Re:Balancing Multiplayer Competitive Games (2009) [pdf]
by derefr on Monday May 25, 2015 @04:21PM
(#9601571)
Where do you go, that you hear so many complaints about unbalanced matchmaking?
Tournaments and ladder systems almost automatically cause match "balance" in the way you're speaking of. Some games go further and introduce handicaps, so weaker players can play stronger players with the result not being predictable. In either case, nobody is really thinking about balance; it's just built into the social systems around the game.
The only time one might hear complaints about match "balance" is in non-competitive "casual" play. (This is actually a large part of what Nintendo's game design is about. The Smash Bros, Mario Kart, Mario Party, etc. series are all about letting people with unbalanced skill—family members, say—play casually against one-another while still having fun.)
Tournaments and ladder systems almost automatically cause match "balance" in the way you're speaking of. Some games go further and introduce handicaps, so weaker players can play stronger players with the result not being predictable. In either case, nobody is really thinking about balance; it's just built into the social systems around the game.
The only time one might hear complaints about match "balance" is in non-competitive "casual" play. (This is actually a large part of what Nintendo's game design is about. The Smash Bros, Mario Kart, Mario Party, etc. series are all about letting people with unbalanced skill—family members, say—play casually against one-another while still having fun.)