Re:Nebraska Abolishes Death Penalty
by mikeash on Wednesday May 27, 2015 @06:11PM
(#9614737)
Is that different from any other punishment? We imprison people to show that imprisoning people is unacceptable. We take people's money to show that taking people's money is unacceptable. We even violate the speed limit to show that violating the speed limit is unacceptable.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
> Is that different from any other punishment?
Yes, death is different. Because all other punishments can, in some way, be compensated if later the punishment is deemed to have been given in error. That is not yet possible with someone who is dead.
While that's a good argument for preserving other punishments but abolishing the death penalty (and one I happen to agree with), it has no bearing on the supposed illogic of killing in order to show that killing is unacceptable.