News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Math's Most Famous Proof Nearly Broke by fsk on Saturday May 30, 2015 @01:06AM (#9629076)
The problem with all these proofs is that it'd take someone who already has a Math PhD several years of full-time effort to understand the proof.

Because these famous problems were solved, there is now increased demand for Math PhDs with that specialty.

How do you know if the proof is valid, or if they're just scratching each others' backs and pretending they're all brilliant? You might say "Wait, a fraud that big couldn't happen." Just like one of the biggest investment funds couldn't be a Ponzi Scam? (Madoff)

I.e., the few Mathematicians who know enough to be able to check the full proof might be doing the equivalent of this guy:

http://nymag.com/scienceofus/2015/05/how-a-grad-student-unco...

Re:How Math's Most Famous Proof Nearly Broke by impendia on Saturday May 30, 2015 @09:33AM (#9630108)
> How do you know if the proof is valid, or if they're just scratching each others' backs and pretending they're all brilliant?

(Professional mathematician here)

Such a conspiracy could never happen. Mathematicians are, in general, scrupulously honest to a fault. There are exceptions of course, but such a scam would need everybody's cooperation.

Moreover, if you have tenure then you would have no incentive to participate in such a fraud (even to the extent of keeping quiet about it). Once you get tenure you are basically working for pride and for the sheer joy of solving problems, and maintaining a big lie would do nothing for either.

Re:How Math's Most Famous Proof Nearly Broke by Confusion on Saturday May 30, 2015 @01:21PM (#9630863)
I would like to both broaden and qualify that statement: scientists are, in general, scrupulously honest where it concerns their work, probably because their work is about 'truth'. Nevertheless, scientists are still people and many people lie and cheat when it suits them.
Re:How Math's Most Famous Proof Nearly Broke by Tloewald on Saturday May 30, 2015 @01:19AM (#9629110)
This isn't really a comparable example. We are talking about the most famous recent piece of math that made headlines all over the world first when the proof was published, again when issues were found with the proof, and again when those issues were addressed. Vs a "world famous in Poland" study in what not even barely qualifies as a science.

No one in bleeding edge science can fully grasp bleeding edge work outside their specialty, but high profIle stuff like this gets a lot of attention.

Re:How Math's Most Famous Proof Nearly Broke by raverbashing on Saturday May 30, 2015 @04:02AM (#9629449)
Yes, they might.

But then this gets published and other people could point their mistakes. And then it's not only about what the authors got wrong, but also what the reviewers let slip.

And while the number of mathematicians that can understand the proof is low, it is > 1

Re:How Math's Most Famous Proof Nearly Broke by Beltiras on Saturday May 30, 2015 @02:22AM (#9629254)
The only (gaping) hole in your conspiracy is that you get points for proving anyone wrong in academia (even yourself). A conspiracy about mathematic proofs sounds about as ridiculous as an honest segment of The O'Reilly Factor.