Because my preferred openid provider uses client-side SSL certs to authenticate me, google doesn't. Part of the point of openid is it allows me to implement security procedures you haven't thought of without making me beg every site I use to do things the way I want.
Because I don't have a google account. But I do run my own openid provider.
I'd say that's an edge case, but still - sites that don't support OpenID would require you to create login. This method basically asks you to create that login with Google instead, is more secure than most of these sites.
Even for an OpenID-savvy user, why would it be frustrating or less secure to login via Google? If someone got my Gmail password, sites like mine would be the least of my worries..