News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by jdp23 on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @05:22PM (#9649116)
Great questions. USA Freedom has some reforms, and shifts the collection to the telcos rather than the NSA. Then again it largely keeps the current regime in place (which makes it a win for the NSA), and it misses out on a lot of potential improvements. Some privacy and civil liberties organizations supported it; EFF and ACLU neither supported nor opposed it.

Unfortunately, more aggressive reforms -- like the Surveillance State Repeal Act -- weren't on the table; and there was a lot of concern that the Senate would further weaken it. So given the makeup of the House and Senate, passing the House version unmodified after a sunset was probably the best outcome. ACLU's Jameel Jaffer says "This is the most important surveillance reform bill since 1978, and its passage is an indication that Americans are no longer willing to give the intelligence agencies a blank check."

While the sunset doesn't actually have any long-term effect, IMHO it's still symbolically important: it meant that the usual tactics of "engineer a last-minute crisis" didn't work this time. And because of Rand Paul, it's actually going to be an issue in the GOP Presidential campaign -- which is huge. [Sanders voted against it as well, saying it was too weak.]

So on the whole I'd say it's a win for reformers ... a small win, admittedly, and tinged with disappointment that even after Snowden we couldn't do better. Still, it's a long term battle. And frankly it's been a while since we've had even a small win.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by jdp23 on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @05:49PM (#9649259)
And, here's EFF's statement:

Technology users everywhere should celebrate, knowing that the NSA will be a little more hampered in its surveillance overreach, and both the NSA and the FISA court will be more transparent and accountable than it was before the USA Freedom Act.

It’s no secret that we wanted more ...

Even so, we’re celebrating. We’re celebrating because, however small, this bill marks a day that some said could never happen—a day when the NSA saw its surveillance power reduced by Congress. And we’re hoping that this could be a turning point in the fight to rein in the NSA....

https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2015/05/usa-freedom-act-passes...

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by d23 on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @09:25PM (#9650074)
I suppose it's too much to ask that we actually congratulate the people that represent us on doing something positive. Maybe we could all dial the cynicism back a bit too.

Not directed at you; just a general thought.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by phaus on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @05:45PM (#9649244)
Its technically a win, but in reality its a victorious battle that has likely cost us the war. Now everyone who voted for this anemic pile of shit can go back to his/her constituents and brag about how they fought the tyranny of the NSA. This "victory" is going to prevent a more meaningful reform bill from gaining any traction in the future. Meanwhile, the NSA gets >99% of what they want.
Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by tosser-004 on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @06:19PM (#9649415)
What would be an acceptable level of data collection in your opinion? I've heard a lot about what people think is wrong, but what would the intelligence landscape look like if you had your way? Has the EFF stated what they would find acceptable?
Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by seanflyon on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @06:34PM (#9649482)
I like the way it worked before the Patriot Act: want to search someone's property? Get a warrant. Want to tap someone's phone? Get a warrant. Want to collect whatever private information? Get a warrant with the target's name on it.
Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by bkeroack on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @07:54PM (#9649789)
Echelon had been going on for a long time before the PATRIOT Act[1].

1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by rayiner on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @06:49PM (#9649535)
All of those things still require a warrant, and collecting call metadata has never required a warrant.
Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by themartorana on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @07:38PM (#9649720)
Maybe. That's one of the problems, that the NSA is trying to get everything that hasn't explicitly been labeled as private to be considered public - from phone metadata to emails stored in the cloud.

Although that said, they read ALL emails, and have said [0] that they require no authorization or warrant to listen to your calls, read your text messages, and read your email. So no, without explicit reigning in, those things the GP lists are not all as they once were.

[0] http://www.cnet.com/news/nsa-spying-flap-extends-to-contents...

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by Retric on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @07:48PM (#9649766)
The NSA does not need a warrant to track people outside the USA which is more or less it's job. It can then trade that information with a foreign governments for there collection of US suspects without a warrant.

From 1946: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/UKUSA_Agreement "For example, the British newspaper The Independent reported back in 1996 that the U.S. National Security Agency "taps UK phones" at the request of the British intelligence agency MI5, thus allowing British agents to evade restrictive limitations on domestic telephone tapping.[53]"

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by tptacek on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @08:19PM (#9649875)
Can it actually do that?
Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by Retric on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @08:29PM (#9649916)
The NSA can and has, the other side may have limitations. http://techcrunch.com/2015/02/06/ipt-nsa-gchq-ruling/

Note the actual judgement is linked on the bottom.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by tptacek on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @09:02PM (#9650006)
Sorry, I was imprecise.

I believe you that the NSA might provide intelligence to its partners about foreign nationals that those partners could not lawfully collect themselves.

I'm wondering if NSA can actually procure intelligence about US citizens from its partners.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by Retric on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @10:26PM (#9650225)
It's a well established rule that private party's can hand the U.S. government information of there own free will without issue. The issue is the government can't request specific information, but a wink wink system of bulk data sharing should be perfectly legal.

Beyond that point, I have no idea if there is some exemption that lets them request specific information.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by mpyne on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @09:06PM (#9650020)
Nowhere in that article does it appear that GCHQ actually asked NSA to tap UK citizens' private communications. Is it buried under one of the other links?

Instead it appears that NSA had gathered data relating to UK citizens (under NSA's existing legal authorities) and that the GCHQ then asked for that data to be shared with it.

UK law is incredibly surveillance-friendly compared to the USA so I'd be surprised if there were even a reason for GCHQ to ask NSA to do surveillance on GCHQ's behalf; GCHQ could much more easily do it directly.

But NSA-sourced data could still be useful for GCHQ, which would make sense that GCHQ asks for it when it's been collected, for the same reason Germany's BND was found to be sharing data with NSA (in BND's case, because they wanted NSA to share their own data with BND).

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by Retric on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @10:15PM (#9650196)
That first quote was from this link. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/UKUSA_Agreement

Which uses 53 as its source. "US spy base `taps UK phones for MI5'" which may or may not be credible. http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/us-spy-base-t....

However, my second posts links to a court case which suggests they overstepped some bounds.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by takeda on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @06:35PM (#9649487)
About 0%.

No data should be collected without a warrant, this look so much like how communist countries during cold war were spying on its own citizens. What makes it even worse is that thanks to advanced technology far more information can be collected about us.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by mpyne on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @09:08PM (#9650026)
> No data should be collected without a warrant

In your world, are police officers allowed to call in license plate numbers to see if the car of the person they just pulled over is registered to an escaped armed criminal? May the government tune radios to public airwaves? Or is it just electronic communications which are special?

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by takeda on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:14AM (#9650836)
Anything a normal person would assume is private should be treated that way.

License plates? That's why they are for, you register your car with DMV or similar institution in your country for the sole purpose of matching you with the car.

So keeping database of all license plates that match drivers, perfectly ok, but scanning automatically license plates and building map of your daily routes, that is going too far. Where I frequent is my private business.

Public airwaves? Yes, the keyword is "public", assuming the communication is not encrypted. If it is encrypted then it means it should be private.

Criminals can use encryption? Doesn't matter, it is still private. If we allow to go that route, next thing you know we will have implants in our heads transmitting what we are thinking.

“Those who surrender freedom for security will not have, nor do they deserve, either one.” -- Benjamin Franklin

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by mpyne on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @07:10PM (#9656481)
> Anything a normal person would assume is private should be treated that way.

Fine, just don't complain when it turns out that your expectation of what is normal doesn't match up with the population.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by voxic11 on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @10:28PM (#9650233)
pretty sure he meant any data obtained via methods which would be illegal for a private citizen to utilize should require a warrant. So no national security letters or breaking into secure facilities to place taps ect.
Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by mpyne on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @07:12PM (#9656492)
> pretty sure he meant any data obtained via methods which would be illegal for a private citizen to utilize should require a warrant.

Oh, so the solution is easy then; just make tapping phones legal for everybody again! It might also make those guys with their police scanners happy.

While we're at it, they can bring back party lines for landline telephone use and save some money, or let weev out of prison, and in the meantime the NSA and FBI can gobble up all of our communications.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by phaus on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @07:12PM (#9649619)
I think that all types of personal information, even metadata, should require a warrant in order to collect it. A warrant issued by the normal legal system, as opposed to a secret court.

As far as the landscape of intelligence. That's a very good question. The NSA is an incredibly large organization with a wide variety of projects. I think for the most part the organization's mission is pretty noble. I just also happen to think that they went off the rails at some point and started doing misguided, counterproductive things that should be illegal.

I don't have an entire plan drawn out for the restructuring of the NSA, but I do think that Bruce Schneier made some very sensible suggestions for true reform.

https://www.schneier.com/blog/archives/2014/02/breaking_up_t...

That being said, I think that the FBI needs some work as well.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by knodi123 on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @06:34PM (#9649478)
This is a much more interesting question than the one that usually gets asked, IMO.

I'd be okay with mass collection of metadata, as long as searches through that data had to be limited, audited, and focused on a specific topic for a specific active investigation. And if there were a trustworthy access control and auditing process to make sure there were no more LOVINT leaks, and none of that bullshit that the FBI pulled on MLK jr.

However, I don't think I would trust any agency to not find a way around that, in time. The power is too great, it's too tempting, and administrations change. Therefore, in our real world, I don't support mass un-targeted perpetual data collection, at all.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by mc808 on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @07:33PM (#9649692)
The only real long-term solution is to keep moving toward decentralization and encryption everywhere, making it close to impossible for anyone to conduct mass or targeted surveillance. Even if we assume the NSA (U.S. National Security Agency) follows orders, there are still 190+ other NSAs (Nation-State Actors) doing their own thing - not to mention the private and quasi private entities running the infrastructure. If someone can peep, someone will peep.
Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by trowawayaway on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @02:41AM (#9650917)
The founding fathers took care of that one for the EFF and the rest of us. Get a warrant. Get a warrant before rummaging around in people's digital effects. Here's the Supreme Court from last term: " A decade ago officers might have occasionally stumbled across a highly personal item such as a diary, but today many of the more than 90% of American adults who own cell phones keep on their person a digital record of nearly every aspect of their lives."

By the way the same question applies to the intelligence agencies. What level of freedom is acceptable in their opinion. I've heard a number of easily disprovable talking points in favor of continued expansion of this full-employment-act for intelligence "analysts," but what would people's ability to freely express themselves look like if the intelligence community had its way?

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by chatmasta on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @06:39PM (#9649507)
@taketa

> thanks to advanced technology far more information can be collected

Advanced technology also provides the tools to defend against mass surveillance.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by rand334 on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @08:54PM (#9649980)
See my comment above. It's not "symbolically a good thing"--the intelligence community wanted this. It just expands their powers. It's only symbolic effect is that now, the average American not paying attention, actually things that we've made reform and can stop caring about it. This is a fucking sad day. I'm disappointed in everyone who is saying this is anything but a terrible thing.

https://regmedia.co.uk/2015/05/01/and_then_i_told_them.jpg?x...

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by higherpurpose on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @06:26PM (#9649454)
I may be wrong but didn't the House actually want to pass a rather strong version of the USA Freedom Act and then the House Committee drastically watered it down before sending it to the Senate?

If that is true then it's most disappointing. Couldn't the House members have done something about that (just calling for a replacement of the Committee members, I guess?). The House Committee doing something like that sounds quite undemocratic, because the House Representatives passed a significantly different bill and then these "middle-men" intervened to kill it.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by jdp23 on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @07:29PM (#9649682)
That's kind of what happened last year. Here's EFF's discussion from May 2014. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2014/05/eff-dismayed-houses-gu...

This year, the House Intelligence Committee worked with the administration, the intelligence community, and privacy advocates to come up with a compromise "USA Freedom" that everybody could live with. The House Judiciary Committee wanted to strengthen it but was concerned that would lead to the compromise falling apart and so didn't amend. The House then passed it, fairly overwhelmingly (although 50ish representatives who voted against wrote a letter to the Senate saying it should be stronger). All the amendments failed in the Senate, so they passed it as well.

And yeah, it's really disappointing. The leadership in both the House and Senate has a huge amount of control over what bills make it to the floor, and they defer to the Intelligence committees (who tend to overwhelmingly support the NSA) so the cards are strongly stacked against reformers. And this isn't just a party-line issue; when the Democrats were in control, it was a very similar dynamic.

Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by tootie on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @07:14PM (#9649634)
I think that aside from the reforms that were left on the table, it's another step to be exlicit about what's allowed and what isn't. For the past 14 years, the view from within the executive was that if no one has said one way or the other, let's just do it until we get caught. Now, we're zeroing in on an explicit set of rules and parameters so there's less ambiguity.
Re:Senate Approves Bill to Rein in N.S.A. Surveillance by snarfy on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @07:28PM (#9649681)
> USA Freedom has some reforms, and shifts the collection to the telcos rather than the NSA.

It also shifts the legal liability, which I believe was the purpose. I don't know if I would call this a win.