News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by kozukumi on Monday June 01, 2015 @06:38AM (#9637664)
Looks like you and I hit a nerve here on HN. You are right though. Microsoft will be shipping Windows 10 with an incomplete version of their new Edge browser with the promise of adding critical features such as extensions in the future. Basically Windows 10 won't really be feature complete RTM for another 6 months. Even if Microsoft want to pretend it is ready now.

Edit: To clarify the "hit a nerve" bit, when I wrote this my post and agildehaus's were both down voted.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by ulfw on Monday June 01, 2015 @06:48AM (#9637686)
Sounds exactly like OS X 10.10 Yosemite to me, where the promised Photos app (which really is nothing special) arrived many months later.
Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by kozukumi on Monday June 01, 2015 @07:23AM (#9637797)
In some ways yes it is the same. However Photos isn't exactly the most important piece of software that comes with your OS.

Microsoft are trying to change how people think of their web browser. Edge is very important yet they are launching it without one of the biggest features needed in a modern browser, extension support.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by veidr on Monday June 01, 2015 @08:02AM (#9637923)
Certainly, browser extensions are important to some people.

But do you believe that more than 1% of web browser users install and use one or more browser extensions?

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by acheron on Monday June 01, 2015 @10:36AM (#9638849)
But do you believe that more than 1% of web browser users install and use one or more browser extensions?

In 2013, this article[1] gave numbers of anywhere from 9% to 22% of users blocking ads, which requires an extension AFAIK. So, "yes". Even if those numbers are exaggerated due to skewed measurements, I'm pretty sure it's going to be more than 1%.

[1] http://www.forbes.com/sites/kashmirhill/2013/08/21/use-of-ad...

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by Someone1234 on Monday June 01, 2015 @11:02AM (#9639057)
If you include Flash and Silverlight? Uhh yes. Likely over 90% of browser users use one or more extension.
Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by wlesieutre on Monday June 01, 2015 @11:54AM (#9639600)
Edge supports Flash already, so if that's all that 90% of people use, it won't be a problem. And it's typically categorized as a "plug-in" rather than an extension, so I wouldn't lump it in with the extension functionality.

Not sure if it has Silverlight, but since we aren't streaming the 2008 Olympics and Netflix doesn't need it anymore I'm not terribly worried.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by kayoone on Monday June 01, 2015 @08:20AM (#9637988)
For me Yosemite still has a lot of issues, mostly performance wise in it's current version.
Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by themartorana on Monday June 01, 2015 @08:10AM (#9637955)
Are they allowed to ship a browser as a core OS feature? I thought that ship had been sunk - in the EU at least.
Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by pcai on Monday June 01, 2015 @09:22AM (#9638302)
I believe they have shipped EU-specific versions for years to comply with their mandate
Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by baldfat on Monday June 01, 2015 @07:22AM (#9637786)
But the answer is going to be that Apple Updates are free. Which is going to be the same reply for Windows 10 for the next year.
Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by radiorental on Monday June 01, 2015 @08:10AM (#9637959)
Just to clarify. MS said users of win 7 & 8 will be able to upgrade for free to win 10 within a year.

I believe I read somewhere that this will be MS's last release #. It will be a rolling release from here on out. I have not seen details on how they monetize that unless they switch to Apple's HW model.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by joshuapants on Monday June 01, 2015 @08:41AM (#9638077)
Microsoft has stated that most of the money they make from Windows is from selling licenses to hardware partners. Of course, they are also starting to move into an Apple-like hardware model (though of course they still allow third parties to make hardware).
Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by baldfat on Monday June 01, 2015 @09:20AM (#9638291)
I don't see the Hardware Model at all.

I think they are just wanting as many people as possible to switch to Windows 10 as fast as possible. They are doing this by giving it away for free.

After the year Windows will be monotonized the same way. As someone that always builds his own comoputers I jumped on the $29.99 Windows 7 deal which they offered the first 6 months and $39.99 for Windows 8 which was good for the first three months (Off the top of my head not needed to be accurate for arguement sake)

It's free for a year to upgrade and than back to business as usual.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by joshuapants on Monday June 01, 2015 @11:43AM (#9639499)
> I don't see the Hardware Model at all.

They sell computers and mobile phones of their own design tailored for their own OS. The only difference is that they allow third party hardware and Apple doesn't.

> I think they are just wanting as many people as possible to switch to Windows 10 as fast as possible. They are doing this by giving it away for free.

I agree.

> After the year Windows will be monotonized the same way.

This doesn't seem to be consistent with their stated goals and the direction they've been moving in. The idea is that Windows 10 is the last numbered version of Windows, after that it will be evergreen. What upgrades are there to sell?

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by ninjaoxygen on Monday June 01, 2015 @10:02AM (#9638597)
This is their chosen strategy though, that as of Windows 10 there will no longer be full major Windows versions. Instead it will be an ongoing rolling release of incremental changes.

From a developer perspective, this sounds like a support nightmare given the number of potential configurations that could end up out there with no clear way of identifying them.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by Silhouette on Monday June 01, 2015 @01:17PM (#9640375)
Instead it will be an ongoing rolling release of incremental changes.

I genuinely don't understand this move by Microsoft. Of all the things you want to be stable and reliable over time, your basic OS and platform software has to be at the top of the list.

While dumping any responsibility to support software older than the latest release has obvious appeal for developers, evergreen software has mostly proven to be mediocre-to-disastrous from the user's point of view so far. For business users, it's also painful from an internal support point of view, for much the same reasons. And as you mentioned, for an OS or other platform software, anyone developing other software that runs on top of it also faces problems.

About the only thing this kind of constantly updating deployment model has been good for is getting security and stability patches out faster. This is beneficial, but that benefit is tempered by the "just ship junk and patch it later" philosophy that has become widespread at the same time. Many of those patches simply shouldn't ever have been necessary in the first place, but new releases are now routinely of such poor quality that many people just don't bother, and advice to wait until SP1 or the equivalent is common.

If I were Microsoft, I think I'd want my new flagship OS to be the stable, reliable, trustworthy antidote to Apple's broken-within-a-week operating systems[1], not something with the same reputation for constantly tweaking things as Chrome/Firefox, on-line SaaS apps, and the like.

[1] For legal reasons, I would like to point out that not all Apple operating systems break within a week. In fact, the fastest I have seen a mainstream Apple device break in practice was approximately an hour after purchase, when iOS updated on a mobile device almost immediately, leaving the device so much worse than what the purchaser had previously tried out and thought they were buying that they took it straight back to the shop and demanded a full refund.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by lholden on Monday June 01, 2015 @06:14PM (#9642569)
Businesses have had the ability to manage update deployments for a while now. Big Win10 feature changes will likely come in a service pack form or similar, with security fixes and minor updates using the same model they always have.

A business will typically test and verify updates before pushing then out to their employees.

Businesses which allow its users to perform updates directly from Microsoft already face the issues you describe. (Many updates can and have caused issues. Especially the occasional broken patch that gets rolled back shortly after release).

I can certainly see this being an issue for support companies. On the other hand, they will likely still have some form of versioning to base their support on. "Sir, please do XXX. You should see something saying Windows 10 Service Pack and then a number. Can you please tell me what that number is?"

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by Silhouette on Monday June 01, 2015 @07:18PM (#9642878)
Businesses have had the ability to manage update deployments for a while now.

Sure, but someone still has to test each update as it applies to each critical system or widely used standard PC configuration before giving the OK to roll it out across the organisation. If MS moved to releasing non-essential updates in an ad-hoc fashion, it seems inevitable that the result would be either a scheduling and resource management headache for corporate IT departments or (perhaps more likely) a general policy of not deploying non-essential updates at all by default in large organisations because the hassle of keeping up isn't justified. Corporate IT have enough to worry about already without someone potentially moving the goalposts on a daily basis.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by tracker1 on Monday June 01, 2015 @10:28PM (#9643472)
I still don't see how what you are describing is any more or less of a headache than supporting Windows XP a decade after the first release.. it's still rolling updates, just with less intensive UI changes over that period.

The same goes for companies supporting Windows 7 today... they're using their own base, with cherry picked updates. It seems to me, that this would be easier to manage, than keeping up with rolling from xp/7/8/8.x etc.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by cm2187 on Monday June 01, 2015 @08:07AM (#9637947)
I would be surprised if they would make such a gamble. The last thing they can afford is another PR disaster with Windows 10.

Right now, there is very little incentive for a user to move on from Windows 7 on an existing machine, particularly if it is not touch enabled. Now imagine if they hear that Windows 10 is riddled with bugs and doesn't work.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by ryan-allen on Monday June 01, 2015 @10:27AM (#9638766)
I prefer Win 8.1 to 7 any day. I spend 99.9% of my time in desktop mode and it's fine. I prefer it!

EDIT: I don't have many/any ongoing issues with bugs, and I even use Visual Studio CTP/RC on a day to day basis, without any major issues.

Microsoft do software _really_ well. The crap they have to get right on an ongoing basis is nothing compared to Google and Facebook, we should give them some credit.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by dagw on Wednesday June 03, 2015 @05:25AM (#9651430)
As a power user and developer, I agree with you. On the other hand I would never recommend casual users like my parents to upgrade from 7 to 8.
Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by ryan-allen on Thursday June 04, 2015 @08:28PM (#9663132)
Hopefully 10 will be familiar enough for casual users with the start button back and all!
Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by tracker1 on Monday June 01, 2015 @10:32PM (#9643486)
Win8.x with ClassicShell isn't bad.. and VS 2015 RC is pretty decent, most of the functionality works a lot better than it did in previous versions...
Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by pp19dd on Monday June 01, 2015 @09:55AM (#9638544)
It may not be perfect at this very moment, but it will get more polished as time goes on. It has to.

The carrot they're dangling is a free upgrade, so think I might take this gamble. I'm not a penny pincher, but even so I cringe at the thought of paying for operating system upgrades.

This opportunity won't last forever, so I'll start with laptops and work my way up.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by porker on Monday June 01, 2015 @10:54AM (#9638997)
I'll take the free upgrade too, but if there's a 12 month window to upgrade I'll take it in month 11...
Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by Someone1234 on Monday June 01, 2015 @11:06AM (#9639101)
You should.

But I strongly suspect after a year Microsoft will extend the upgrade indefinitely. The whole year limit only exists to accelerate Windows 10 upgrades (to add urgency to it).

It doesn't make sense for Microsoft to end the free upgrade program after that point. They've already sacrificed most of the private licence revenue by the majority of the people buying them already upgrading, so the remaining trickle after the year won't be significant.

But I might be wrong. They did end the Windows 8 $25 upgrade after a year for real. So we'll have to wait and see.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by cm2187 on Tuesday June 02, 2015 @04:04AM (#9644536)
But why is a free upgrade a good thing? What do I get by upgrading?

To a power user you get lots of nice things. Hyper-V is fantastic from Windows 8. Explorer is also faster and locks a lot less files and folders (the "you can't delete a folder that contained pictures" bug in windows 7).

But to a common user, there is nothing better in windows 10, other than the fact that they need to relearn how to use windows. From a UI point of view, the only additions are multiple desktops, which is at best a featurette, and moving the search bar from within the start menu to the task bar, which isn't exactly a revolution. If you don't have touch enabled on your machine, which would be the common case for windows 7, upgrading to windows 10 is only going to be a hassle.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by usernick on Monday June 01, 2015 @10:13AM (#9638671)
Are we calling extensions a "critical feature" of browsers now? They're certainly commonplace and expected but "critical"? Hardly.
Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by wernercd on Monday June 01, 2015 @11:04AM (#9639080)
iPhone shipped feature-incomplete yet people were screaming from the rafters about how awesome it was. Earth Shattering. MAGICAL!

Gotta love the double standards...

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by mattkevan on Monday June 01, 2015 @11:39AM (#9639445)
No, not really.

The original iPhone was feature complete, in that the features it shipped with were complete.

Whether it had all the features it could have done is another question. However that misses the point - the goal was to set the bar for a fully touch-screen interface, not compete on feature lists.

And it was earth shattering. That one product launch was the catalyst for a huge amount of change – our entire computing landscape has been shaken up, previous incumbents are dead or dying, new industries have been created and billions of dollars of value has been created and destroyed.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by MichaelGG on Monday June 01, 2015 @11:55AM (#9639605)
The current Win10 builds are not even close to having the polish iPhone 1 had. There's all sorts of inconsistencies and screwed up stuff. Hell, just clicking on search settings doesn't even work (in true JS style even; it just does nothing, no error, no response).

OTOH, coming from Win8, where it's so much worse, Win10 is an improvement. After running I for months, a friend asked what was new. "Well they undid the Metro app fiasco, more or less. And console windows are now resizable. Font rendering is blurry in half the OS. And most settings are messed up and unusable until you manage to get into the "legacy" settings dialog. And uh... That's it?" Yeah they added a weak attempt at some new window management, but nothing super usable.

Anything is better than Win8, but Win7 users are not going to enjoy it. They'll probably prefer the old shell, with the new kernel extensions.

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by ladzoppelin on Monday June 01, 2015 @03:46PM (#9641599)
Anybody who thinks Windows 7 is better than Windows 8.1 needs to get a new monitor or their eyes checked. Also if you update to the latest Windows 10 build, released this weekend, it fixes the search/start menu launch stuff. I am running 8.1 and Windows 10 in a virtual plus several users are already running 10. Blurry fonts are the app makers problem, just like Apple.
Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by MichaelGG on Monday June 01, 2015 @04:22PM (#9641855)
Uh blurry apps include all the Metro stuff, IE/Sparta, etc. It's because MS is abandoning pixel snapping in lieu of "more accurate" subpixel positioning. This approach only works well on high DPI or large fonts. It sucks compared to normal ClearType at smaller (<13 pt) sizes.

Users are gonna be hard pressed to list the advantages of 20 over 7. Console windows suck less. Start menu is back. Task manager is better. Lots of under-the-hood stuff, sure. But day to day? I've been using Win10 for months and can't think of anything. (Virtual desktops, maybe... Their implementation seems clunky compared to others I've used.)

Unless you're into metro apps and like the junk ridden store, what's the killer app? What's the huge win in upgrading?

Re:Hello World: Windows 10 Available on July 29 by yuhong on Monday June 01, 2015 @09:29PM (#9643296)
I think giving app developers a market is part of why Win10 is free.