News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by sktrdie on Saturday June 06, 2015 @09:28AM (#9670722)
Meh... Semantic Web is a field... it's like hating natural language processing or distributed systems for not having achieved much over the past 10 years. But the fact is they provide strong theoretical foundations for us to develop killer apps on top of.
Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by epistasis on Saturday June 06, 2015 @11:51AM (#9671175)
No, it's not, because NLP and distributed systems are producing useful artifacts that help influence the world in positive ways.

Semantic Web is a field that is obsessed with theory, without producing any useful theory, nor any practical artifacts that can be used.

Hating entire fields is an entirely reasonable thing to do when they are not productive and when they draw attention away from more useful activities. And it's quite possible for social dynamics to do that, for the wrong thing to become en vogue, and for really wrong paths to be followed for long periods of time. And it's entirely possible to study something that's actually nothing, such as alchemy. Perfectly fine to hate the field of alchemy.

Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by sktrdie on Saturday June 06, 2015 @01:59PM (#9671626)
I beg to differ. Being a semantic web researcher myself, I can tell you that it has produced many relevant theories and artifacts that do help influence the world in positive ways. Here's a few to get you started:

http://linkeddatafragments.org/ - allows to query several "semantic web" datasets at runtime by issuing several concurrent HTTP requests

http://www.rdfhdt.org/ - allows to store graph-like data in a very compressed format that is queryable directly in memory

http://events.linkeddata.org/ldow2015/papers/ldow2015_paper_... - (shameless plug) allows you to query and browse semantic datasets (hosted by different people on different servers) on the web using keywords

The fact that they're not useful to you does not make the entire field useless.

Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by ma2rten on Saturday June 06, 2015 @10:10AM (#9670853)
What strong theoretical foundations do they provide? (this is a genuine question)
Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by sktrdie on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:03PM (#9671642)
Please have a look at last weeks ESWC program (one of the top semantic web conferences): http://2015.eswc-conferences.org/program/accepted-papers

Foundations such as query federation, graph compression (HDT), reasoning, data integration and much much more.

Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by DyslexicAtheist on Saturday June 06, 2015 @10:53AM (#9670982)
CSS/HTML, and its syntax validators, DOM, RDF, HTTP, MathML, PNG, heck here is a full list:

http://www.w3.org/TR/

Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by lambda on Saturday June 06, 2015 @12:58PM (#9671429)
CSS/HTML are not meaningfully semantic; they encode presentational attributes of documents and applications. Syntax validation is not semantic; it's syntactic. DOM is not either; it's an API for manipulating HTML, generally used for presentational purposes. RDF is designed for semantics, but no one of interest uses it. HTTP is a transport protocol; it's a way to take an opaque URL plus some persistent state and get a blob of text or binary data back, along with just the barest of semantics about which requests are intended to make persistent changes server side. MathML is this weird semantic/presentational hybrid, of which I have only ever seen the presentational side used; I am aware of no real-world systems that produce or consume the semantic subset of MathML. PNG is an image encoding format.

So out of all of that, RDF and MathML are the only things that even attempt to define any kind of semantic encoding, and as far as I can tell they completely fail at that in the real world. For the vast majority of real world services, if you want to extract semantic data out of them you use JSON.

Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by icebraining on Saturday June 06, 2015 @06:29PM (#9672552)
For the vast majority of real world services, if you want to extract semantic data out of them you use JSON.

JSON is just the encoding, not the data model; it doesn't work at the same level. That's why RDF/JSON and JSON-LD exist.

Without disputing the idea that the implementation of the Semantic Web is a failure, this idea that JSON (or XML, for that matter) is a data format is holding us back. Every provider is saying that they output in a "standard" format (JSON), while we keep writing new clients for each and every service out there, because every data format is different and it's impossible to write common handlers.

Except for a few attributes, a Github user and a HN user could have the same structure, since conceptually they're quite similar concepts. Yet, try handling [1] and [2] with the same code.

The regular claim that programmers can handle more abstraction than regular people just sounds like a sad joke whenever I think about the shortsightedness and lack of self-awareness that has led to the current situation.

[1] https://hacker-news.firebaseio.com/v0/user/jl.json?print=pre...

[2] https://api.github.com/users/octocat

Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by nitwit005 on Sunday June 07, 2015 @02:13AM (#9673605)
Github users are tied to social interaction, job hiring, integration with multiple version control systems, and a pile of other crap, including systems not part of the website itself. Hacker News users are pretty much just tied to posts and comments on the site.

The only piece of data that seems in common is that they both have user names.

There is no reason user data should be similar across different systems. Products are generally unique, or they don't have much value. That means the data tied to a user is often also unique.

Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by icebraining on Sunday June 07, 2015 @05:11AM (#9673939)
Each site has a set of attributes, which partially overlaps. The data formats should reflect this, allowing for software clients that know the base attributes to interact with both, while still having their non-overlapping attributes. Why can't I add both profiles to my PIM software without special adapters?

This is what RDF allows you to do: instead of designing a custom format, or being tied to a rigid standard one, you can simply add standard attributes to the element in an ad-hoc fashion, so the client can use whatever attributes it supports while allowing for the ones it doesn't. And if there is no standard attribute, fine, you can add custom ones as well.

There's no reason the same code shouldn't be able to process HN, Slashdot and Reddit threads, for example - and even a Github issue.

Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by icebraining on Saturday June 06, 2015 @11:07AM (#9671027)
W3 != Semantic Web.
Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by DyslexicAtheist on Saturday June 06, 2015 @11:21AM (#9671077)
The question was "What strong theoretical foundations do they provide? (this is genuine question)" which "they" I assumed referred to the W3C.

http://www.w3.org/standards/semanticweb/

Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by ma2rten on Saturday June 06, 2015 @12:05PM (#9671240)
I should have said "it" not "they". I was referring to the academic field. I guess I was thinking about people in the field when I wrote "they".

The parent post said "they provide" but it was referring to multiple fields.

Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by pestaa on Saturday June 06, 2015 @11:11AM (#9671042)
No, but they continue to think about the problem and produce useful recommendations.
Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by DyslexicAtheist on Saturday June 06, 2015 @10:55AM (#9670990)
he actually admitted in the comments that the title was clickbait. the value of the article for me was the insight into the inner workings of the W3C.
Re:JSON-LD and Why I Hate the Semantic Web (2014) by sktrdie on Saturday June 06, 2015 @02:04PM (#9671645)
W3C is a standard body. The semantic web is a research field. Different things.