Re:Marcus du Sautoy: Without maths we’re lost in a dark laby...
by jgrahamc on Friday November 27, 2009 @11:06AM
(#964012)
I have a pretty deep knowledge of mathematics and I watched those programs as well with my SO (who is not mathematical). We gave up watching them because I was able to understand what he was getting at because of my education and she wasn't because he was so unclear. I think it was a pretty poor effort.
There are some lovely bits of mathematics (such as Cantor's diagonalization argument) that could be explained to most people with patience and enthusiasm.
I agree with your general point though, in particular I wish he'd be a bit more specific when talking about these examples of mystical beauty he finds so appealing in mathematics.
Unfortunately, as some of the other commentators have mentioned I can see why that kind of thing might be cut by editors - my parents watched the series he presented a while back, and sort-of gave up by the time the last programme was on, saying they didn't really understand a lot of it. Then again, maybe that's the problem! If he explained a bit more instead of briefly touching on the more complicated areas then perhaps they would have followed it better.