Years ago, I dropped out my junior year of high school to be a junior sysadmin at webdev shop in Chicago. I was 17, had worked there for about 6 months, and summer was ending (this was around '99; right before the dotcom collapse).
I could've chosen to go back to high school, but I didn't see the point. I was learning far more in the real world. To get this job though, my boss (who I'll never forget, and to this day appreciate the chance he gave me) had to take a leap of faith. He was hiring a kid with no real work experience, no degree, no proof he knew what he was talking about besides the pictures of his breadracks in his basement with x86 machines networked and crunching through DES keys for distributed.net (which was the style at the time).
Once you get your foot in the door though, the sky is the limit. I've had the opportunity to work on some amazing products and technologies, private and academic, all because I had a few years of experience when it came time to apply at those jobs (after a few years, no one asks about your education if you know what you're doing, and if they do, you probably don't want to work there anyway).
You can most definitely use a portfolio or knowledge in lieu of a college degree. You may have to knock on more doors, you may get turned away from more places, but you'll still be able to get hired.
The more relevant question is this: is it easier to succeed without an education than it is to get an education?
Even now after having worked as a programmer for 15 years and as a department head or founder for 7 of those years I'm planning on starting back on a CS program next year just to have the experience of having done it and the chance to focus on studying topics I wouldn't normally think of in my day to day.
"Project Euler is a series of challenging mathematical/computer programming problems that will require more than just mathematical insights to solve. Although mathematics will help you arrive at elegant and efficient methods, the use of a computer and programming skills will be required to solve most problems.
The motivation for starting Project Euler, and its continuation, is to provide a platform for the inquiring mind to delve into unfamiliar areas and learn new concepts in a fun and recreational context."
In IT? I'd argue without, most definitely. For example, no one teaches DevOps, and a CS degree would've been a waste while doing it.
Without an education, you're in a vast sea of options, and little means to tell what you are capable of.
Of course, if you already have a job, what difference does it make? You aren't going to learn DevOps sitting on your laptop at home, either. So of course, if you assume the conclusion, the means don't matter.
Or as the saying goes: "Education is for those who give orders; training is for those who take them."
To think you need a college education to lead or, as you said, "give orders" is preposterous.
Do you think someone who had a career at that age had less or more responsibility than someone in college?
I still had the experience of first time being on my own though since I moved overseas for my first tech job.
Hiring right out of HS would have been a higher risk in my mind
Problem is, college is synonymous with gaining maturity, since for many, its the first time they're truly on their own. Responsible for their own grades, responsible for day to day life, responsible for projects and outcomes. Being able to handle your life, handle deadlines, not think you can boil the ocean - is very important for me as a manager. Having a bit of higher education under your belt gives me a warm fuzzy feeling (maybe wrongfully so) that you can hack it in the real world.
There are exceptions, but the stereotypes do fit most of the time.