Are other mistaken sentences, like life in prison, acceptable?
Re:Nebraska Abolishes Death Penalty
by Florin_Andrei on Thursday May 28, 2015 @08:29PM
(#9622038)
No mistaken sentences are "acceptable" in a naive sense. But a death sentence, after it's been executed, is 100% irreversible.
A prison sentence is reversible in the sense that the individual could be released; sure, the time lost cannot be retrieved, but the individual is still alive.
Re:Nebraska Abolishes Death Penalty
by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 27, 2015 @07:11PM
(#9615069)
> Are other mistaken sentences, like life in prison, acceptable?
Clearly, they are undesirable and, if detected, the remedies may be imperfect, but nowhere near as imperfect as the remedies for a mistaken death sentence once it has been executed.
Then this argument against capital punishment isn't simply that mistaken application of capital punishment is bad, because all mistaken legal sentencing is bad.
Re:Nebraska Abolishes Death Penalty
by dragonwriter on Wednesday May 27, 2015 @08:18PM
(#9615312)
No, the argument against capital punishment is that its existences increases the harms resulting from mistaken legal sentencing without offering any concrete, demonstrable benefit to society to weigh against that increased harm.
(While "any mistaken legal sentencing is bad" is perhaps part of the foundation on which that argument rests, it is not the whole, or even the important part, of the argument.)
Irreversible punishment is the height of arrogance.