Re:Against Camel Case
by blasdel on Friday November 27, 2009 @02:25PM
(#964267)
An online bibliographical supplement: http://www.steamthing.com/2009/11/the-kneecapping-of-interca...
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I much prefer William Safire's treatment linked from that bibliography: http://www.nytimes.com/1997/07/20/magazine/jammedtogether-na...
Safire seems to treat the whole thing with a sense of playfulness and levity, as if he realizes that the very purpose of a language is to evolve. Crain's article is preachy and disdainful- he might as well shoo us with a broom and tell us to get off his lawn.
Re:Against Camel Case
by gabrielroth on Friday November 27, 2009 @05:02PM
(#964431)
The tone you call 'preachy and disdainful' I find humorous and self-aware. Likewise the conceit of refusing to print any camel-case terms. "I could print it here to show you, but I refuse to allow my prose to be so disfigured": it's a parody of a grumpy-old-man routine. I assume he's sincere in his distaste for inner caps, but he plainly recognizes that it makes him sound like an old codger, and he's playing that up for comic effect.
That could be, and I certainly did a double-take when I saw this his blog is called "Steamboats are ruining everything." Still, at first blush, any winking and/or nodding was lost on me, and I usually pick up on that kind of stuff.
I thought it was pretty clear when he added the part about letting the dog sleep on the sofa.
"Preachy and disdainful" -- I did not find it so. In fact, close to tongue-in-cheek, more of a "ha ha, just serious".
... "Three! And why not let the dog sleep on the sofa?"
Re:Against Camel Case
by DanielBMarkham on Friday November 27, 2009 @04:14PM
(#964382)
Safire's piece is an order-of-magnitude better than this one.
He is missed.