News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by monocasa on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @10:47AM (#9605189)
So I've had a question about stellar mass black holes that I can't seem to be able to get answered (the question was deleted for /r/askscience).

How does a stellar mass black hole actually form a singularity given the fact that there's gravitational time dilation? Wouldn't the heart of a black hole slow down relative to an outside observer as mass is added to it so that you never actually reach infinite density? It seems like you're fighting the upwards curve of a parabola to make that happen, and meanwhile you're releasing pressure from above via hawking radiation.

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by ars on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @11:55AM (#9605610)
I reached the same conclusion years ago, and the answer is very simple (and controversial): Black holes do not exist.

If they existed they could exist, but it's impossible for them to form.

I've asked many many physicists this very same question, and none could answer me (or I've gotten hand-wavy non answers). It's like no one wants to be the first to declare this well accepted thing as non-existing.

The black holes observed by astronomers are not actually black holes, but rather super massive neutron starts. It's not possible to distinguish between these two objects, astronomers assume a black holes based on size, not based on observed phenomena.

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by guard-of-terra on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @12:20PM (#9605757)
I've wondered the same, found this:

http://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/21319/how-can-any...

"The objects that can be very similar to black holes are called collapsars. They are virtually indistinguishable from actual black holes after a very short time of the formation. They consist only of matter outside the radius of the event horizon of a BH with the same mass. This matter is virtually frozen on the surface like with actual BH, due to high gravity level.

Such collapsars possibly can become BHs for a short time due to quantum fluctuations and thus emit hawking radiation.

Astrophysicists do not separate such collapsars from actual black holes and call all them BHs due to practical reasons because of their actual indistinguishability."

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by Retric on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @03:47PM (#9607175)
In your model you get a skin forming around the event horizon. However, stuff would still be attracted to that object. This increased mass would increases the size of the event horizon. So, your hypothetical border would need to expand as matter accumulates. One of the odd things about black holes is there density decreases as their size increases. At really large scales even the 'vacuum' between galaxies is dense enough to form a black hole in a static universe.

PS: In reality black holes are molded by the full general relativity equation which most physicists don't actually understand. Much like how most programmers don't understand how GPU drivers work in detail.

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by 4ad on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @02:22PM (#9606585)
Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by ars on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @02:34PM (#9606682)
That explained nothing whatsoever.

I'll even quote:

"At some moment, the radius of the star drops below the Schwarzschild radius - that's where the yellow and orange lines intersect. At this moment, the star is pretty much doomed. Right now I am not sure whether one can generally prove that the event horizon becomes inevitable at this point but I am sure that it is going to be there in a moment according to the picture above which is surely realistic."

He simply skips right past the impossible point: "the radius of the star drops below the Schwarzschild radius". It will take that Sun an infinite amount of time to do that. Any conclusions you draw after that point are unscientific.

He draws all sort of conclusions from the diagram, without ever showing that his diagram is actually true.

There was some talk of how to be a stationary observer near the black hole you must keep accelerating, but a: I fail to see how that explains the infinite time, and b: who said I have to be near the black hole to look at it?

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by 4ad on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @05:32PM (#9607804)
> It will take that Sun an infinite amount of time to do that (drops below the Schwarzschild radius). Any conclusions you draw after that point are unscientific.

Not true. You incorrectly assume that when the star collapses there is already an event horizon, somewhere. But it isn't. The event horizon will only form at some particular proper time, and at that time most (but not all) of the stellar mass will be trapped by the horizon and will form a singularity (interestingly all the trapped matter will reach the singularity at the same proper time).

This is all very clearly explained here: http://www.aei.mpg.de/~rezzolla/lnotes/mondragone/collapse.p...

Related physics stack-exchange answer: http://physics.stackexchange.com/a/28837

I don't want to sound rude, but you really need to understand GR. The seminal work on the subject is "The Mathematical Theory of Black Holes" by Subrahmanyan Chandrasekhar, you need to know GR very well to be able to understand it, but the pdf I linked is comparatively much simpler on the GR and the mathematics required.

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by ars on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @05:41PM (#9607854)
> You incorrectly assume that when the star collapses there is already an event horizon

I made no such assumption. You don't need an event horizon to dilate time, just a massive gravitational field, and something resisting it.

When the sun collapses either the outer layers experience a repulsive force of some kind from below (a bounce perhaps, which is already theorized for supernovas, or maybe neutron degeneracy), or the outer layers accelerate to nearly the speed of light, either way they dilate time, and from the POV of an outside observer take an infinite amount of time to collapse.

Because of this dilation the rate of light output (as seen from outside) will drop and the sun will "turn off" - i.e. it will look [almost] identical to a black hole, except without the physics breaking singularity or event horizon.

One visible effect will be extreme red-shift of the light, which will look (to us) like a very distant object hubble-red-shifted by distance/time.

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by 4ad on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @05:50PM (#9607902)
> just a massive gravitational field

There is no massive gravitational field inside a star.

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by ars on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @06:22PM (#9608069)
In the exact center, no. But there certainly is everywhere else in the star.

After all, if there was no massive gravitational field, what's causing it to collapse? You can't have it both ways.

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by yexponential on Sunday May 31, 2015 @06:21AM (#9633744)
Thank you both for this interesting discussion, helped me grasp a few things.
Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by maxerickson on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @01:50PM (#9606341)
Astrophysicists aren't insisting that black holes have singularities on the insides (just speculating that there are objects that are well described as a gravity well with an event horizon).
Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by ars on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @02:36PM (#9606698)
Astrophysicists do not see an event horizon. All they see is massive gravity.
Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by maxerickson on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @02:40PM (#9606735)
Yeah, that's why I said "speculating", and they will also say that they are speculating, if you ask them to be careful.

(edited for clarity)

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by contravariant on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @11:29AM (#9605438)
Indeed you won't ever be able to ever see something fall into it, but when you get down to it that's just because the light will take an infinitely long time to reach you. There are coordinate systems that are able to describe stuff falling past the event horizon in finite time, you just won't be able to see this happening until you fall into it yourself.
Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by monocasa on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @11:39AM (#9605500)
My question isn't along the lines of how visible it is to an outside observer, it's more of how can a singularity itself form? It seems like you can't reach infinite density in finite time given gravitational time dilation.
Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by contravariant on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @12:11PM (#9605699)
It only takes "infinite" time in that particular coordinate system, it takes finite time in other coordinate systems, such as one where you're in orbit around the black hole.
Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by return0 on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @03:35PM (#9607107)
It takes a finite amount of proper time (time experienced by the particle) to reach the singularity.
Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by digsmahler on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @11:48AM (#9605567)
Are there such coordinate systems that "describe stuff falling bast the event horizon in finite time"? How does that not violate general relativity?
Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by btilly on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @12:14PM (#9605719)
To the first, yes. For example http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lema%C3%AEtre_coordinates is one.

To the second, when we talk about "coordinates" in GR, we're talking about parametrizing a volume of space-time. Given one parametrization, it is possible to create another parametrization that blows up at any particular spot - not because space-time is weird there - but because you picked a bad coordinate system.

The existence of parametrizations that carry through the event horizon demonstrate that the singularity at the event horizon in Schwarzschild's original metric is not a real problem for GR.

However the singularity at the middle of the black hole is a spot where GR breaks down. It is widely believed that a theory that combines GR and QM will make that singularity impossible.

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by digsmahler on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @01:04PM (#9606057)
Thank you! This will require some study.
Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by contravariant on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @12:13PM (#9605714)
According to general relativity those coordinate systems are equivalent. Well apart from the fact that the "classical" coordinate system isn't able to describe the inside of the black hole. For an example see the Kruskal coordinate system [1].

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kruskal%E2%80%93Szekeres_coord...

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by return0 on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @02:38PM (#9606721)
Matter gets added to the hole even though an outsider never sees it fall in. This should lead to the increase of the schwarzchild radius . It has been proved by Penrose that once the mass falls inside its horizon, the singularity is inevitably formed in its center: http://www.quantum-gravitation.de/media/2d2cde3ec9c38fffffff...
Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by CookieMon on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @12:27PM (#9605799)
I wouldn't think it could matter to an outside observer whether the mass inside an event horizon had converged to a point of infinite density or not, there just needs to be enough mass collapsed to an area small enough to create an event horizon.

If the outside observer were to cross the event horizon to check whether there was a singularity in the middle, they'd approach the same frame of reference, no longer be affected by the time dilation, and find the singularity.

/notaphysicist

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by monocasa on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @12:37PM (#9605865)
Sure, it doesn't matter really to an outside observer, I just threw that in to hit home the time dilation aspect.

You seem to be assuming a preexisting singularity. My question is how does that singularity get there if the compaction itself that would form the singularity continually pushes the goal post down the line?

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by CookieMon on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @12:50PM (#9605961)
No I'm not assuming a preexisting singularity, I'm assuming (possibly incorrectly) that you needn't reach infinite density for an event horizon. i.e. a singularity doesn't need to have formed, and you couldn't tell whether one had anyway.

(My thinking is that if the mass of the singularity was redistributed evenly into a small sphere in the center of the black hole, the gravitational strength around the black hole wouldn't change despite density not being infinite. However that thought experiment is newtonian thinking, not GR, so perhaps flawed)

Edit: I assume "singularities" are a red herring here and you're also thinking that as the mass approaches whatever density is required for an event horizon, time slows to zero for the outside observer so no event horizon happens either, but that would leave mass on and around the smaller-or-proto-event-horizon so you get the situation from the link guard-of-terra posted "He also said that the black-hole-with-an-essentially-undetectable-object-just-outside-its-event-horizon is a very good approximation to a black hole of a slightly larger mass.". So perhaps for outside observers, black holes are just very good approximations of black holes - unless you go in for a closer look, in which case you find they are real black holes.

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by CookieMon on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @08:52PM (#9608613)
> (My thinking is that if the mass of the singularity was redistributed evenly into a small sphere in the center of the black hole, the gravitational strength around the black hole wouldn't change despite density not being infinite. However that thought experiment is newtonian thinking, not GR, so perhaps flawed)

Update: It turns out I was describing something like the "Schwarzschild radius", confirming that in GR you don't need a singularity for a black hole - the mass just needs to be compacted into a volume smaller than a sphere of the Schwarzschild radius.

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by monocasa on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @01:29PM (#9606208)
No, singularities aren't a red herring here, they are very muchthe core of what I'm asking. I don't really care that much about the event horizon (at least for this specific question : ) ).

Imagine two neutron stars colliding and forming a black hole. Now imagine the particle inside one of these that's closest to where the singularity's point would be upon formation. How does that singularity form given that the actual compaction that creates it also continually keeps pushing the goal post farther away due to gravitational time dilation.

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by CookieMon on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @01:34PM (#9606245)
Is there any time dilation in the same reference frame as where the singularity is forming?

(I'm running on rules of thumb rather than a genuine understanding of GR: I would normally answer "no", but "frame of reference" might not be a useful concept where a singularity is forming)

It is kinda neat that the only time where a singularity has formed is contained within the place where the singluarity formed. That isn't even yo dawg.

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by dragonwriter on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @01:28PM (#9606204)
> My question is how does that singularity get there if the compaction itself that would form the singularity continually pushes the goal post down the line?

Isn't it just in the future of every particle within the event horizon (perhaps arbitrarily far from the particle's perspective, and necessarily infinitely far from any outside observer's perspective.)

Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by digsmahler on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @11:46AM (#9605548)
I've been wrestling with this same problem, and can't find a satisfying answer. One problem I have with the usual description of a black hole is that the singularity is at the center. But it seems to me that if the escape velocity is the speed of light at the Schwarzschild radius, then the singularity should be there. More of a spherical asymptote than a point mass in the center.
Re:The strange fate of a person falling into a black hole by 4ad on Tuesday May 26, 2015 @02:21PM (#9606584)