News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Unhappy Birthday by anigbrowl on Wednesday May 27, 2015 @02:41AM (#9609681)
You're saying that literature has value and therefore you deserve to be given money for producing it.

No I'm not. I'm saying I deserve the opportunity to set the terms on which I sell it instead of having it copied for profit by people with greater financial resources than I have.

Copyright doesn't just protect your rights, it protects the rights of Sony executives who pay pittances to thousands of factory workers in third world countries. How many of those factory workers could have been Stanley Kubricks or Federico Fellinis? [...] The truth is, starving to death is a much greater disincentive to people working on pieces of art than the likelihood that someone will steal their work, and copyright exacerbates the "starving to death" problem by creating inequalities.

WTF - you're placing the entire burden of economic inequity ont he copyright system? that's just nonsense, notwithstanding my skepticism about modern capitalist structures.

The vast majority of money made due to copyright is not made by individuals like you, it's made by corporations like Sony, and executives who didn't produce anything--they just bought it from the producers.

Having those people buy the rights from people like me suits me just fine, because I would rather get paid and do more work than have to do all the business of distribution. It seems to me that you're essentially restating the Marxist Labor theory of Value, and I don't subscribe to that, notwithstanding that I am the laborer in this case. Wealth is not created from labor alone; capital-at-risk (the part put up by big studios) is also a necessary factor of production. If you gather 100 talented or skillful people together you don't necessarily end up with a product - they still need tools to work, raw materials to work on, and the product needs to be brought to market somehow. Digital technology assists with this but it is no way the panacea that some ideological folks imagine it to be. I can't tell you how many otherwise-decent creative micro-budget projects fail because the producers/directors haven't made the right decisions about final manufacturing options (in terms of exactly what they have to produce that distributors are looking for) and marketing (in terms of budgeting for PR or film market exhibition costs to get it in front of distributors). I absolutely think the distribution companies and various intermediaries create significant economic value - it's just not obvious to the general public outside the industry what it is that they do. You might as well say that bankers make a fortune for just pushing papers around or programmers get paid a fat money to sit around and push buttons all day.

There are no comments on this comment yet.