Re:Let Oracle own API's, Justice Dept tells top court in sur...
by tzs on Wednesday May 27, 2015 @08:09AM
(#9610748)
On that last part, so CAFC gets the case if it included patent claims, even if neither party is appealing any of the patent issues?
That raises the possibility of copyright plaintiffs tossing in a patent claim that they have no intention of trying to actually win on, just to make sure that they will get CAFC's view of copyright instead of the 9th Circuit's view.
Re:Let Oracle own API's, Justice Dept tells top court in sur...
by richardfontana on Wednesday May 27, 2015 @10:56AM
(#9611794)
Yes, the CAFC would get the case.
The CAFC itself would be bound to apply 9th Circuit precedent, as it purported to do here. Again in principle, a prior copyright decision by the CAFC applying 9th Circuit law would not be binding precedent on a CAFC panel hearing some later copyright case arising out of the 9th Circuit.
On the question in your last paragraph, where P sues D over copyright and patents in the 9th circuit, and there are only appeals of copyright issues, the appeal goes to the CAFC by statute.