Re:Nebraska Abolishes Death Penalty
by koenigdavidmj on Wednesday May 27, 2015 @07:12PM
(#9615073)
Then we're back to the beginning. Here is a syllogism that you just said you agree with:
1. An action is immoral without regard to the actor.
2. Killing is immoral for a regular joe on the street.
3. Therefore, killing is immoral for the government.
However, you don't seem as comfortable with:
1. An action is immoral without regard to the actor.
2. Demanding someone's money by force (e.g mugging) is immoral.
3. Therefore, it is immoral for the government to issue a fine.
Or this one:
1. An action is immoral without regard to the actor.
2. Kidnapping someone and holding them for years is immoral for a regular joe.
3. Therefore, imprisonment is immoral for the government.
You could also remain consistent by saying that armed robbery and kidnapping are moral. It's up to you.
EDIT: Typo and punctuation.
That's precisely what I'm saying. You disagree, but that does not render my argument invalid.