via the legal way for exposing it: a FOI request. Unfortunately, there seems to have been a consp^H^H^H^H^H intentionally organized effort to defeat FOI requests. That makes things sort of a catch-22. (I am starting to believe the theory that this archive was prepared for a FOI request, quashed, and then leaked by a whistleblower. The argument that cinched it for me: how the heck did somebody get a random dump of emails and documents with the ratio of work : personal : spam looking like infinity: negligible: negligible? Either our mysterious hacker has OCD or someone was pretty careful when collecting this data.
I don't think this is it. There is a system for exposing confidential correspondence to the public; it's called a trial. If there is reasonable suspicion that fraud is going on (and lying about your data to get more research money is fraud), then charges can be filed, and the internal emails can be legally obtained. (Or, a condition of receiving research money can be that all your emails must be made public.) Some Random Hackers breaking into private computer systems, though, is not acceptable, no matter how noble the goal. Some judicial oversight is necessary to protect the researchers. (Even criminals deserve privacy.)