Re:Isaac Asimov: The Relativity of Wrong (1989)
by nitrogen on Saturday May 30, 2015 @01:48PM
(#9630995)
By "consensus" I mean what you describe, the accumulation of data from multiple sources. But even a simple human consensus of scientists would be right more of the time than a simple consensus of non-scientists.
Edit: also, I was referring initially to the arguments from other comments, not to Asimov specifically.
Re:Isaac Asimov: The Relativity of Wrong (1989)
by pdonis on Saturday May 30, 2015 @01:56PM
(#9631034)
> even a simple human consensus of scientists would be right more of the time than a simple consensus of non-scientists.
This is probably true, at least in fields where we have a reasonably developed science, but you realize, I trust, that it's not a very high bar. :-)
The point is that what is "less wrong" is the understanding we build up by extending the range of our data and our ability to predict what new data that we haven't yet observed will look like. It's not anything we build up by "consensus". So a lay person, trying to figure out what to "blindly follow", should not be looking at "consensus"; they should be looking at what data we have, how reliable it is, what does it cover, and how well we can predict what we will see when we get further data. As you can see, I put "blindly follow" in quotes because you can't do all this blindly; you can't just ask what the "consensus" is. You have to actually look at the content.