News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Haunting message penned from Soviet 'slaves' found buried... by tptacek on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @12:52PM (#9653970)
US prison labor isn't usefully comparable to Soviet slave labor.

It was also not helpful of you to post a story from 2010 about a Georgia prison strike in response to this article (and I'm a little surprised it got upvoted so much before being flagged off the front page):

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9653515

Re:Haunting message penned from Soviet 'slaves' found buried... by tjradcliffe on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @01:29PM (#9654327)
The responses here show a depressing ignorance of the Soviet era, which was a time of massive industrialization using a system of forced labour. Western apologists for Stalinism continued to tout the "success" of this project right up to the fall of the Soviet Union.

It is good we are still able to hear the voices of the dead from the Gulag, not just to be reminded of who they were and how they died as a result of deliberate Soviet policy, but to be reminded of how badly misunderstood and misremembered the horrors of that policy are.

If the US prison system deliberately killed millions of people over decades by systematic intent to create industrial infrastructure in a nation previously dominated by peasant farming it would be comparable. Otherwise, not so much.

That the Soviet system deliberately killed millions of people over decades is not in dispute. The purpose of the Gulag is well-documented. But there are as always Denialists who will believe what they want and claim anything they think is remotely plausible to justify it.

http://www.amazon.com/Gulag-Archipelago-Abridged-Experiment-...

Re:Haunting message penned from Soviet 'slaves' found buried... by CWuestefeld on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @01:24PM (#9654272)
The labor performed by prisoners of the US prison system isn't comparable, you're right. But given that the US imprisons at a vastly higher rate than the rest of the world, and:

Over all, there are now more people under “correctional supervision” in America—more than six million—than were in the Gulag Archipelago under Stalin at its height. [1]

That, I think, is a useful comparison, and one that we should be making and asking questions about.

[1] http://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2012/01/30/the-caging-of-a...

Re:Haunting message penned from Soviet 'slaves' found buried... by tptacek on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:39PM (#9654816)
We can play "Six Degrees Of Kevin Bacon" with this and connect injustices in the US to virtually any story through virtually any starting point. For instance, you could just as convincingly have argued:

"But given that economic inequality in the US is so high, and given the demographics of the kinds of people sent to prisons, we should be asking questions about the parallels between Soviet slave labor and US prisons."

Re:Haunting message penned from Soviet 'slaves' found buried... by CWuestefeld on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @05:53PM (#9656142)
So you argue (at the risk of putting words in your mouth: "you can't compare USA and USSR prison camp systems because the work conditions are hugely different".

Then I respond: "but the systems are similar in the way they both grabbed unprecedented levels of citizens, and possibly the justice of their convictions".

Why are the dots you've decided to connect the right ones, while the dots that I think are important are just playing a game?

Re:Haunting message penned from Soviet 'slaves' found buried... by tptacek on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @08:00PM (#9656680)
The overwhelming majority of US prisoners do not do work for the direct benefit of the population at large.
Re:Haunting message penned from Soviet 'slaves' found buried... by CWuestefeld on Thursday June 04, 2015 @11:06AM (#9659757)
Although the Gulag system was intended to be an engine of productivity in the USSR, that goal was never achieved. Throughout its history, the work camps were never profitable, they never carried their own weight. So it's hard to say that in the USSR, the work camps were benefiting the population at large.
Re:Haunting message penned from Soviet 'slaves' found buried... by MrZongle2 on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @12:57PM (#9654020)
When the warts of Russian history are being discussed, you'd be surprised what aspects of American culture (present or past) are suddenly considered comparable.
Re:Haunting message penned from Soviet 'slaves' found buried... by idlewords on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @01:13PM (#9654172)
This was a routine dodge in Soviet times. If you brought up human rights violations or the gulag to a Soviet diplomat, you'd get an earful about racial discrimination and poverty in the United States.

These aren't the "warts of Russian history". Slave labor and terror were the flesh and bones of Russian history for over half a century. If you can dismiss that history with "there is injustice everywhere" handwaving, then you can accept pretty much anything.