I really don't know anyone who carries on these kinds of arguments. In my experience, we code for the web most of the time, because it works and is usable by most people on most devices. Once in a while, we have a compelling reason not to. When that reason comes along, we code a native app.

It isn't a competition between platforms, and we aren't trying to make them look and act the same. We just pick the platform that offers the simplest workable solution.

Maybe I just run in a more pragmatic crowd...