News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by yellowapple on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @06:51PM (#9649550)
> microkernel government

Hah. I wish. In reality, it's more of a modular monolith than a proper microkernel.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by mindslight on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @09:32PM (#9650094)
The nominal government has ballooned in size, but the whole power structure is still a microkernel architecture. How many aspects of your daily life are determined by insurance companies and private rulemaking bodies? Nothing can get through congress unless it benefits some special interest, illustrating that most power is outside of USG itself, as it is held by capital. Even large scale policy is set by prominent universities that prevail through attrition by repeatedly broadcasting "the way it's going to be". None of these things are accountable to the voters, even if democracy actually worked.
Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by yellowapple on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @01:34PM (#9654375)
That's not a microkernel you're describing. That's a modular monolith with malicious drivers (read: lobbyist-influenced legislators) you're describing. In a microkernel government, said legislators would be running in userspace, and therefore not have a direct influence on kernel-space policies like they do now.

The only way our government could possibly be described as a "microkernel" is if it's a microkernel a la AmigaOS, where memory protection is virtually nonexistent (at least in the early versions).

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by mindslight on Thursday June 04, 2015 @12:38PM (#9660389)
Our disagreement is a matter of perspective on where the real power lies.

> legislators would ... not have a direct influence on kernel-space policies

They don't. The kernel is not the federal government, which is but one group of (albeit somewhat privileged) processes. The kernel is economic control, which is why I pointed out that most of your daily life is shaped by non-government processes.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by yellowapple on Thursday June 04, 2015 @02:05PM (#9660949)
Then we're not talking about a microkernel government, but instead talking about microkernel socioeconomics.

If we stick to the former case, though, then it's not accurate to say that the economy is the kernel of this hypothetical operating system. The federal government very much is; just because it's susceptible to a multitude of security-related bugs doesn't mean that it's no longer the kernel, much like how just because the NT kernel is susceptible to a multitude of security-related bugs doesn't mean that it's no longer the kernel.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by mindslight on Friday June 05, 2015 @07:13PM (#9668771)
As I said, different perspectives on the power relationship between USG and megacorps.

It's like someone used a security bug in NT to load a hypervisor. You could say that NT was still "the kernel", but most of the important stuff goes on outside of it.