Re:Psychohistory
by dunstad on Thursday May 28, 2015 @04:58PM
(#9621136)
I wasn't aware this was an actual field of study. I fully expected to be directed to the article in the disambiguation at the top, about Asimov's Foundation series.
They make an interesting pair, with this real life version focused on the motivations of an individual and how they shaped our world, and the fictional version focused on the motivations of large groups, and how they will shape the world to come.
Re:Psychohistory
by Red_Tarsius on Thursday May 28, 2015 @05:00PM
(#9621141)
Psychohistory is also one of the most interesting theories of science fiction. Here's a recent thread on The Foundation: will psychohistory ever become reality?https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9052538
Re:Psychohistory
by SwellJoe on Thursday May 28, 2015 @05:13PM
(#9621220)
Counterpoint: I've re-read it every five years or so since I was about 22, when I first read it (actually, I'd read some of the first one when I was much younger, maybe 6th grade, and got overwhelmed with the span of time and number of characters, but never finished it until I was about 22). I've loved it every time, and I'm just about due for another re-read and I'm looking forward to it.
There are some weaknesses, sure. Asimov himself was even aware of some of his weaknesses as a writer and talked about them occasionally in his memoirs and such. But, aside from HHGTTG and Dune, I can't think of anything that I've re-read more often, or that has been a more satisfying part of my reading life (and I read a lot). Asimov remains my favorite author after all these years. Admittedly, some of that is the "old friend" factor. But, nonetheless, I believe it is very solid sci-fi, and recommend it to anyone who hasn't read it.
Re:Psychohistory
by oskarth on Thursday May 28, 2015 @05:11PM
(#9621207)
I was really into it as a young teenager as well, but when I tried reading it a few years ago or so I couldn't get more than a hundred pages. I had the same experience with Catch 22.
I don't know what changed - it's a shame, since I was really looking forward to it. It's possible I'll give it another shot in a few years.
Re:Psychohistory
by fishnchips on Friday May 29, 2015 @03:10AM
(#9623172)
Poor writing was my first and foremost gripe: obvious character motives and an almost total lack of surprising plot twists. To be fair, I also re-read The Star Diaries which I first read (and loved!) in my early teens and I had the same issues with the author's workshop. That being said I think Asimov's prose hasn't aged very well in the light of actual technological progress (information storage and retrieval) and you just keep smiling while reading about Encyclopedia Galactica.
Re:Psychohistory
by Frondo on Thursday May 28, 2015 @06:10PM
(#9621512)
I read it as an adult and was disappointed by the flatness of the characters and the almost-total absence of any female characters.
To clarify: I'm not saying that people should shoehorn women into stories to satisfy a quota, I'm saying that stories that include women are simply more interesting, because they display a wider range of humanity and of the human experience.
Or, to put it another way, it's just boring to read a story where all the characters fit within a very narrow range of personality.
Re:Psychohistory
by fishnchips on Friday May 29, 2015 @03:14AM
(#9623182)
Sure, but 2500 years passed since and you'd expect writing to get a bit better. And yet Homer's characters are way more nuanced than Asimov's. Also, in Plato's Dialogs characters are completely irrelevant and are merely instruments that directly represent philosophical standpoints.
They make an interesting pair, with this real life version focused on the motivations of an individual and how they shaped our world, and the fictional version focused on the motivations of large groups, and how they will shape the world to come.
I don't see a citation for this one and I'm not sure why it would be true
There are some weaknesses, sure. Asimov himself was even aware of some of his weaknesses as a writer and talked about them occasionally in his memoirs and such. But, aside from HHGTTG and Dune, I can't think of anything that I've re-read more often, or that has been a more satisfying part of my reading life (and I read a lot). Asimov remains my favorite author after all these years. Admittedly, some of that is the "old friend" factor. But, nonetheless, I believe it is very solid sci-fi, and recommend it to anyone who hasn't read it.
I thought the original trilogy (Foundation, Foundation and Empire, Second Foundation) was amazing.
I also thought Asimov really, really, really should have stopped there.
I don't know what changed - it's a shame, since I was really looking forward to it. It's possible I'll give it another shot in a few years.
To clarify: I'm not saying that people should shoehorn women into stories to satisfy a quota, I'm saying that stories that include women are simply more interesting, because they display a wider range of humanity and of the human experience.
Or, to put it another way, it's just boring to read a story where all the characters fit within a very narrow range of personality.