While this ignition switch mess - the lack of a recall - is clearly the result of wrongdoing, I'd say it's not characteristic. OTOH, Toyota recklessly developed software that caused loss of human life, even when well-designed examples had been on the market for years. As software isn't like hardware manufacturing, isn't that "worse?"
It may sound like I hate gm and American cars. Not at all. I've owned (currently own), and have made a living fom them. Cut my racing teeth with American v8s. I drool at corvettes, camaros, mustangs, challengers, etc. Modern and classic versions. Love them. But love won't stop me from comparing and seeing the differences.
I currently own three euro sedans and a Toyota pickup. Probably should have gotten a K1500 instead of the yota. It would rust less, withstand more abuse, and I'd be able to find parts when it did break.
The serial data link for the electronic carburetor control abomination and EFI controls is an example of the thoughtfulness that I meant. They implemented it really early, even quite earlier than the German makes I know about. It was undoubtedly priceless to have at the factory (for those cases where the factory cared - thinking on the shop floor seemed to have been a decade behind management) and would have been eminently useful in the dealership service bay if the techs had decided to make use of it.
http://projects.marketwatch.com/2014/gm-recalls-the-numbers-...
Per wikipedia: A product recall is a request to return a product after the discovery of safety issues or product defects that might endanger the consumer or put the maker/seller at risk of legal action.
The company with the highest recalls (per data provided in link above) makes great cars. Great cars that manage to kill people for the mere act of driving them normally.
So it looks like Consumer Reports' favorites are having bad times: Both Toyota and Honda had a higher share of recalls than vehicles in service for five model years.
Also for any model year until 2014, from these bargraphs it appears that GM has not had a higher percentage of recalled cars than others: 2008 may be close, 2009 beaten by Ford, 2010 by Toyota, 2011 by Toyota Honda and Chrysler, 2011 by Toyota Ford and Chrysler, 2012 by four makes, 2013 by five makes. Looks like 2014 was a sad model year for GM and do-overs.
Who are "they" and who is their management now?
The current CEO is Mary Barra. She seems to be talented and getting the firm going in the right direction, but was basically handed a shit sandwich. I wish her luck.