News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: Things I Learned about Credit Bureaus This Week by jaworrom on Thursday June 04, 2015 @02:30PM (#9661151)
Anybody want to tackle this (seemingly large) problem that we have with credit bureaus? I'd be more than happy to try and dethrone the credit bureau beasts with a new, helpful, transparent service that folks actually enjoy.
Re:Tell HN: Things I Learned about Credit Bureaus This Week by AreaGuy on Thursday June 04, 2015 @03:04PM (#9661360)
The best way to do this is to create a more accurate credit prediction system. Underwriters rely on credit scores because they’re cheap, quick, and easy way to triage risk. Credit scores are riddled with inaccuracies, but because risk is difficult to model precisely to begin with, these companies are still in business because they work decently well even despite the many errors.

If you could create a system using publicly available data that is a statistically and meaningfully superior way of predicting risk, it would be immensely valuable to the asset owners that are buying mortgages, insurance products etc. that rely on credit scores. You’d have to get them to demand it enough to change their underwriting guidelines (a morass of bureaucracy), but once they do, you’d also gain some steady demand and a moat of competitive advantage.

Re:Tell HN: Things I Learned about Credit Bureaus This Week by crxgames on Thursday June 04, 2015 @04:38PM (#9661878)
Some payday lenders already have their own prediction systems in place using scraped public data. The problem that arises is that due to regulation, credit decisions cannot be made based on certain information. I'm sure this varies across sectors of finance though.
Re:Tell HN: Things I Learned about Credit Bureaus This Week by fweespeech on Thursday June 04, 2015 @03:17PM (#9661426)
> If you could create a system using publicly available data

The problem is, making people's financial transaction data public is essentially illegal and represents a competitive advantage.

You'd have to start with convincing major banks / credit issuers to report people to you. With that data, you could build what you suggest. The real hurdle is convincing people to do that and complying with the regulations.

Re:Tell HN: Things I Learned about Credit Bureaus This Week by rahimnathwani on Friday June 05, 2015 @03:44AM (#9664345)
"Credit scores are riddled with inaccuracies"

Are you mixing up credit scores and credit histories?

"If you could create a system using publicly available data that is a statistically and meaningfully superior way of predicting risk"

That's what underwriters at banks and other lenders try to do, albeit with not just publicly available data.

Re:Tell HN: Things I Learned about Credit Bureaus This Week by jedberg on Thursday June 04, 2015 @03:28PM (#9661485)
I heard of a company that was just starting up that plans to offer credit scores based solely on your Facebook, linkedin, twitter, etc. profiles. Be interesting to see if they get traction.