If anything, the blame should then go to the state departments responsible for funding the research. If they are being blinded by such crap, it is a problem.
That said, I think succeeding in academia requires good skills in politics, I have a lot of respect for some people who manage to do well both in research and in pulling the right strings.
This shouldn't be necessary, of course. The raw data and a description of the algorithms (with sufficient latex-y equations) should suffice. If not, I don't think the paper is worth much.
I think, though, this is what you meant by:
"Nobody is ever going to try to actually duplicate the math it took to transform your raw data into your massaged data -- that is hard work"
But that is exactly what must happen for anyone to claim they have reproduced the original results. If you just get a VMWare instance of the original author's computer, run his program and get the same results you still are no closer to knowing whether he made a mistake or not.
Defending bad science because you agree with its conclusions is not a good idea. I'm sure there's good climate science out there, and I suspect it can show a connection between human endeavors and the actual climate. But if it turns out the evidence just isn't there yet, at least with this bunch at the wheel, well then let's suck it up and accept that, rather than circle the wagons and defend "science" when it's clear the scientists in question have not acted in accord with their professed principles.
Though now that you mention it, that seems like it would save a heck of a lot of work.
Surely if you present a chart, you also have to present the way you derived it, at which point any fakery should become evident.
If nothing else, this scandal is exposing the difference between the dogmatic version of science we all learned in the Scientific Method lecture back in 6th grade, and science as it is actually practiced in the real world. The Scientific Method lecture says that all results must be reproduced by experts. In the real world, the computer programs involved are outrageous hacks, the data are practically never seen after publication (and go missing with disturbing regularity), and the peer review concentrates mostly on making sure you cite the right people and scratch the right backs. Nobody is ever going to try to actually duplicate the math it took to transform your raw data into your massaged data -- that is hard work and have you ever met an engineer who would reliably leave detailed instructions to exactly reproduce 6 months of labor, in a form where they would be instantly comprehensible to anyone in the field? I would be astounded if scientists routinely actually committed to paper an exhaustive list of all the software installed on the computer they did the math on. (What version of which library, etc etc. So you can reproduce bugs.)
Then there is the "Frustrate anyone who opposes us at any turn, destroy data in response to FOI requests, get our nemeses expelled from their institutions, and ruin journals which publish competing work" angle, which takes it from "science as it is practiced in the real world" to just farce.